Speculation Chad Warner

[Get_The_Gaff]

You can only give what you have. There msy well be a second rounder to sweeten the deal.

Chad may nominate a club

Ha ha ok mate .

With your reasoning west coast could split pick 3ish for a top 10 pick and a future pick and give it to swans ?

 

[King Huskii]

Ha ha ok mate .

With your reasoning west coast could split pick 3ish for a top 10 pick and a future pick and give it to swans ?

If they can manage that then sure.

 

[eastfreo75]

Ha ha ok mate .

With your reasoning west coast could split pick 3ish for a top 10 pick and a future pick and give it to swans ?

Swans have three academy players who are likely to go top 25.

Not sure they want that deal.

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

Swans have three academy players who are likely to go top 25.

Not sure they want that deal.

Oh I understand that . Its that your fellow supporter thinks we should have to pay significantly more because we have more/better picks is my issue .

Warner's value is his value and teams shouldn't have to pay more or less because their finishing position.

Eg your mate huski said we would need a top 10 pick + future top 10 pick insinuating our first 2025 and 2026 .

But pick 3 would probably buy a late top 10 pick and future pick .

 

[ghostbat12]

Swans have three academy players who are likely to go top 25.

Not sure they want that deal.

They can find a better deal with someone else.

Oh wait, they won’t be able to. So what do they do…hmmmm

Again someone saying that swans’ good problem to have is somehow west coast’s problem. Swans having academy kids is not some burden west coast has to bear.

 

[eastfreo75]

They can find a better deal with someone else.

Oh wait, they won’t be able to. So what do they do…hmmmm

Again someone saying that swans’ good problem to have is somehow west coast’s problem. Swans having academy kids is not some burden west coast has to bear.

You need to trade something of value or useful.

 

[rye]

You need to trade something of value or useful.

west coast's first pick will almost definitely fall before any likely sydney academy player and be adequate value for out of contract warner

 

[ghostbat12]

You need to trade something of value or useful.

We have things of value. And more than anyone.

Fact that Sydney have to use it on talented academy kids doesn’t make it useless. Knock on effect for them

It’s not wc problem they don’t have untalented academy kids this year. My heart bleeds for this injustice.

 

[King Huskii]

We have things of value. And more than anyone.

Fact that Sydney have to use it on talented academy kids doesn’t make it useless. Knock on effect for them

It’s not wc problem they don’t have untalented academy kids this year. My heart bleeds for this injustice.

These northern academies and there free access unlike other clubs restricted access to there academies is sure paying off for the AFL

 

[eastfreo75]

west coast's first pick will almost definitely fall before any likely sydney academy player and be adequate value for out of contract warner

Carlton's first round pick won't be part of the deal.

Most likely West Coast 1st and 3rd will most likely outcome.

 

[eastfreo75]

We have things of value. And more than anyone.

Fact that Sydney have to use it on talented academy kids doesn’t make it useless. Knock on effect for them

It’s not wc problem they don’t have untalented academy kids this year. My heart bleeds for this injustice.

Have you negotiated anything in your life?

The art of negotiation is the understanding of the other side.

 

[eaglevision]

Carlton's first round pick won't be part of the deal.

Most likely West Coast 1st and 3rd will most likely outcome.

Given that pick belongs to Hawthorn you’re probably right.

We have Hawks 1R, 2R, 3R.

 

[Adnico26Parker]

What if West Coast trade their 1st rd pick (say 3-5) like they did in the Baker trade before a Warner trade?

 

[eaglevision]

What if West Coast trade their 1st rd pick (say 3-5) like they did in the Baker trade before a Warner trade?

We won’t. IMO there is no way we get Warner without giving Sydney our 1R as part of the deal.

 

[eastfreo75]

Given that pick belongs to Hawthorn you’re probably right.

We have Hawks 1R, 2R, 3R.

For the best midfield- forward in the AFL can you come up with comparable trade within the last 5 years?

 

[eaglevision]

For the best midfield- forward in the AFL can you come up with comparable trade within the last 5 years?

Not sure I agree with that but I’ve said all along I think the deal would be Warner Bros, 17 (and possibly Sheldrick) for 3 and F1. Seems to upset parts of both boards so probably in the ball park.

Bolton deal is probably the best and perhaps only precedent.

 

[eastfreo75]

Not sure I agree with that but I’ve said all along I think the deal would be Warner Bros, 17 (and possibly Sheldrick) for 3 and F1. Seems to upset parts of both boards so probably in the ball park.

Bolton deal is probably the best and perhaps only precedent.

Who is the best midfield-forward in the league?

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

For the best midfield- forward in the AFL can you come up with comparable trade within the last 5 years?

Warner isn't even the best mid/forward in his side

Heeney is better , gulden is on par not as good around goals but probably the best field kick in the league

Shai Bolton is also up there but is more of a forward/mid

A uncontracted warner vs contracted shai Bolton is a very good trade comparison.

Warner is a more valuable player but Bolton had to be paid overs in trade capital due to being contracted

 

[King Huskii]

Warner isn't even the best mid/forward in his side

Heeney is better , gulden is on par not as good around goals but probably the best field kick in the league

Shai Bolton is also up there but is more of a forward/mid

A uncontracted warner vs contracted shai Bolton is a very good trade comparison.

Warner is a more valuable player but Bolton had to be paid overs in trade capital due to being contracted

According to you

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

According to you

And the rest of the post ?

Uncontracted warner vs contracted Bolton as a trade comparison?

Pretty dam close IMO

 

[WCE777]

Warner isn't even the best mid/forward in his side

Heeney is better , gulden is on par not as good around goals but probably the best field kick in the league

Shai Bolton is also up there but is more of a forward/mid

A uncontracted warner vs contracted shai Bolton is a very good trade comparison.

Warner is a more valuable player but Bolton had to be paid overs in trade capital due to being contracted

its a good comparison.
If WC finish bottom 3 that pick alone should be fair value and maybe a 3rd round pick.
Hawks 1st(9-11) and WC F1st (5) is a very generous offer.

 

[THE_GUN]

They can find a better deal with someone else.

Oh wait, they won’t be able to. So what do they do…hmmmm

Again someone saying that swans’ good problem to have is somehow west coast’s problem. Swans having academy kids is not some burden west coast has to bear.

Yes it is

The Swans are not going to agree to a trade that will have the pick swallowed up in a bid
Eagles will have a top 5 pick and swans will demand and get it along with another later pick

 

[THE_GUN]

And the rest of the post ?

Uncontracted warner vs contracted Bolton as a trade comparison?

Pretty dam close IMO

If both Warner & Bolton available to the eagles for pick #3
which would you take

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

If both Warner & Bolton available to the eagles for pick #3
which would you take

Warner but its close they are both very good players .

Bolton is more the Cherry on top player perfect for freo as they have already got a very good midfield.

Can you honestly tell me that a contracted player is worth more in a trade than a uncontracted player

 

[THE_GUN]

Warner but its close they are both very good players .

Bolton is more the Cherry on top player perfect for freo as they have already got a very good midfield.

Can you honestly tell me that a contracted player is worth more in a trade than a uncontracted player

There is your answer on which player is worth more in a trade

2025 1st & 3rd is a good deal for both clubs