Opinion Best 22 - 2015

[Moe B]

Watch a Carlton 4th quarter. They're leading me to a quicker death. Actually, scrap that idea.. they also cause a great deal of pain!

Why is life so difficult? I just wana watch blues games, trade period and national draft every 2 months while I kick back doing nothing all day! Who created this work thing anyway? What an idiot! Oh yeah a nice female won't go astray..

 

[Hussey14]

Here is my new take on our best 22 for 2015.

B: Kristian Jacksch, Michael Jamison, Dylan Buckley

HB: Blaine Boekhorst, Sam Rowe, Kade Simpson

C: Sam Docherty, Chris Judd, Chris Yarran

HF: Dale Thomas, Lachie Henderson, Andrew Walker

F: Troy Menzel, Liam Jones, Levi Casboult

RK: Matthew Kreuzer, Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy

INT: Ed Curnow, Mark Whiley, Andrejs Everitt, Dillon Viojo-Rainbow

EMG: Patrick Cripps, Andrew Carrazzo, Simon White.

Really excited about this forward line and with a midfield that can hit the scoreboard.

 

[andrew_]

Here is my new take on our best 22 for 2015.

B: Kristian Jacksch, Michael Jamison, Dylan Buckley

HB: Blaine Boekhorst, Sam Rowe, Kade Simpson

C: Sam Docherty, Chris Judd, Chris Yarran

HF: Dale Thomas, Lachie Henderson, Andrew Walker

F: Troy Menzel, Liam Jones, Levi Casboult

RK: Matthew Kreuzer, Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy

INT: Ed Curnow, Mark Whiley, Andrejs Everitt, Dillon Viojo-Rainbow

EMG: Patrick Cripps, Andrew Carrazzo, Simon White

A few players stiff to not make this team include: White, Carrazzo, Tuohy, Sheehan, Tutt, Graham, Bell, Dick, and Watson.

Good lineup, but the only changes I would make at this stage would be Rainbow and Whiley out for Tutt/Graham and Bell. Other than that, thats pretty much how we should go into round 1 barring any injuries.

 

[Carl Tone]

Good lineup, but the only changes I would make at this stage would be Rainbow and Whiley out for Tutt/Graham and Bell. Other than that, thats pretty much how we should go into round 1 barring any injuries.

Yep, Whiley out and would like to see him prove himself a bit first. Boekhorst (a lucky auto in) to the wing and Doc back flank. If Graham and Bell star in the 2s but can't get into the 1s then we know the squad will be doing pretty well. Simon White will be replacing Whiley. White's fit and training hard, big body and Mick loves his aggression on the field - which we simply don't have enough of.

 

[gbatman]

KJ is one for the future, is a KPP who needs more developing as he's still a little light on, might be depth at this stage or come in against taller sides. White is a genuine back pocket, can step up to play on key position forwards and also play on medium forwards which is required for this role, not sure that KJ is up to that but I guess we may find out.

Lots of variations in teams listed, no right and wrong answers at this stage, all of them potentially good.

Hoping there are quite a few players who have been regulars of recent years unable to get a game despite being fit this year. We should have a lot of players killing it in the VFL this season as many who are unlikely to get game will be far too good for it.

Regulars who will be under pressure this season will be Carrazzo, Tuohy, Everitt, Bell, Curnow and White. Expecting irregular players like Sheehan, Buckley Cripps and Graham to be screaming out for selection with new recruits Jaksch, Boekhorst, Dick, DVR, Smith, Whiley, Tutt and possible Walsh and Byrne also pushing very hard for selection. All these players can play and more than likely will tear up the VFL if playing there. Wood included.

Watson, Casboult, Henderson and Jones are interesting as all three will be pushing really hard for games. They will all dominate the VFL. I even expect Foster to have a few moments in the VFL (good to see him listed as 196cm now). We could easily see all of them in the team as if Jamison or Rowe suffer a form slump or injury Henderson will likely go back.

Interesting times ahead. Looking forward to watching and hearing from our VFL games, if we don't have injuries there should be some talent getting about there.

 

[ShanDog]

Here is my new take on our best 22 for 2015.

