Bigfooty Megathread: Who has been the best recruit of 2014?

[Fitzey]

So Basically you have 7 days to vote for the top 5 recruits of season 2014. Must be traded to the club i.e: Dom Tyson.

Voting will go like this.

1: =5 points
2: =4 points
3: =3 points
4: =2 points
5: =1 point

My votes:
5 votes: Lance Franklin
4 votes: Eddie Betts
3 votes: Dom Tyson
2 votes: Nick Dal Santo
1 votes: Matt White

 

[SterlingArcher]

For about 8 rounds it wasn't Franklin. And then it was Franklin.

5. Lance Franklin




4. Dom Tyson
3. Eddie Betts
2. Paul Chapman
1. Nick Dal Santo

 

[I Lost My Keays]

5. Franklin
4. Betts
3. Tyson
2. Dal Santo
1. Chappy

 

[clogged]

Colin Sylvia

 

[DardySingh360]

5: Franklin
4: Yeo
3. Dal Santo
2. Matt White
1. Chapman

 

[Hank Scorpion]

5. Lance Franklin
4. Dom Tyson
3. Paul Chapman
2. Shane Mumford
1. Nick Dal Santo

 

[Kakkle]

5 votes: Lance Franklin
4 votes: Eddie Betts
3 votes: Paul Chapman
2 votes: Nick Dal Santo
1 votes: Anthony Miles

 

[eth-dog]

5. Sylvia
4. Thomas
3. Nahas
2. Armstrong
1. McGuane

Seriously though:

5. Franklin
4. Betts
3. Tyson
2. Chapman
1. White

HM: Dal Santo, Laidler, Mumford

 

[Engimal]

Franklin.

 

[ThisIsJake]

1. Nicky Dal
2. Buddy
3. Tyson
4. Mummy
5. Betts

 

[ninja_lion]

1 votes: Anthony Miles

I'm not sure Miles was traded. I thought he was actually delisted by GWS. Good nomination otherwise though.

 

[Freomaniac]

5. Lance Franklin (Easily)
4. Eddie Betts (crows needed some X factor and betts provided)
3. Bernie Vince (yeah the demons only got 4 wins but he did will in each of them)
2. Jared Polec (1st half of season was very good.)
1. Nic Dal Santo (Saints should of kept him)

 

[joop]

1. Nic Dal Santo (Saints should of kept him)

Interested to hear why? We used the pick on Billy Longer which turned out to be an extremely good move as Hickey was injured most of the year.

 

[hench]

1. Jared Polec
2. Elliot Yeo
3. Sam Docherty
4. Billy Longer
5. Patrick Karnezis

 

[Bender571]

Colin Sylvia

Agreed, every club needs a quality whipping boy

 

[betterthanu]

5: Franklin
4: Polec
3: Betts
2: Tyson
1: Vince

 

[Super Hans]

5. Franklin
4. Betts
3. Miles
2. Tyson
1. Polec

 

[Freomaniac]

Interested to hear why? We used the pick on Billy Longer which turned out to be an extremely good move as Hickey was injured most of the year.

He wanted to be with the saints for his whole playing career. He only left because North offered him a better contract with more money and longer years. I do rate him during that Period when the saints were good from 2008-2011.

It would of been more beneficial to the saints if he stayed at the saints for 2-3 more years while your players aged under 21-24 develop. At least if he left the saints by the end of 2015, the kids at your team would be better. Dal Santo was a hardened body and a quality mid, not a list clogger.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

5 posts before anyone mentioned Mumford.

For shame.

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

5. Franklin
4. Polec
3. Mumford
2. Betts
1. Dal Santo.

 

[La Dispute]

5. Dale Thomas
4. Andrejs Everitt
3. Sam Docherty
2. Anthony Miles
1. Dom Tyson

 

[Xtreme]

Dayle Garlett!

 

[coniglio_number1]

5: Shane Mumford
4: Heath shaw
3: josh hunt
2: Jed lamb
1: Dylan Addison

 

[Damon_3388]

1. Lance Franklin (Sydney)
2. Shane Mumford (GWS)
3. Eddie Betts (Adelaide)
4. Nick Dal Santo (North Melbourne)
5. Paul Chapman (Essendon)

 

[rocker_oz33]

Eddie big pants Betts been huge for the Crows! People were saying he not worth hes price tag He's been super value for them.Hes kick to big truck was super first a first year player at the club to dish of a goal to a club fav like truck well played Eddie.