Traded Bryce Gibbs [traded to Adelaide] - (cont. in Part 2)

[RippaRiley43]

Take your broken crows glasses off mate..
View attachment 295435 View attachment 295436

Good job comparing Lyons' sub-affected 2014 games with Graham's 2016 season without the sub rule.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Take your broken crows glasses off mate..
View attachment 295435 View attachment 295436

You're not seriously trying to make a case that Gibbs is better than Sloane?

Mate, even the bulk of one eyed Carlton supporters wouldn't even bother with that one.

 

[My name geoff]

Good job comparing Lyons' sub-affected 2014 games with Graham's 2016 season without the sub rule.

Comparing them at the same age.. Pretty reasonable considering Graham has only played 28 games and is 2 years younger than Lyons

 

[My name geoff]

You're not seriously trying to make a case that Gibbs is better than Sloane?

Mate, even the bulk of one eyed Carlton supporters wouldn't even bother with that one.

Gibbs is the equal of Sloane hence why I have made the comparison

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Gibbs is the equal of Sloane hence why I have made the comparison

No

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Gibbs is the equal of Sloane hence why I have made the comparison

Wow. I just... I don't know what to.... I never... Errrr....

 

[My name geoff]

Good job comparing Lyons' sub-affected 2014 games with Graham's 2016 season without the sub rule.

Here are their career averages if it helps you sleep

 

[Mego Red]

Gibbs is the equal of Sloane hence why I have made the comparison

Sloane is more valuable than Gibbs.

Value is something a market determines, and the market values Sloane as more valuable than Gibbs.

 

[My name geoff]

Sloane is more valuable than Gibbs.

Value is something a market determines, and the market values Sloane as more valuable than Gibbs.

Ok..if you say so

 

[Sinjin Smith]

Sloane is more valuable than Gibbs.

Value is something a market determines, and the market values Sloane as more valuable than Gibbs.

The market has not evaluated either Sloane or Gibbs as of yet. Pointless statement.

 

[Mego Red]

Here are their career averages if it helps you sleep

View attachment 295439

No.

This year. How did they compare?

Don't say the age thing - both are mature footballers. Compare what they've just done, otherwise you're trying to pull a scam.

In case you're wondering, here's a look.

 

[My name geoff]

No.

This year. How did they compare?

Don't say the age thing - both are mature footballers. Compare what they've just done, otherwise you're trying to pull a scam.

In case you're wondering, here's a look.

Using your logic, then you have to agree that cripps is a better player and more valuable than sloane?

 

[Monocle]

Gibbs is the equal of Sloane hence why I have made the comparison

No he is not.

 

[My name geoff]

No he is not.

thanks for your input

 

[marty36]

No adelaide player matches like for like with Gibbs he is an elite ball user and outside runner we don't have any of them, sloane is more inside

This is why Gibbs would suit us hugely

What Carlton would want could be the sticking point

 

[Mego Red]

Using your logic, then you have to agree that cripps is a better player and more valuable than sloane?

Cripps? Probably, yeah.

I'd call Cripps more valuable though currently not better.

 

[bignick]

Gibbs is the equal of Sloane hence why I have made the comparison

I am a huge Gibbsy fan but that is a ridiculous statement.

Not one club would take Gibbs over Sloane.

 

[My name geoff]

No adelaide player matches like for like with Gibbs he is an elite ball user and outside runner we don't have any of them, sloane is more inside

This is why Gibbs would suit us hugely

What Carlton would want could be the sticking point

This is exactly right.

Sloane and Gibbs are different players but are of equal talent relatively speaking.

One side may prefer one over the other but you won't lose either way.

 

[My name geoff]

I am a huge Gibbsy fan but that is a ridiculous statement.

Not one club would take Gibbs over Sloane.

Carlton fans are notorious for understating their own..

We are the same club who hand delivered Eddie betts and Sam Jacobs to the crows not too long ago.

 

[My name geoff]

Cripps? Probably, yeah.

I'd call Cripps more valuable though currently not better.

Using your logic, Cripps is currently a better player

 

[marty36]

This is exactly right.

Sloane and Gibbs are different players but are of equal talent relatively speaking.

One side may prefer one over the other but you won't lose either way.

Without biased if I was offered one I would take Sloane every day of the week AT!M he is killing it. Gibbs is a bit softer not as much of a hard nut so not a fans fav but can be damaging

 

[My name geoff]

Without biased if I was offered one I would take Sloane every day of the week AT!M he is killing it. Gibbs is a bit softer not as much of a hard nut so not a fans fav but can be damaging

If I was offered Sloane for Gibbs, I would keep Gibbs.

If Carlton had half a decent side around Gibbs, a lot more people would hold the same opinion

 

[Monocle]

thanks for your input

Your welcome.

Sloane is ahead of Gibbs on trade value by quite some margin.

You navy blue glasses make that hard for you to see.

 

[marty36]

If I was offered Sloane for Gibbs, I would keep Gibbs.

If Carlton had half a decent side around Gibbs, a lot more people would hold the same opinion

I'd say Sloane almost single handed controlled our midfield and got us to 5th on the ladder as he had limited support in the midfield our rick struggled can't say Gibbs did the same for you

 

[JDavey]

If I was offered Sloane for Gibbs, I would keep Gibbs.

If Carlton had half a decent side around Gibbs, a lot more people would hold the same opinion