B: Kristian Jacksch, Michael Jamison, Dylan Buckley

HB: Blaine Boekhorst, Sam Rowe, Kade Simpson

C: Sam Docherty, Chris Judd, Chris Yarran

HF: Dale Thomas, Lachie Henderson, Andrew Walker

F: Troy Menzel, Liam Jones, Levi Casboult

RK: Matthew Kreuzer, Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy

INT: Ed Curnow, Mark Whiley, Andrejs Everitt, Dillon Viojo-Rainbow

EMG: Patrick Cripps, Andrew Carrazzo, Simon White

Top marks for a good team and explaining it all well

You didn't really specify if your team was best 22 for round 1 or if it was a sort of 'overall for the year' best 22, but my thoughts for round one are below:

I think Cripps should be in the starting 22, probably at the expense of someone like Whiley, since we already have Curnow in the team as a number one tagger. The Coyote needs to be his backup or try to force his way into the team as a legitimate midfielder.

Also, White should be in there instead of Jaksch. For the moment, KJ needs to improve his fitness and physical size too. Won't be ready for round one. White has runs on the board and helps improve the size and physicality of the back half, particularly with SOJ, BB and Simmo in there - all light frames.

One slight change - I don't think Skittles will be ready to play in round one. Still needs a little more strength and conditioning, but has been looking pretty good in the photos during pre-season, so might not be too long of a wait! Instead, I would have Graham in there, or perhaps even Tutt in there as the sub to use his pace.

 

[TeeJay Blue]

Forgive me. I am a newbie here.

Here is my best 22
B - Simon White, Michael Jamison, Sam Rowe
HB - Kristian Jaksch, Kade Simpson, Chris Yarran
C - Sam Docherty, Bryce Gibbs, Ed Curnow
HF - Troy Menzel, Liam Jones, Dale Thomas
F - Levi Casboult, Lachie Henderson, Tom Bell
R - Matthew Kreuzer, Chris Judd, Marc Murphy
(I) - Dylan Buckley, Andrew Walker, Andrejs Everitt, Andrew Carrazzo (SUB)
E - Ciaran Sheehan, Nick Graham, Matthew Watson

Never thought that it was this hard.

Reasons Why
SIMON WHITE - To be honest, I don't see Mick Malthouse looking past him despite what impact he has, and Malthouse does not usually do this.
MICHAEL JAMISON - Well given his experience in this position, there is no doubt. He is a definite starter.
SAM ROWE - The story of last year. Age don't matter, Rowe will keep this spot for the next few years.
KRISTIAN JAKSCH - From many pictures, he might not look bulked. But with game time, we will see him become bigger & better.
KADE SIMPSON - Need I say more.
CHRIS YARRAN - Now that Betts and Garlett are gone (forwards or not), seeing him on his own is great. Last year he proved he was worth it.
SAM DOCHERTY - Docherty was a good get. There are some flaws to his game style, but his passion to perform is there.
BRYCE GIBBS - John Nicholls Medalist of 2014. Der!
ED CURNOW - Best tagger and certain starter. Many underestimate his capabilities on field. Underrated indeed. DE can be questioned. Other than that.
TROY MENZEL - Yet to become better and better. Felt bad that I doubted him. The way he kicks the ball excites me.
LIAM JONES - Give this bloke a chance. He might do wonders for this team. Just wait and see.
DALE THOMAS - He is getting better. I don't think at all it was a waste of money. He'll show some more this year.
LEVI CASBOULT - His kicking style has improved. But he tends to play better in patches. I'm sure we will see him playing better on a regular basis.
LACHIE HENDERSON - Our go-to man in terms of goal kicking. Losing Fevola did hurt but getting this guy made up for it (in my opinion).
TOM BELL - After that match against Gold Coast last year, I can't see why he shouldn't be in the team.
MATTHEW KREUZER - First ruckman. But if he struggles, we always have Wood as back-up.
CHRIS JUDD - Most likely his last year of football. Let him make the most of it and walk out in best way possible.
MARC MURPHY - Skipper. Leader. Somebody to lead the team out. He just needs to remember to work on his game as well (which I'm sure he does).
DYLAN BUCKLEY - The history says it all. This player still has much to learn, but his passion and will to give it his all is there.
ANDREW WALKER - Forward or back, he does his job. I just get that feeling that the club is losing him. He might retire eventually.
ANDREJS EVERITT - Another keeper. Before injuring his PCL, he was an awesome fit into the team. Does his job and does it well.
ANDREW CARRAZZO - Approaching his end. Taking pressure of him by making him sub. Bleeds blue, but don't know how much more he can give.

