Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Chronz]

I think i'd rather see the interstate teams flop moreso than carlton in finals. Imagine the juicy vicbias drivel if a vic team obtains the premiership again, the meltdowns would be astronomical.

Plus there are some upstanding carlton supporters/posters that deserve some glory on here, well not in this thread of course.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

All the Blues have done since 2000 is win 5 flash in the pan wooden spoons

So you are saying that someone else should have won the spoons are you? I agree that 2005 spoon should've went to Collingwood instead.

 

[Worm4]

honestly you have no idea. We lost to the premiership faves by a point and beat Brisbane in the last 2 games when we got our structure back. WE will trade for our needs because we have a smart recruiting and coaching team. I am very comfortable with the fact that we will be top 4 with average luck with injuries, And you will be wrong yet again

Pies don't have a list manager, in fact the one they had left on an all time high of giving away draft picks willy nilly for a puglsey german from fremantle . This in turn has ensured that they can't trade for what I consider a player in the top 5 in the league who was a Collingwood nut growing up. Shame really as he would have been the perfect fit but alas, not to be. Twas a grand parting gesture indeed. Smart recruiting

 

[black is White]

Plus there are some upstanding carlton supporters/posters that deserve some glory on here, well not in this thread of course.

You should wash your mouth out with soap and sterilise your eyeballs how could you be so sacrareligois!

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Pies don't have a list manager, in fact the one they had left on an all time high of giving away draft picks willy nilly for a puglsey german from fremantle . This in turn has ensured that they can't trade for what I consider a player in the top 5 in the league who was a Collingwood nut growing up. Shame really as he would have been the perfect fit but alas, not to be. Twas a grand parting gesture indeed. Smart recruiting

Talking bout Petracca? He's staying at Melbourne, suck it up Wormy

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

I think i'd rather see the interstate teams flop moreso than carlton in finals. Imagine the juicy vicbias drivel if a vic team obtains the premiership again, the meltdowns would be astronomical.

Plus there are some upstanding carlton supporters/posters that deserve some glory on here, well not in this thread of course.

You would be very much an anomaly there. Normally Pies supporters wouldn't give Carlton the steam off their piss and vice versa.

 

[Worm4]

Talking bout Petracca? He's staying at Melbourne, suck it up Wormy

View attachment 2097873

You can talk about any player available, collingwood are all chips in with the fat little German.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

We never got blown away like you peanuts will

We finished your club off in 1964 when we poached Ron Barassi, and we finished it off yet again in that semi final last year.

Go and merge with the Saints. The Melbourne Demon Saints has a lovely but albeit contrary ring to it.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

honestly you have no idea. We lost to the premiership faves by a point and beat Brisbane in the last 2 games when we got our structure back. WE will trade for our needs because we have a smart recruiting and coaching team. I am very comfortable with the fact that we will be top 4 with average luck with injuries, And you will be wrong yet again

April fools day has been and gone mate.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

You can talk about any player available, collingwood are all chips in with the fat little German.

The fat little German is playing with a bunch of premiership stars and picking up their winning habits, won't be long before he gets his fat fingers on the trophies and medals like his esteemed teammates

 

[RPCB]

I think i'd rather see the interstate teams flop moreso than carlton in finals. Imagine the juicy vicbias drivel if a vic team obtains the premiership again, the meltdowns would be astronomical.

Plus there are some upstanding carlton supporters/posters that deserve some glory on here, well not in this thread of course.

First Kiryu and then some nice words about Carlton.

I feel like I need to say something nice about Collingwood. But I just don’t wanna.

 

[Worm4]

The fat little German is playing with a bunch of mexicans and picking up their eating habits, won't be long before he gets his fat fingers on the burgers and chips like his esteemed teammates

Edited for accuracy

 

[Robertio]

The fat little German is playing with a bunch of premiership stars and picking up their winning habits, won't be long before he gets his fat fingers on the trophies and medals like his esteemed teammates

He's not playing this September though, probably in Bali with a bunch of premiership stars.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Edited for accuracy

You are so obviously jealous that we have the juicy little Bratwurst and all you have is a guy named after a toddler word for pain.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

You are so obviously jealous that we have the juicy little Bratwurst and all you have is a guy named after a toddler word for pain.

