Meltdown Carlton and Collingwood - who finishes higher in 2024?

Remove this Banner Ad

I'm miserable you didn't finish 13th

But isn't it fun making finals and having a chance? ie what you guys normally call a "participation ribbon"
Misery that we didn't miss finals would be high for a few of you 😉

So far we have mirrored my preseason prediction/expectation 13-15 H&A wins

Now finals, will be fun to see how that plays out
 
Misery that we didn't miss finals would be high for a few of you 😉

So far we have mirrored my preseason prediction/expectation 13-15 H&A wins

Now finals, will be fun to see how that plays out
Do you have an expectation from here?

I think you'll survive one week (70% chance Carlton to win this week, 40% chance of winning the semi, 1% chance of winning prelim v Brisbane)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Participation ribbons - once mocked by Carlton supporters, now being celebrated 😂

I ain't celebrating making finals

We still have a relatively young list, with only 2 players 30+ for the whole of next year

So, it's more what we do in the next 3 years

While the top 3 have a statistical advantage, that shouldn't stop us making a GF if we are good enough
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Or the prior 60 odd years? We can all frame a timeline that suits our arguments

Unless you want to discuss your predictions over the last 3 years 😉
I've fully enjoyed my life as a Collingwood supporter.

Regularly competitive with no extended periods of being a laughing stock and whipping boys of the competition.

Can't say that about many teams, including yours.

I hope Carlton win it if Collingwood don't this year. I've got many good friends who are Carlton supporters who have been miserable for two decades.
 
I've fully enjoyed my life as a Collingwood supporter.
Same as mine as a Carlton supporter

Regularly competitive with no extended periods of being a laughing stock and whipping boys of the competition.

Can't say that about many teams, including yours
Hmmm same amount of flags last 30 years, but 8 to 2 in my lifetime

The lows not so great, the highs, well nothing that you would have experienced

.

I hope Carlton win it if Collingwood don't this year. I've got many good friends who are Carlton supporters who have been miserable for two decades.
I have many miserable Pie supporter mates over the last 60 odd years
 
I have many miserable Pie supporter mates over the last 60 odd years
They have no reason to be, our club delivers for them year after year, no extended periods at the bottom or out of finals

They should be very satisfied with an overflowing drawer full of participation ribbons, enjoying the game regularly like you are now
 
Hmmm same amount of flags last 30 years, but 8 to 2 in my lifetime
There are two types of Carlton supporters:
1. Those who have seen flags, are approaching senility, and have been miserable for two decades, and
2. Those who haven't forgiven their parents for making them barrack for Carlton.
I have many miserable Pie supporter mates over the last 60 odd years
Lies on multiple fronts.
 
They have no reason to be, our club delivers for them year after year, no extended periods at the bottom or out of finals

They should be very satisfied with an overflowing drawer full of participation ribbons, enjoying the game regularly like you are now
Indeed.

Pies supporters are always up and about.

Clearly telling porky pies. As if he'd have any mates.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Meltdown Carlton and Collingwood - who finishes higher in 2024?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top