CIARAN SHEEHAN - Still needs more time in VFL. Sooner or later, we will see him with more to show.
NICK GRAHAM - Hard to fit him in, so he is a definite replacement for anyone in the team.
MATTHEW WATSON - I still see hope for him. The last game of 2014 became the reason why.

The Others
TUOHY was quite disappointing last year. If it was an injury, then I would understand. If he can get back in form like that of the 2013 season, he is in. But who he would replace is the question.
Another Malthouse likes in ELLARD, is questionable. I like him in the team, but his calf troubles are concerning.

Just because CRIPPS & BOEKHORST were Carlton's recent top draft picks, it does not mean that they are certain starters. Who knows, a pick 62 can be better than a pick 12. Where they sit in the draft doesn't matter. It is how they prove themselves in the preseason (and without a doubt, they are doing so). Last time I saw CRIPPS play, he was pretty ordinary. But I suppose game time comes with improvement. I'm sure they will become good for us in a matter of time. But at the moment there are quite a few ahead of them. With who is most likely to not see the following season (ARMFIELD, WARNOCK, GILES (unfortunate), FIELDS (judging from now) (unfortunate), JUDD, CARRAZZO, etc.) they are a good chance to become regulars in 2016.

As for the rest (ARMFIELD, GOWERS, FIELDS, HOLMAN, TUTT, SMITH, BYRNE, WARNOCK, JOHNSON, FOSTER, VIOJO-RAINBOW, WHILEY, WOOD, RUSSELL, DICK & WALSH), some will need to prove themselves, and others are always there when the team needs them.

 

[Bluejob]

Nice first post NBTJ35. I'd agree with your team for the most part.

On a side note. I have been getting confused with some posts lately. Are we putting forth our best 22? (ie; a team comprising the best 22 players to take the field/positions to win a game), or are we putting forward a 22 with players we think will be good in the future cos they are young and got recruited and we have rose tinted glasses?

Some sides have multiple players who have played zero games. If the CFC is at a point where 2+ recruits with zero AFL experience are better placed to take the field as our very best 22, then we are in considerable trouble.

 

[TeeJay Blue]

Nice first post NBTJ35. I'd agree with your team for the most part.

On a side note. I have been getting confused with some posts lately. Are we putting forth our best 22? (ie; a team comprising the best 22 players to take the field/positions to win a game), or are we putting forward a 22 with players we think will be good in the future cos they are young and got recruited and we have rose tinted glasses?

Some sides have multiple players who have played zero games. If the CFC is at a point where 2+ recruits with zero AFL experience are better placed to take the field as our very best 22, then we are in considerable trouble.

Thank You!

Well I have posted the best 22 to walk out in round 1 (if fully fit). But it is quite hard to do so having seen a glimpse of young and/or inexperienced talent.
The way I should see it, is that there is no such thing as a best 22. Every player is capable of making round 1 (unless they are not an elevated rookie, which I am still confused of that given Wood's debut for us against North Melbourne). I do happen to pick by game experience and who had excited me last year.
It is hard not to disappoint, given those that I have excluded.

Those such as BUCKLEY, MENZEL, CURNOW, GRAHAM, BELL, DOCHERTY & EVERITT, had drawn me into watching the team more last year (even when the team was not going so well), as they had show glimpses of being a dangerous player to their opponents.

 

[thylacine60]

Forgive me. I am a newbie here.

Classic opening line!

 

[huddler]

White offers mongrel too. It's an oldie, but imo it's vital. I look around our list and despite seeing good footballers everywhere, I don't see the gritty, love-the-taste-of-a-bust-lip kind of players. Maybe I'm just missing Heath Scotland.