Schultz this off season learning off Degoey

 

[South of the Yarra]

Wow for all Carlton’s carry on of an ageing list and no young talent at Collingwood , Carlton did not have one player picked in the Under 24 top 40 this morning. That is insane. Not one youngster worth making the top 40. That list is cooked. If it doesn’t win a flag this year it never will.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Wow for all Carlton’s carry on of an ageing list and no young talent at Collingwood , Carlton did not have one player picked in the Under 24 top 40 this morning. That is insane. Not one youngster worth making the top 40. That list is cooked. If it doesn’t win a flag this year it never will.

We have 2 players over 30... I think we've got a bit more than a year left in the tank lmao

 

[carlton_99]

We have 2 players over 30... I think we've got a bit more than a year left in the tank lmao

6th least experienced team in 2024 based on games played as well

 

[Worm4]

Wow for all Carlton’s carry on of an ageing list and no young talent at Collingwood , Carlton did not have one player picked in the Under 24 top 40 this morning. That is insane. Not one youngster worth making the top 40. That list is cooked.

That list just finished above your list. We also have a few debutants from late in the season that show some promise, on top of camporeale and walker coming in . I think we will cope

 

[smit_is]

Wow for all Carlton’s carry on of an ageing list and no young talent at Collingwood , Carlton did not have one player picked in the Under 24 top 40 this morning. That is insane. Not one youngster worth making the top 40. That list is cooked. If it doesn’t win a flag this year it never will.

Ah let me guess, Nicky was the only player from the Wobbles? The same one bloke the Wobbles rely on for everything?

Takes more than one great player to be a great team.

God forbid the great (black and) white hope gets injured. It’d be like watching your favourite pub burn down.

#NickyOrBust

 

[Worm4]

Ah let me guess, Nicky was the only player from the Wobbles? The same one bloke the Wobbles rely on for everything?

Takes more than one great player to be a great team.

God forbid the great (black and) white hope gets injured. It’d be like watching your favourite pub burn down.

#N#NickyOrBust

And bigfooty servers crash

 

[HeathySure]

Ur 'needs' is some sort of cryogenic chamber that rewinds the aging of about 10 of your players. Sidebottom, Pendles, Crisp, Howe, Cox, Mihocek, Elliot, WHE, Titch... It's a god damn retirement home down at Pieland

Bottom 6 guaranteed

lol once again you just dont get it. Why have the cats stayed up all these years with geriatric players and no early draft picks?

 

[HeathySure]

Sort of like the Pies this season

so the blues can blame injuries but the pies cannot? interesting. Anyway we have had many players playing through injuries that should have sidelined them for a long time and our structure players not in the side. A longer pre season hopefully will get them the rest they need and we will launch once again.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

lol once again you just dont get it. Why have the cats stayed up all these years with geriatric players and no early draft picks?

Dekoning, Holmes, Clark, O'Sullivan, Conway, Dempsey, Henry, Bruhn must all play table tennis. Cats have plenty of younglings, when their FA strategy started to dry up and their senior core began to decline they started hitting the draft.

Pies have Nicky and then nobody and are even older than the Cats were

 

[HeathySure]

Pies don't have a list manager, in fact the one they had left on an all time high of giving away draft picks willy nilly for a puglsey german from fremantle . This in turn has ensured that they can't trade for what I consider a player in the top 5 in the league who was a Collingwood nut growing up. Shame really as he would have been the perfect fit but alas, not to be. Twas a grand parting gesture indeed. Smart recruiting

lol we finished 17th 2 years before we won a flag because we finally got rid of the cancer of the club. Straight past the blues. We dont need high draft picks because they are meaningless for immediate improvement