Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[VinnieB]

Bloos fans always counted Martin and Marchbank big ‘outs’ each week.

Vossy and the list manager already thinking outside the square and giving Bloos fans their first excuse for 2025.

 

[VinnieB]

The old "my team were premiers so i know better" post, don't you love Bigfooty.

30 yrs in 2025….
Can’t wait to help you celebrate.

Who is making the fairy bread?

 

[Worm4]

Who is making the fairy bread?

Probably Darcy Moore he'd be that type of guy

 

[Worm4]

By losing both games to Collingwood?

Carlton sure stood in the way of Collingwood and Back to Back!

We gave you a direct path to play finals and they balls'd it up. It's been epic

 

[VinnieB]

Probably Darcy Moore he'd be that type of guy

That’s so inappropriate.
As long as Jon Dorotich hasn’t made it with his bare hands, should be fine.

 

[Worm4]

That’s so inappropriate.
As long as Jon Dorotich hasn’t made it with his bare hands, should be fine.

I'm sure Joffa would help if asked

 

[VinnieB]

We gave you a direct path to play finals and they balls'd it up. It's been epic

You played the bottom 3 teams 5x.
What more can the AFL do for Carlton?

 

[Worm4]

You played the bottom 3 teams 5x.
What more can the AFL do for Carlton?

6 times would have been nicer , just for the melts from you people alone

 

[VinnieB]

I'm sure Joffa would help if asked

Just stay away from the guy walking around with a tray of cocktail frankfurts.

 

[Worm4]

Just stay away from the guy walking around with a tray of cocktail frankfurts.

Nick the Dick ?

 

[Robertio]

30 yrs in 2025….
Can’t wait to help you celebrate.

Who is making the fairy bread?

We won't need any help from outsiders.

 

[Pistol Night]

The old "my team were premiers so i know better" post, don't you love Bigfooty.

My word i do

 

[Scritchyscroony]

30 yrs in 2025….
Can’t wait to help you celebrate.

Who is making the fairy bread?

The elephant in the room will make the 30th anniversary of the '95 flag a bit awkward.

 

[Fadge]

I notice Carlton have finally bitten the bullet and delisted a few of their injury prone players - Martin, Cunningham and Marchbank.

Step 1 in Fadge's 4 step process for Carlton to build a list to contend for the premiership.

Might even be enough to elevate them from 13th to 11th or 12th in my 2025 predictions... let's see what they do with the list spots.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I notice Carlton have finally bitten the bullet and delisted a few of their injury prone players - Martin, Cunningham and Marchbank.

Step 1 in Fadge's 4 step process for Carlton to build a list to contend for the premiership.

Might even be enough to elevate them from 13th to 11th or 12th in my 2025 predictions... let's see what they do with the list spots.

Blues could add Petracca, Prime Chris Judd, Eddie Betts, Matthew Scarlett and a dozen of the best role players of all time and you'd still have us coming 10th at best.

Meanwhile the Pies will add a fat lard like Schultz or Stringer and instantly the Pies are on the verge of a 9peat.

Never change Fudgey

 

[Fadge]

Blues could add Petracca, Prime Chris Judd, Eddie Betts, Matthew Scarlett and a dozen of the best role players of all time and you'd still have us coming 10th at best.

Meanwhile the Pies will add a fat lard like Schultz or Stringer and instantly the Pies are on the verge of a 9peat.

Never change Fudgey

No, not at all.

This group will be the first to know when I assess Carlton's list as capable of contending for a premiership.

 

[Worm4]

No, not at all.

This group will be the first to know when I assess Carlton's list as capable of contending for a premiership.

 

[Seeds]

Shouldn't these threads be on the bay? Isn't this type of thread exactly what the bay exists for?

 

[Maddo11]

Shouldn't these threads be on the bay? Isn't this type of thread exactly what the bay exists for?

But nobody goes to the bay, so this thread wouldn't exist at all, which is why nobody goes to the bay

 

[HeathySure]

Shouldn't these threads be on the bay? Isn't this type of thread exactly what the bay exists for?

250 pages into part 3 and this is what you can come up with? This is why no one likes Geelong supporters anymore

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Shouldn't these threads be on the bay? Isn't this type of thread exactly what the bay exists for?

It's a "lame duck" period, nothing happening at either club atm

The thread will get back to its usual high quality during trade week

 

[carlton_99]

250 pages into part 3 and this is what you can come up with? This is why no one likes Geelong supporters anymore

Late contender for POTY

 

[Worm4]

It's a "lame duck" period, nothing happening at either club atm

The thread will get back to its usual high quality during trade week

The big question is , if collingwood were happy to cough up large for a fat little weasel , what are they prepared to offer Carlton for an honest midfielder with a Lego man haircut ? Surely a future 1st

 

[Mr Meow]

Late contender for POTY

Exactly!

You've always enjoyed neutrals actually offering their perspective rather than calling the thread useless.

I and others will keep contributing, as it is not a pointless thread at all.

 

[Chief]

Shouldn't these threads be on the bay? Isn't this type of thread exactly what the bay exists for?

This thread has the Bay affirming thread prefix denoting it is for "Banter".

Go and be all serious elsewhere.