 

[King of Ruin]

Classic opening line!

They've been saying this since back in your day..

 

[thylacine60]

but no-one forgives.......

 

[Blue By Blood]

Top marks for a good team and explaining it all well

You didn't really specify if your team was best 22 for round 1 or if it was a sort of 'overall for the year' best 22, but my thoughts for round one are below:

I think Cripps should be in the starting 22, probably at the expense of someone like Whiley, since we already have Curnow in the team as a number one tagger. The Coyote needs to be his backup or try to force his way into the team as a legitimate midfielder.

Also, White should be in there instead of Jaksch. For the moment, KJ needs to improve his fitness and physical size too. Won't be ready for round one. White has runs on the board and helps improve the size and physicality of the back half, particularly with SOJ, BB and Simmo in there - all light frames.

One slight change - I don't think Skittles will be ready to play in round one. Still needs a little more strength and conditioning, but has been looking pretty good in the photos during pre-season, so might not be too long of a wait! Instead, I would have Graham in there, or perhaps even Tutt in there as the sub to use his pace.

The team I picked probably isn't theoretically our best 22 (otherwise guys like Carrazzo would be in) but rather a team picked to give hope to the supporters, generate some excitement, and build for the future. So mainly it's how I'd like us to line up more than an actual best 22, although it's close.

Cripps is behind Whiley in development. I would see Whiley starting ahead of him to be honest. As much as I would love to see Cripps in the team from the start, I can't see it happening. Also I read an article talking to McKay where he said that Cripps is behind a few of the other boys in development. He will get games this year, just not in my starting team for now.

Jacksch got the spot ahead of White because of his huge upside. We are not going to bring a 3rd year player (1st round draft pick across to spend most of his time in the twos). Yes he is skinnier. Yes he is not as developed physically as White. He will be the one player we pick ahead of his time with two eyes on the long term picture.

I agree on DVR. He was picked mainly for balance reasons to create a team that has the perfect amount of inside and outside players. That is why if he's not picked I think Tutt is. I can't see Graham fitting in the team I picked without disrupting the balance of inside to outside ratio.

Will this team I picked win many games.. the answer is not clear. We may surprise and push for the finals or we may finish with a half dozen wins. What I do know though is that that team I picked on paper is damn exciting and will generate much hope and excitement for our supporter base going forward. For the first time in ages we are actually in a position to embrace our youth (we finally have quality youth) rather than play depth guys like White to keep us competitive. We may suffer a couple of extra losses as a result but it's the smart way for us to go heading forwards to number 17! That's just my thoughts.

 

[the conch]

Forgive me. I am a newbie here.

Here is my best 22
B - Simon White, Michael Jamison, Sam Rowe
HB - Kristian Jaksch, Kade Simpson, Chris Yarran
C - Sam Docherty, Bryce Gibbs, Ed Curnow
HF - Troy Menzel, Liam Jones, Dale Thomas
F - Levi Casboult, Lachie Henderson, Tom Bell
R - Matthew Kreuzer, Chris Judd, Marc Murphy
(I) - Dylan Buckley, Andrew Walker, Andrejs Everitt, Andrew Carrazzo (SUB)
E - Ciaran Sheehan, Nick Graham, Matthew Watson

Never thought that it was this hard.

