Changes v Geelong - Vince, TSmith, Kent for MRP duo & Brayshaw

[LeverPuller]

OUT: Hannan (did nothing), ANB (similar)
IN: Kent, Vince

If Hogan goes...perhaps we play Spencil.

 

[Tulip]

OUT: Melksham, ANB, Hannan
IN: Kent, Frost, Vince

 

[schmuttt]

OUT: Melksham, ANB, Hannan
IN: Kent, Frost, Vince

That'll do me.

 

[d33my]

Hogan and Lewis surely in trouble?

Vince in, not sure about Hannan and ANB. Reckon you back them in for one more game. Kent will be champing at the bit though.

 

[Tulip]

Vince in, not sure about Hannan and ANB. Reckon you back them in for one more game. Kent will be champing at the bit though.

Neither had any impact though? I'm happier to bring in best 22 players and let the young guys earn their way in by taking their chance.

 

[schmuttt]

Hogan and Lewis surely in trouble?

Vince in, not sure about Hannan and ANB. Reckon you back them in for one more game. Kent will be champing at the bit though.

Forgot about the Hogan/Lewis stuff. If Hogan misses I think going two rucks would be fine.

 

[LeverPuller]

Hogan and Lewis surely in trouble?

Vince in, not sure about Hannan and ANB. Reckon you back them in for one more game. Kent will be champing at the bit though.

Need to see the Hoges one again but Rowe made everything he could out of it after starting the fight from what I saw.

 

[Yakker]

Out
Melksham

In
Anyone else

 

[Cannon82]

Hogan and Lewis surely in trouble?

Vince in, not sure about Hannan and ANB. Reckon you back them in for one more game. Kent will be champing at the bit though.

Yep. Not a fan of sending blokes packing on the back of one bad game, especially when they played better against a better side. Melksham should definitely go out, but will he? Your move, Simon.

In: Vince
Out: Melksham
?: MRP

 

[Cannon82]

Need to see the Hoges one again but Rowe made everything he could out of it after starting the fight from what I saw.

Yep, would also like a replay. Saw it very quickly and I thought he gave him a gentle massage rather than a pop on the chops. A few of the Carlton guys made the most of some light contact.

 

[RandB]

Vince on Dangerfield - rough him up all game ala a few years back. Will be fresh and raring to go.

Viney on Selwood - make him bleed again. Needs to make amends, give him a mission.

Norf tried to rough them up and whilst they lost Cats had to earn it.

Rest of our mids focus on the footy.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

North showed everyone how to beat the Cats. Play on from free kicks, run the corridor, and kick long. I don't know if we have the skills to pull it off but when we played our best against the Saints at Etihad it's when we were attacking.

 

[Canary]

Out: Melksham, ANB
In: Vince, Kent

Hopefully both Hogan & Lewis OK (surely they should be...) if not, ANB earn a reprieve and bring in the Spencil.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Thought there were a few Oscar winning performances from the boys in white. Fines at worst.

Vince has to come in - not sure who goes out. Possibly Brayshaw, who has been quiet so far.
Did Casey play this weekend? If so, how did Kent go. If he's knocking down the door, he could also come in for Hannan.

 

[dees arent rabble]

I think we missed burn big time

 

[dees arent rabble]

Hannan should stay in the side. Going to be a good player

 

[stretcharmstrong]

Melksham the **** out

 

[Bartram_Class]

Melksham, ANB out.
Kent, Vince in.

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Clarry to share the votes around and only pick up 2 Brownlow votes the gready bugger.

 

[BG32]

Hogan and Lewis both did open handers use the slider at 20 seconds to see the point of contact http://www.afl.com.au/video/2017-04-02/is-hogan-in-trouble-for-this-hit and as for Lewis it happened right below me in the pocket and was watching at the time it was exactly what Vince did to Isaac Smith and he got a week i recall

 

[CTHORANGE]

Pending any suspensions

Out: Hannan and Melksham

In: Kent and Vince

 

[schmuttt]

Is it stiff to drop Hannan and/or ANB after one poor game each? I'm not really sure either way but curious to see what you guys think.

 

[CTHORANGE]

Is it stiff to drop Hannan and/or ANB after one poor game each? I'm not really sure either way but curious to see what you guys think.

Think Kent is in our best 22, and Hannan is in his spot at the moment, and Hannan didn't do a whole lot today, no doubt he'll get more chances in the future though if dropped. ANB can run in midfield as well, Hannan doesn't seem to have this ability, yet anyway

 

[schmuttt]

Think Kent is in our best 22, and Hannan is in his spot at the moment, and Hannan didn't do a whole lot today, no doubt he'll get more chances in the future though if dropped. ANB can run in midfield as well, Hannan doesn't seem to have this ability, yet anyway

I agree, just interesting to see if Goodwin is willing to give them a 'tiebreaker' 3rd game so to speak to play well and hold their spot.

Honestly as we're going up against Geelong I really want Kent in the side.

 

[LeverPuller]

Is it stiff to drop Hannan and/or ANB after one poor game each? I'm not really sure either way but curious to see what you guys think.

I think you look at who is sitting there waiting to come in. Considering both Kent and Kennedy are there and we knew that forward slot was going to be hot property coming in, I wouldn't be surprised if Hannan is dropped.

Nib is interesting partly because I don't think Harmes played that well either, he shat me off when he didn't have a ping during his I50 charge in the fourth that lead to Dom's goal.