Player Watch Brayden Sier (Delisted 2021)

[Saintly Viewed]

I've heard it's all a misunderstanding. Other coaches told Bucks to never pick Blair again. He misheard it as never pick Bear again.

They are same same in size, but different

 

[CFC2010]

so like Swanny.

IF you are a Gun you can get away with a lot more then?

Spot on Dave...…….but the penny has finally dropped for Jordan now its Brayden's turn.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

In my opinion he is in the non-tradeable bracket. Such a big fan of this kid, will grow to be the focal point of our midfield over the next 2-4 years.

Over the last few years I had serious concerns about what happens to our midfield over the next few years when the older heads like Pendlebury Mayne Greenwood, Beams and Sidey (29/28 respectively) all start to slow down but Sier has removed that fear.

I know we have Adams and Treloar, but Sier is in the younger bracket below them and along with Phillips DeGoey Maynard and the young ones like the Browns he is center to our new generation of core midfielders.

While, I don't necessarily disagree with your point, I think the club knows a bit more.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Left training early, Bucks says he's got a rib issue that he's been battling this week that is affecting breathing, so unlikely for VFL this week.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Bucks at the presser was asked why Sier left the ground early today.

He responded with “he has bit of a rub issue. He’s been struggling to breathe atm. I’ll let you know when the Scotts get back to me. Doubtful for the VFL this weekend”.

Not good.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Left training early, Bucks says he's got a rib issue that he's been battling this week that is affecting breathing, so unlikely for VFL this week.

Jinx.

 

[Johno9911]

Considering he is out of contract at the end of this season, it might not be up to us.

Very good point mate. Hopefully he can see that being patient will have it benefits and that he should spend the next period of time trying to learn as much as he can from the older mids while their still around.

 

[Anzacday]

I’ll let you know when the Scotts get back to me

Hope it's Brad, Chris is interstate.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Not Forgotten Man by Collingwood Fans

The actual forgotten man is Tim Broomhead!! Welcome back son

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Left training early, Bucks says he's got a rib issue that he's been battling this week that is affecting breathing, so unlikely for VFL this week.

It can’t be injury. Injury is a boring story. He’s out due to attitude!!!!!

 

[unplugged]

 

[TradeDraft]

Spot on Dave...…….but the penny has finally dropped for Jordan now its Brayden's turn.

Hopefully Jordan can help Sier out

 

[Saintly Viewed]

The actual forgotten man is Tim Broomhead!! Welcome back son

He was swept under the carpet...

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Will the Hyphen has an injury, he’ll be back.

Brayden has an injury he’ll be back.

It’s a long season and let’s be a little patient for the patient.

 

[regpies]

IF he does not then trading him be well and Truly be on the Cards

I don’t think trading him is a smart option.

Needs to work on a couple things but us trading him has the potential to be similar to Kennedy leaving Hawthorn. They didn’t have room for him in their midfield and he became a star at the Swans

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I don’t think trading him is a smart option.

Needs to work on a couple things but us trading him has the potential to be similar to Kennedy leaving Hawthorn. They didn’t have room for him in their midfield and he became a star at the Swans

Let’s not give good players away.

There’s enough medium talent for Sier to surpass.
Plenty of room.

 

[Gaben]

Fighting Jesse Hogan when he was out on the froffs last Friday?

 

[RGpies]

Hopefully this week off he will require due to his ribs will give him a light bulb moment that just because it all happened for him last year, it isn’t guaranteed this year; and will give him some fire in the belly to find back his form

 

[Mark W]

In my opinion he is in the non-tradeable bracket. Such a big fan of this kid, will grow to be the focal point of our midfield over the next 2-4 years.

Over the last few years I had serious concerns about what happens to our midfield over the next few years when the older heads like Pendlebury Mayne Greenwood, Beams and Sidey (29/28 respectively) all start to slow down but Sier has removed that fear.

I know we have Adams and Treloar, but Sier is in the younger bracket below them and along with Phillips DeGoey Maynard and the young ones like the Browns he is center to our new generation of core midfielders.

All very good points, but here is a counter-argument - devil's advocate if you will.

I should say before I start, that I rate Sier very highly. But Ive never been a punter who equates trading a player with thinking they are no good. On the contrary if you want to get something good, you have to give up something good....

Ok so here is the argument...

2019 goes pretty similar to 2018. We have a terrific year, get bloody close again, our midfield is terrific, our small forwards deadly, our defence cohesive. We go deep into September once more but but once again our lack of key position strength costs us in the finals. The clock is ticking on our premiership window. Pendles, Sidey and Beamsy are all veterans. Our time is now. So how are we going to get a plug n play key position player to boost our chances in 2020? Now in that scenario, wouldn't trading away a kid for a ready made key position player make sense?

 

[grayza2018]

The rib thing doesn't sound too flash. A solid 3-5 weeks in the VFL replicating last year's VFL run and he'll be back up there I reckon. Still a step down from thinking he'd be 2 extra games into his AFL career by now..

 

[Saintly Viewed]

All very good points, but here is a counter-argument - devil's advocate if you will.

I should say before I start, that I rate Sier very highly. But Ive never been a punter who equates trading a player with thinking they are no good. On the contrary if you want to get something good, you have to give up something good....

Ok so here is the argument...

2019 goes pretty similar to 2018. We have a terrific year, get bloody close again, our midfield is terrific, our small forwards deadly, our defence cohesive. We go deep into September once more but but once again our lack of key position strength costs us in the finals. The clock is ticking on our premiership window. Pendles, Sidey and Beamsy are all veterans. Our time is now. So how are we going to get a plug n play key position player to boost our chances in 2020? Now in that scenario, wouldn't trading away a kid for a ready made key position player make sense?

But if we trade anyone good for a key position it better be a good one not another average one

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Hm....so ribs

Would explain his struggles I guess. Hope he recovers quick, we need him out there

 

[Antz]

I'm just glad he hasn't gone off the rails and hoping he can make a speedy recovery and start pushing for a spot soon.

 

[Gone Critical]

All very good points, but here is a counter-argument - devil's advocate if you will.

I should say before I start, that I rate Sier very highly. But Ive never been a punter who equates trading a player with thinking they are no good. On the contrary if you want to get something good, you have to give up something good....

Ok so here is the argument...

2019 goes pretty similar to 2018. We have a terrific year, get bloody close again, our midfield is terrific, our small forwards deadly, our defence cohesive. We go deep into September once more but but once again our lack of key position strength costs us in the finals. The clock is ticking on our premiership window. Pendles, Sidey and Beamsy are all veterans. Our time is now. So how are we going to get a plug n play key position player to boost our chances in 2020? Now in that scenario, wouldn't trading away a kid for a ready made key position player make sense?

Only problem with that senario is if we are trading Sier because he doesn’t fit into the 22 and isn’t getting a game he will have low value and certainly wouldn’t have the currency to be swapped for a ready made KPP who historically cost plenty

 

[Go Woods]

Big part of our future, you don't trade a young gun midfielder. Will be best 22 again at some stage this season.