Reasons Why
SIMON WHITE - To be honest, I don't see Mick Malthouse looking past him despite what impact he has, and Malthouse does not usually do this.
MICHAEL JAMISON - Well given his experience in this position, there is no doubt. He is a definite starter.
SAM ROWE - The story of last year. Age don't matter, Rowe will keep this spot for the next few years.
KRISTIAN JAKSCH - From many pictures, he might not look bulked. But with game time, we will see him become bigger & better.
KADE SIMPSON - Need I say more.
CHRIS YARRAN - Now that Betts and Garlett are gone (forwards or not), seeing him on his own is great. Last year he proved he was worth it.
SAM DOCHERTY - Docherty was a good get. There are some flaws to his game style, but his passion to perform is there.
BRYCE GIBBS - John Nicholls Medalist of 2014. Der!
ED CURNOW - Best tagger and certain starter. Many underestimate his capabilities on field. Underrated indeed. DE can be questioned. Other than that.
TROY MENZEL - Yet to become better and better. Felt bad that I doubted him. The way he kicks the ball excites me.
LIAM JONES - Give this bloke a chance. He might do wonders for this team. Just wait and see.
DALE THOMAS - He is getting better. I don't think at all it was a waste of money. He'll show some more this year.
LEVI CASBOULT - His kicking style has improved. But he tends to play better in patches. I'm sure we will see him playing better on a regular basis.
LACHIE HENDERSON - Our go-to man in terms of goal kicking. Losing Fevola did hurt but getting this guy made up for it (in my opinion).
TOM BELL - After that match against Gold Coast last year, I can't see why he shouldn't be in the team.
MATTHEW KREUZER - First ruckman. But if he struggles, we always have Wood as back-up.
CHRIS JUDD - Most likely his last year of football. Let him make the most of it and walk out in best way possible.
MARC MURPHY - Skipper. Leader. Somebody to lead the team out. He just needs to remember to work on his game as well (which I'm sure he does).
DYLAN BUCKLEY - The history says it all. This player still has much to learn, but his passion and will to give it his all is there.
ANDREW WALKER - Forward or back, he does his job. I just get that feeling that the club is losing him. He might retire eventually.
ANDREJS EVERITT - Another keeper. Before injuring his PCL, he was an awesome fit into the team. Does his job and does it well.
ANDREW CARRAZZO - Approaching his end. Taking pressure of him by making him sub. Bleeds blue, but don't know how much more he can give.

CIARAN SHEEHAN - Still needs more time in VFL. Sooner or later, we will see him with more to show.
NICK GRAHAM - Hard to fit him in, so he is a definite replacement for anyone in the team.
MATTHEW WATSON - I still see hope for him. The last game of 2014 became the reason why.

The Others
TUOHY was quite disappointing last year. If it was an injury, then I would understand. If he can get back in form like that of the 2013 season, he is in. But who he would replace is the question.
Another Malthouse likes in ELLARD, is questionable. I like him in the team, but his calf troubles are concerning.

Just because CRIPPS & BOEKHORST were Carlton's recent top draft picks, it does not mean that they are certain starters. Who knows, a pick 62 can be better than a pick 12. Where they sit in the draft doesn't matter. It is how they prove themselves in the preseason (and without a doubt, they are doing so). Last time I saw CRIPPS play, he was pretty ordinary. But I suppose game time comes with improvement. I'm sure they will become good for us in a matter of time. But at the moment there are quite a few ahead of them. With who is most likely to not see the following season (ARMFIELD, WARNOCK, GILES (unfortunate), FIELDS (judging from now) (unfortunate), JUDD, CARRAZZO, etc.) they are a good chance to become regulars in 2016.

As for the rest (ARMFIELD, GOWERS, FIELDS, HOLMAN, TUTT, SMITH, BYRNE, WARNOCK, JOHNSON, FOSTER, VIOJO-RAINBOW, WHILEY, WOOD, RUSSELL, DICK & WALSH), some will need to prove themselves, and others are always there when the team needs them.

Jones 'd be better on flank or pocket imo

 

[Stig O'Hara]

but no-one forgives.......

Little Baby Jesus does.

 

[thylacine60]

When he's not going postal on the temple traders..........

 

[thylacine60]

can I get a witness?

 

[Stig O'Hara]

When he's not going postal on the temple traders..........

Sedition is a bitch.

He don't talk too much, all the same, and he's had 2000 years.

 

[CFCtragic]

Using 3B's template I've decided to have a go at picking my best 22 for next year. Maybe some of my selections are a bit left field but I'll explain them below.

