You seem to be very keen on Whiterod Roota??
I wouldn't be so certain, the times i saw him i didn't think he was great, including gf, and i would probably have rated Pollock and maybe Walters in front of him this year!!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Central Murray FL
- Thread starter Weapo
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I wouldn't be so certain, the times i saw him i didn't think he was great, including gf, and i would probably have rated Pollock and maybe Walters in front of him this year!!
You have got to be joking Sockit. Pollock didn't play in the ruck most of the time. I will say that Walters had a sensational year, improved out of sight, but for me Whiterod was the standout big fella in the comp this year
I'm a Charlton boy and I've heard that we've picked up Gav Spinks for next year. Can anyone tell me if he can play?
Charlton hey? Yet, not once have you posted on the NCFL thread? But yes I'm told he can play. I saw 4-5 TM games this year and he only played once. Didn't do much but I think he had ankle trouble all year.
Caught with the ball
Debutant
Yes he is a very good footballer & is about 6 foot 1, wirery but strong. And he has very nice hair i think his mum still combs it every morning!
What ever you smoking taking or drinking stop now before it does permanent damage to your brain
I doubt it very much it certianly wouldnt be money Farms at Kyalite and lives in Tooley Would not get a nicer Family. Been tooly all their life Played at Denny because that is were he was working at the time also on the commitee.
Kelvin 69
Team Captain
Bull Faeces!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'd say a bulls bum, only guessing though
Who really cares. Alot of hits for a rumour with very little substance.
I've got a bit of serious discussion (maybe)
With Premiership hopefulls such as Tyntynder (Parsons), Tooly, Kerang, Swan Hill etc its interesting to note that none of these Clubs have opted for tried and true GF/premiership coaches. Granted some have premiership experience and and all are top players. Also worth considering why in several circumstances their own clubs did/couldn't secure their services and are still left without a coach.
What are your thoughts???
I've got a bit of serious discussion (maybe)
With Premiership hopefulls such as Tyntynder (Parsons), Tooly, Kerang, Swan Hill etc its interesting to note that none of these Clubs have opted for tried and true GF/premiership coaches. Granted some have premiership experience and and all are top players. Also worth considering why in several circumstances their own clubs did/couldn't secure their services and are still left without a coach.
What are your thoughts???
Maybe there are not many tried and true premiership coaches around or available for that matter.
Is it possible that a premiership coach who has been there done that doesn't harbour the same hunger as a coach whom is yet to taste premiership success. How sure are you that Forsyth hasn't coached elsewhere with success? Don't overestimate the value of a coach in terms of success, a reasonable coach with a good playing list will win more premierships than a gun coach who's getting the most out of a bunch of duds.
I'm certainly not underestimating Forsyth's value. He certainly may be the exception. I think he had a fair bit of input last year (more than most a/c's) from my observations from a far and also happen to miss out on that premiership by a whisker. I beleive he has played in Hamilton and N.T and i'm not aware of him coaching before Kerang.
When faced with the choice of star coach/ average player and average coach/ star player, clubs these days go for the latter. I reckon most clubs pick a guy and hope they can coach but if they cant at least they get a good player. I'm not saying thats wrong either. Its the old saying -Do players make coaches or do coaches make players/teams. Also I reckon a star player can cause more trouble if they cannot coach.
Anderson didnt coach or even play that day, Assistant coach Guy Booker coached that day & did an amazing job...
- Nov 11, 2006
- 45
- 0
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #3,748
Anyone on here know of an ex Dingley boy, Clinton Brooks? I can't remember what club he was with or even if he is still there but he transferred to the cmfl a few years back. Was a great player at Dingley and was just wondering if he was firing up there. Any info would be great. Cheers.
toshay kelvin,
would hate to be lining up against you round one, could set a new league record for most goals kicked, using this thread as ammunition
Edwin, just wondering if you have got over your case of firing at both ends?
- Status
