brisbane lions/bears/fitzroy lions all time best team?

Remove this Banner Ad

yeah they probably did have a few better ruckmen, i didn't do much research but i came up with a few alright players

Actually, they didn't have any better ruckmen in my lifetime. For this reason, the only player I'd include in this team, if the interchange bench were extended, as it was for the Fitzroy TOC, that would be Alan Gale. In general, I've restricted myself to players I've seen. The exceptions are Bunton, whom my dad and Jack Dyer said was the best player they'd ever seen. Pretty difficult to argue with that. I never saw Ruthven play, but for a period of at least a decade, he was easily Fitzroy's best player, and certainly in the top five in the League over that period. Anyway, here goes:

B: C. Johnson G. Pert J. Leppitch

HB: K. Murray P. Roos N. Lappin

C: M. Conlan M. Voss J. Akermanis

HF: O. Abrahams J. Brown G. Wilson

F: L. Power B. Quinlan A. Lynch

R: C. Keating S. Black H. Bunton

Inter:J Charman; N. Johnstone; A Ruthven; J. Murphy

Coach: Len Smith

Osborne and Smallhorn can consider themselves unlucky, as if they'd give a toss, especially Wilfred.

Some may be surprised at the nomination of Len Smith. There is a good footy reason, and a personal one for this. When he took over the senior team in 1958, after coaching the thirds for several years, he transformed a bunch of no-hopers into a finals team by being smarter than his opposing coaches. He invented the idea of players constantly rotating positions through half-forward and on-ball throughout a game. He invented the flick pass which gave rise to the use of handball as an offensive weapon, rather than as a method to overcome the panic of being tackled.

Most of all though, Len was one of the nicest football people I've ever met. In 1963, he coached a bunch kids from my school for a couple of hours at the Brunswick St Oval. I learnt more about footy and the philosophy which underlies the playing of the game in those two hours than I had in the previous 15 years, or in the subsequent however many years that is.

He also has written the only credible methodology for a coach to conduct himself in his job. These notes are still as relevant as they were when they were written in the 1960s, and I'd bet putative coaches still read them to this day. He changed the game to a form which is recognisable today, in the space of five years.

Finally, Len had to be my coach because he and his brother Norm were playmates of my father, as they all grew up in what were then the paddocks adjacent to the railway line at Westgarth.

To me, this was a simply brilliant idea for a thread, and I hope I haven't bored you witless with these ramblings. I hope I've managed to convey some of the passions I've developed in following the Lions throughout many years. The disappointment I felt in 1996 has been ameliorated by the pleasure the newer manifestation of the Lions has given me.
 
B: C. Johnson G. Pert J. Leppitch
HB: K. Murray P. Roos N. Lappin
C: M. Conlan M. Voss(C) 'Chicken' Smallhorn
HF: O. Abrahams J. Brown G. Wilson
F: A Lynch B. Quinlan A Ruthven
R: A Gale S. Black H. Bunton

Inter:C Keating; N Johnstone; R Merrett; J Murphy

Emerg: R Champion; J.Akermanis: R Osborne

Coach: L Matthews
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Nigel Lappin would be extremely unlucky to miss out if he wasn't named on the half-back flank.

IMO the 3rd best player Brisbane have produced after Voss and Leppa.
Sure, you could swing the team around to fit players in. I was just commenting on the teams as they were named. Whatever way you dice it I think Murray and Roos are absolute certainties. And Pert in his prime was an absolutely sensational defender.
 
FWIW, Aker gets my vote ahead of Lappin. AA defender not to mention in the top 5 mids in the comp for several years and a genius up forward. I'd might just even put Johnson ahead of Nige aswell if just for the position he played (although I know Nige is an absolute champ).
 
FWIW, Aker gets my vote ahead of Lappin. AA defender not to mention in the top 5 mids in the comp for several years and a genius up forward. I'd might just even put Johnson ahead of Nige aswell if just for the position he played (although I know Nige is an absolute champ).
Love Nigel but I’d absolutely have Johno in the backline before him.
 
B: C. Johnson G. Pert J. Leppitch
HB: K. Murray P. Roos N. Lappin
C: J Akermanis M. Voss(C) 'Chicken' Smallhorn
HF: J.Murphy J. Brown G. Wilson
F: A Lynch B. Quinlan A Ruthven
R: A Gale S. Black H. Bunton

Inter: M Conlan; N Johnstone; R Merrett; J Moriarty

Emerg: L Power; C Keating: O Abrahams

Coach: L Matthews

This would be a bloody good team, and would put almost every other AFL club's all-time best in the shade.

Obviously it's impossible to fairly compare players from different eras.

But, from the current era, Aker has to be in the starting 18. Mick Conlan was my hero, but he should only get a bench spot. Murphy also has to be in the starting 18, probably at the expense of Abrahams.

I don't think Keating has played enough matches to make the top 22 and I'd have Luke Power, Chris Scott or Marcus Ashcroft in the emergencies ahead of Champion.

As Fitzroy's all-time leading goal kicker, Jack Moriarty probably has to get in ahead of Osborne.
 
According to the above side, just a few years ago we had 7 of those players (9 if you include emergencies) playing for us in the same team. No wonder we did reasonably well.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

brisbane lions/bears/fitzroy lions all time best team?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top