B: Kade Simpson, Michael Jamison, Dylan Buckley
Kristian Jaksch
HB: Andrew Walker, Sam Rowe, Simon White

C: Andrejs Everitt, Patrick Cripps, Chris Judd,

HF: Troy Menzel, Lachie Henderson, Sam Docherty
F: Liam Jones, Levi Casboult

RK: Matthew Kreuzer, Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy

INT: Mark Whiley,Dale Thomas , Chris Yarran SUB: as needed


Defensive Selections – Explained:
Upon reviewing our games from last year, it became appartent to me that our transition game and midfield turn overs were the two areas that needed to improve the most for us to become competitive with the top 4 teams. In my opinion while our defense is strong defensively they are poor at offense running and covering each other. Many of our "midfield" turnovers came about form the backline not carrying the ball and kicking shallowly to contested situations.

I am also a fan of a spare man in defense. While I think that it has limited use as a defensive ploy, I think that it works well as an offensive ploy to help with a teams transition game.

Kade, jamo, 1AW, Sam and Whitey pick them selves as our lock down defensive unit.

Jacksch: This is Jaksch 3rd season and reviewing his GWS games he looks to have all the attributes that you would expect form an offensive spare man in defense, good height, good run and carry, good speed and good disposal. Additionally he adds flexability to the side as he, Hendo, DOC, Andrejs and 1AW can all swap forward - back.

Buckley: In my opinion once young Buckley was injured last year, our run and carry took a significant hit. Probably because 1AW was also injured, but we just didn't have that explosiveness from the back half anymore. So bucks gets my nod for this role.

Rucks Selections – Explained:

Completely agree with 3B: Kruz, Gibba and Murph says it all

Midfield Selections – Explained:
All of these guys offer a difficult matchup for the opposition, Good disposal and fantastic skills, having targets like these while streaming out from defense will provide options top the defensive unit. Additionally all of them are good extractors of the ball.

Judd: Still too good to be left out of the midfield, but at this stage of his career I'd rather someone be handing the ball off to him that see him on the bottom of the pack everytime, so out to the wing he goes.

Andrejs: was great for us last year until he got injured, he provides a strong marking target, and is particurly hard to man up on in the midfield due to his exceptional tank.

Cripps: I saw a few NB games last year and honestly at times this guy was simply untouchable. I don't think that he has much to learn in the 2's and I think that he can provide some much needed grunt to the side. He is also very hard to matchup on and uses his height well to provide a marking option when needed.

Forward Selections – Explained:
Henderson: Our CHF. Enough said.

Jones: All reports are that he will be leading out of the goal square for the Blues in 2015. Needs to grab this second chance and provide defensive pressure or could find himself out of the team for Watson, White, or even Foster.

Casboult: Dangerous third tall with a high tank. Looks to have slimmed down and can run further up the ground this year. Could be set for a big year.

Menzel: So much class around goals. Will get some midfield minutes but majority of time will be up forward. Look forward to seeing continued improvement from him this year.

DOC: Doc just seems to have a knack for a goal and to be fair I really see him and Yaz making the transition to the midfield this year by rotating through the HFF. Helps a lot that both of them can be very dangeorus up forward.

Bench – Explained:
Unfortunately for some of our older players, there is no room for poor disposal if we are going to cut down on turnovers and transition from middle tier to consistent top eight competitor. So some of my favorites (like Ed and Bell) have been left out.

Whiley: Completely agree with 3B, he is physically ready to play significant minutes in 2015. More developed than Cripps and more talented than Bell. The fact that he can also tag means that players such as Carrots and Ed miss out. This team has two tagging options with Andrejs and Whiley so this is no longer a skill that will get players with poor to average disposal into the side.

Yaz and Daisy: Midfield rotation

 

[the conch]

Using 3B's template I've decided to have a go at picking my best 22 for next year. Maybe some of my selections are a bit left field but I'll explain them below.

B: Kade Simpson, Michael Jamison, Dylan Buckley
Kristian Jaksch
HB: Andrew Walker, Sam Rowe, Simon White

C: Andrejs Everitt, Patrick Cripps, Chris Judd,

HF: Troy Menzel, Lachie Henderson, Sam Docherty
F: Liam Jones, Levi Casboult

RK: Matthew Kreuzer, Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy

INT: Mark Whiley,Dale Thomas , Chris Yarran SUB: as needed


Defensive Selections – Explained:
Upon reviewing our games from last year, it became appartent to me that our transition game and midfield turn overs were the two areas that needed to improve the most for us to become competitive with the top 4 teams. In my opinion while our defense is strong defensively they are poor at offense running and covering each other. Many of our "midfield" turnovers came about form the backline not carrying the ball and kicking shallowly to contested situations.

