List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

[Soapy V]

What's happened to Lemmey? I heard he wasnt too far off the mark. TBH, given the form of our seniors, I'd be rolling the dice and giving him a game if not injured.

Was good yesterday. Close to his best game.

I still don’t think he’s close to being ready yet. Pity O’Keefe isn’t fit as I’d play him. He would mentally handle it

 

[Aphrodite]

What would be the motivator to extend him on his output.

Carlton seems to have zero performance management

Sent from my SM-N981B using Tapatalk

It’s a rumour.

Chill.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Would we trade Jack Carroll for Harry Edwards?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Would we trade Jack Carroll for Harry Edwards?

In a heartbeat. Edwards would be far more valuable though as a promising young KPP

 

[Beyond Blue]

Would we trade Jack Carroll for Harry Edwards?

Yes but West Coast would never agree to that deal. I was at Friday nights game and whilst he wasn’t great in the night he moved very well for a player his size. I was thinking while I was watching he’d be a great pick up for us. I wouldn’t be against trading our first to get him.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Yes but West Coast would never agree to that deal. I was at Friday nights game and whilst he wasn’t great in the night he moved very well for a player his size. I was thinking while I was watching he’d be a great pick up for us. I wouldn’t be against trading our first to get him.

Quite liked the look of Jack Williams for them too. Could be a swingman type pick up

 

[swuzzlebubble]

I wouldn’t be against trading our first to get him.

That seems high to me after a bit of due diligence

 

[Prem17]

Geez Dan Houston or Miles Bergman would be a great get this off season!

I mentioned Houston a couple of months ago and got fed to the lions.
Going alright though for a bloke that apparently can't offer us anything!

 

[frank_frankson]

Yes but West Coast would never agree to that deal. I was at Friday nights game and whilst he wasn’t great in the night he moved very well for a player his size. I was thinking while I was watching he’d be a great pick up for us. I wouldn’t be against trading our first to get him.

Would West Coast entertain the trade, considering Barrass is all but gone McGovern is best mates with their physio, might end up costing too much to snag?

On SM-A536E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[katmanblue]

People have short memories re Walsh. He is curtailed by injury, thats obvious, even though he is out there. We saw from the bye onwards last year how good he was, and was player of the finals series last year too.

We need to get the back issues sorted out with him, that is the issue. Guy is an out and out gun when he is fully right.

It's mostly decision making which injury doesn't cover.

On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

It's mostly decision making which injury doesn't cover.

On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app

When you're hindered and out of form your decision making is effected. We know Walshy's best is elite, just need to get him back to it.

 

[Beyond Blue]

Would West Coast entertain the trade, considering Barrass is all but gone McGovern is best mates with their physio, might end up costing too much to snag?

On SM-A536E using BigFooty.com mobile app

I highly doubt it. Edwards looks like he’s a big part of their future plans. That’s why I think the trade cost will be so high.

 

[JamisonRun40]

Between him and Cunningham the backline is in dire need for some new blood. Could we look at Barass coming to the blues.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Between him and Cunningham the backline is in dire need for some new blood. Could we look at Barass coming to the blues.

He'd be awesome. We couldn't afford the asking price though.

 

[branedotorg]

It can't be overstated how much our midfielders sell our defenders into constant trouble. They remind me of Lemmings. As a consequence, the backline is constantly under the pump. Defense starts up the field.

That's it, defence in modern football is a whole team structure, when the midfield is allowing unpressured entries, of course our defenders look second rate.

Far too often, we see our defenders having to choose between closing down the ball and staying with their man - yet I don't feel like we generate that kind of offensive overlap and outnumber as often as we suffer from it.

Both are symptoms of Oppo midfields beating ours.

 

[Arr0w]

That seems high to me after a bit of due diligence

I'd trade our 1st in a heart beat

 

[DangerousD]

I mentioned Houston a couple of months ago and got fed to the lions.
Going alright though for a bloke that apparently can't offer us anything!

I’m sure you were fed to the lions as you say because, Houston is a great player, is contracted and plays a position we are relatively covered for.

Houston would be fantastic for us, he would improve us but he will cost over $700,000 and would cost our first rounder and then some.

And if we did that, we still wouldn’t have addressed our two biggest areas of need in KPD and pace

 

[Prem17]

I’m sure you were fed to the lions as you say because, Houston is a great player, is contracted and plays a position we are relatively covered for.

Houston would be fantastic for us, he would improve us but he will cost over $700,000 and would cost our first rounder and then some.

And if we did that, we still wouldn’t have addressed our two biggest areas of need in KPD and pace

I used him as an example of better disposal after yet another woeful kicking display, maybe the first Geelong game?

 

[DangerousD]

He'd be awesome. We couldn't afford the asking price though.

Ok I’ve thought it, many have posted it, lets put it out there, why couldn’t we?


We supposedly offered Hayward a big deal, would they not be comparable? Even if he was slightly more, do we not have options to make room?

Tom turns 29 this year, so he wont command a huge trade price, we currently have pick 11, id suggest that’s even slight overs for a 29 year old who has some slight injury concerns.

 

[Blue Pulse]

Because stats.

30 of the most inconsequential possessions you’ve ever seen.

Worst #1 pick since all our other ordinary #1 picks.

Wow, this is almost and I say almost as good as the "trade Cripps" talk a few years back when he was carrying an injury.

Might want to review some of his past performances, a lot more good than bad.

Playing under duress at the moment and probably should have been thrown out onto a wing to prevent him being busted up on the inside

 

[The Return of the Paf]

That seems high to me after a bit of due diligence

It smacks of desperation; is he even that good apart from being tall?

 

[RAPPA]

Wow, this is almost and I say almost as good as the "trade Cripps" talk a few years back when he was carrying an injury.

Might want to review some of his past performances, a lot more good than bad.

Playing under duress at the moment and probably should have been thrown out onto a wing to prevent him being busted up on the inside

Agree that a position change is needed. But he also tries to burst through tackles and gets caught far too often. Walshy needs to understand that he ain’t no Crippa which is perfectly fine as he has other elite skills that he and the team are better off exploiting.

 

[The Sultan]

watching the hawks over last few weeks... Connor MacDonald would be super handy right now.. the Blues were keen on him, but hawks took him one picj before us.

 

[Blue Pulse]

Agree that a position change is needed. But he also tries to burst through tackles and gets caught far too often. Walshy needs to understand that he ain’t no Crippa which is perfectly fine as he has other elite skills that he and the team are better off exploiting.

He needs to get away from the hustle and bustle of the midfield until his mind knows what his banged up body can do. He can obviously still run but needs to know his limitations.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

It smacks of desperation; is he even that good apart from being tall?

I'd assume there's better options that could be got for less than first round pick.