You lost me at Dangerfield to even mention his name with Martin and Ablett .
Opinion Can Dustin Martin be the GOAT? (Answer: no)
- Thread starter adammania9
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Loool your living in fairyland.
No need to be fixed because his achievements say it all. What a load of crap he wasn't that great for significant parts of his career.
- May 5, 2016
- 47,904
- 53,707
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Disprove it.
I’m neither here nor there on what that means in the grand scheme of things but as a statement on its own it’s fairly straightforward
A 5 year window for All Australian selections that covers the period he was elite in. In 2 of those seasons, the elite status was consolidated with great finals series (it was borderline until then - fringe of AA selection). In 2017 and 2018 he already had fantastic H&A seasons before he got to finals.
The spreading over a lot of finals series is a big factor too. Martin's averages are brought way up by his best 3 finals series as he actually didn't play that many finals compared to a lot of the modern greats. And he was rotated forward a lot more in those than conventional midfielders. He still did a stunning job but the averages don't look so great if you contain them to the 2013, 2014, 2015, 2018 and 2022 finals series where he was mostly NOT in the dominant side in the league (2018 you can argue they were until finals) - i.e 5 out of his 8 finals series in his career.
It's better to just say 2017-2020 was the best finals stretch of a player in the AFL era. Rather than the whole "undisputed greatest finals player in VFL/AFL history". Because he has these caveats:
-Never had a great finals series outside of a premiership year
-Never had a fantastic game in a losing final
-Was in the best handful of players on the ground in a final in only 4 different seasons (2017, 2018, 2019, 2020 - one continuous 4 year period)
-No strong finals as a youngster (24 or under) or a veteran (30 or over)
-His best work irrefutably came when his side was the dominant finals side of its era. In any other situation, there was a big drop off
Something like "most influential player during a side's dynasty?" Now that's something there is real evidence for. But greatest of all time discussions and such there is too much missing including a fairly condensed elite period (2016-2020). He has excuses for his peak being cut short, of course, but it doesn't change the fact that the missing elite seasons after he turned 30 are still there.
Lunchtime
Club Legend
- Mar 23, 2024
- 1,794
- 2,976
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Why the need to cherry pick certain games? All players have good games in Finals games and quiet games in Finals games - this applies to Martin.....and every other player. That's why averages are a good indicator.
Sttew
Brownlow Medallist
And yet here you are mentioning Dusty's name with GAJ
10 of Martin's 16 career finals came in premiership years, contained to 3 seasons. That is a whopping 63%. If you look at those games they heavily, heavily skew the averages. His averages are basically protected by not having to play many finals 2011-2016 or 2021-2024. Throw another 24 finals in those years and of course his stunning averages would decline. It's common sense.
Selwood even won an extra premiership yet still only 30% of his finals (12 out of 40) were in premiership seasons where his side was the dominant one. He played many finals as a kid in a periphery role, as an emerging star, in his peak in a great side, in his peak in a decent-ish but not dominant side (2012-2016) and as a veteran in sides of varying quality (2017-2022). Many of the modern champs have similar spreads.
It's fine to say Martin's peak finals period was better than any of those players peak finals period i.e best 4 year run. But it's lazy to say he was a much better finals player overall when 5 of his 8 finals series he was still poor, a non-factor or average at best. He just had 3 insanely good finals series when his side was dominant and he was at his peak.
and the thing is, when there have been polls asking who is the best midfielder of the 21st century Ablett Jnr doesn't just win by a bit, he wins by a lot every single time. It isn't even close. Only the most rabid Richmond fans (and one Hawthorn fan for some reason) believe Martin is the best midfielder of the 21st century. 80% or more of the general bigfooty community picks Ablett.
- Sep 15, 2011
- 33,841
- 53,314
- AFL Club
- West Coast
And the other 20 per cent pick Judd. Martin not in the conversation.
Well at the very least in this regard which you highlighted then yes, he’s objectively better than Martin. You said averaging 22 disposals and 1.6 goals as a midfielder was very very good, I pointed out that Danger did it twice over full seasons compared to Martin’s 0, GAJ even further ahead of both of them.
- Dec 12, 2022
- 608
- 594
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
Break someone's jaw? No I don't think Dusty has that in him
Richmond fans have not only deserted attending games, they've deserted Bigfooty
- Feb 12, 2017
- 19,303
- 51,046
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- have been WARPED by Geelong
Dustin crawled so Harley could run.
Surely its time.
Someone start the Can Harley Reid be the GOAT thread please
Someone start the Can Harley Reid be the GOAT thread please
Wosh
🐨 Admin 🐨
- Admin
- #7,120
This thread is sufficient
I think every footy lover appreciates a genuine talent and in his day I watched Richmond games just for Dusty because he was so incredibly good and incredibly entertaining. No one changed a game like Dusty when he put his afterburners on. Harley is still a baby but I doubt anyone could deny he is a pip to watch already.
Wosh
🐨 Admin 🐨
- May 21, 2015
- 4,737
- 6,989
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Dusty building form nicely just in time to humiliate Geelong yet again