I am also a fan of a spare man in defense. While I think that it has limited use as a defensive ploy, I think that it works well as an offensive ploy to help with a teams transition game.

Kade, jamo, 1AW, Sam and Whitey pick them selves as our lock down defensive unit.

Jacksch: This is Jaksch 3rd season and reviewing his GWS games he looks to have all the attributes that you would expect form an offensive spare man in defense, good height, good run and carry, good speed and good disposal. Additionally he adds flexability to the side as he, Hendo, DOC, Andrejs and 1AW can all swap forward - back.

Buckley: In my opinion once young Buckley was injured last year, our run and carry took a significant hit. Probably because 1AW was also injured, but we just didn't have that explosiveness from the back half anymore. So bucks gets my nod for this role.

Rucks Selections – Explained:

Completely agree with 3B: Kruz, Gibba and Murph says it all

Midfield Selections – Explained:
All of these guys offer a difficult matchup for the opposition, Good disposal and fantastic skills, having targets like these while streaming out from defense will provide options top the defensive unit. Additionally all of them are good extractors of the ball.

Judd: Still too good to be left out of the midfield, but at this stage of his career I'd rather someone be handing the ball off to him that see him on the bottom of the pack everytime, so out to the wing he goes.

Andrejs: was great for us last year until he got injured, he provides a strong marking target, and is particurly hard to man up on in the midfield due to his exceptional tank.

Cripps: I saw a few NB games last year and honestly at times this guy was simply untouchable. I don't think that he has much to learn in the 2's and I think that he can provide some much needed grunt to the side. He is also very hard to matchup on and uses his height well to provide a marking option when needed.

Forward Selections – Explained:
Henderson: Our CHF. Enough said.

Jones: All reports are that he will be leading out of the goal square for the Blues in 2015. Needs to grab this second chance and provide defensive pressure or could find himself out of the team for Watson, White, or even Foster.

Casboult: Dangerous third tall with a high tank. Looks to have slimmed down and can run further up the ground this year. Could be set for a big year.

Menzel: So much class around goals. Will get some midfield minutes but majority of time will be up forward. Look forward to seeing continued improvement from him this year.

DOC: Doc just seems to have a knack for a goal and to be fair I really see him and Yaz making the transition to the midfield this year by rotating through the HFF. Helps a lot that both of them can be very dangeorus up forward.

Bench – Explained:
Unfortunately for some of our older players, there is no room for poor disposal if we are going to cut down on turnovers and transition from middle tier to consistent top eight competitor. So some of my favorites (like Ed and Bell) have been left out.

Whiley: Completely agree with 3B, he is physically ready to play significant minutes in 2015. More developed than Cripps and more talented than Bell. The fact that he can also tag means that players such as Carrots and Ed miss out. This team has two tagging options with Andrejs and Whiley so this is no longer a skill that will get players with poor to average disposal into the side.

Yaz and Daisy: Midfield rotation

Tutt is a great offensive running player. Fast and straight ahead. Game breaker type player.

 

[ferrisb]

Tutt is a great offensive running player. Fast and straight ahead. Game breaker type player.

Don't need then. Last year showed our game was already broken

 

[thylacine60]

cardable

 

[broome_blue1]

I believe our list is in 10 - 20% better shape this year compared to last. That % increase would see us possibly increasing our ladder position between 1.8 and 3.6 places giving hypothetical range of approximatley 8th-10th. Wouldnt be unhappy with that as in my view the serious strides will come 2016 onwards.

 

[ShanDog]

I believe our list is in 10 - 20% better shape this year compared to last. That % increase would see us possibly increasing our ladder position between 1.8 and 3.6 places giving hypothetical range of approximatley 8th-10th. Wouldnt be unhappy with that as in my view the serious strides will come 2016 onwards.

YOUR SCIENCE ISN'T WELCOME HERE!!