Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Carlton

  • Collingwood


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Watching the highlights of their most recent grand final, Shannon Grant did his best Bobby Hill impersonation
Pies September highlight in 2024 is Darcy Moore on Deal or No Deal. Good to see he has been able to find something to keep him occupied given his season is over.
 
Got to hand it to these Collingwood fans going in to battle for their team, when Carlton are holding up the premiership cup in four weeks they will still be saying they had a better year.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

It goes back further than that. Mick Malthouse said they wouldn’t lose a game.

Ah yes, the Collingwood infiltrator. He came to Carlton for a games coaching record and to destroy the club from the inside. Not really surprising that he would go with that sound bite knowing it would be used for years to come as a way to mock Carlton.

Nothing good has ever come out of Collingwood. Totally moronic hire that one.
 
Ah yes, the Collingwood infiltrator. He came to Carlton for a games coaching record and to destroy the club from the inside. Not really surprising that he would go with that sound bite knowing it would be used for years to come as a way to mock Carlton.

Nothing good has ever come out of Collingwood. Totally moronic hire that one.
Ah yes.

Yet another poor decision made by the Carlton Football Club that was clear as day at the time, but was only seen as a fail in hindsight by the Carlton faithful who drank the kool-aid at the time of his arrival...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ah yes.

Yet another poor decision made by the Carlton Football Club that was clear as day at the time, but was only seen as a fail in hindsight by the Carlton faithful who drank the kool-aid at the time of his arrival...
It was a shit signing at the time. A “messiah” who was 87 years old and coming from Collingwood with only the games record on his mind. I don’t know what we were thinking.
 
Ah yes.

Yet another poor decision made by the Carlton Football Club that was clear as day at the time, but was only seen as a fail in hindsight by the Carlton faithful who drank the kool-aid at the time of his arrival...
Malthouse for Jordan Russell was a good trade in my opinion. BTW fadge, did you check out the title of the thread ? Warms my cockles
 
Your captain wears these to bed , along with his night mask .

I am glad Collingwood have found ways to keep Darcy Moore occupied in the offseason, like having him on Deal or No Deal. You really don’t want him out on public. He will probably go around elbowing kittens, small children, kneeing little old ladies. Just being a nuisance.
 
Eff the haters and eff the begrudgers we are in the finals and Collingwood are not.

We are going up to Brisbane tomorrow to do one thing and one thing only and that's win.

The flag is a very open race this year. Anyone can win it except Collingwood!:laughv1:
 
Main memory of that day was singing "We Are The Kangaroos" throughout the last quarter while our Carlton mates huddled outside 😆
It's a shame we never went through with that full takeover of the Roos. Arden Street would make for a lovely location for a Coles or a Woolies.:laughv1:
 
The flag is a very open race this year. Anyone can win it except Collingwood!:laughv1:
Supporters of clubs who don't understand the finals system might truly believe this.

But you're wrong.

There's a reason the premier has come from the teams who qualify for finals with a double chance on 96% of occasions since the current finals system has been in play.
 
Supporters of clubs who don't understand the finals system might truly believe this.

But you're wrong.

There's a reason the premier has come from the teams who qualify for finals with a double chance on 96% of occasions since the current finals system has been in play.

I see you’re back.

Did you stop being bothered by the thread title to rejoin the thread? Good for you. 👍
 
Ah yes, the Collingwood infiltrator. He came to Carlton for a games coaching record and to destroy the club from the inside. Not really surprising that he would go with that sound bite knowing it would be used for years to come as a way to mock Carlton.

Nothing good has ever come out of Collingwood. Totally moronic hire that one.
Best Carlton coach ever🤣.
Did an absolute number on you guys.

No love for Heath Scotland?
 
Supporters of clubs who don't understand the finals system might truly believe this.

But you're wrong.

There's a reason the premier has come from the teams who qualify for finals with a double chance on 96% of occasions since the current finals system has been in play.
You are the one who doesnt understand the finals system
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

Back
Top