List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[Cousin of Daicos]

Someone posted a rumour that Jhye Clarke has told the Cats that he won't sign another contract with them and wants to be traded to us. Grain of salt.

Hope it's true if only to actually see the Cats not get away with salary cap rorting for once

 

[Harry O]

With Tom Wilson likely leaving at years end, what are our Cat B list plans for 2024?
Too soon for the WA Basketballer in the US
Any cricketers like Zak Evans in the pipeline ?
A number of clubs like Carlton and StKilsa are big on taking Irish players this year apparently

 

[gerryg400]

Jeez Ollie looks like an awesome value pick up for the Cats. He's playing well.

He may very well be watching another finals series from the sidelines though.

 

[Apex36]

Jyhe Clark only 1 game this year. Unless he played all 22 next season then you'd expect a 3rd rounder would be enough.

Suspect this is just Pies fans having fun and that there's no truth to him wanting out.

He was a top 10 pick from last year. His value isn’t going to plummet that far in the space of 12 months, stop kidding yourself.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

He was a top 10 pick from last year. His value isn’t going to plummet that far in the space of 12 months, stop kidding yourself.

Dealing with Geelong aswell... they think every one of their list is worth 2 firsts.

 

[KinderSmock]

If he genuinely wants to be at the Pies he will be. Cats won’t force him to the PSD.

But he has a contract which means Geelong can just be like, "wait a year, mate".

 

[KinderSmock]

Jyhe Clark only 1 game this year. Unless he played all 22 next season then you'd expect a 3rd rounder would be enough.

Suspect this is just Pies fans having fun and that there's no truth to him wanting out.

Frampton cost a third and he was more on the fringe than Clark, who is young and shows first round potential.

 

[Oddzonfavourite]

He's the one, I didn't know he was off contract. We were linked to him in the past

Already got Cameron, they're both the 0.9 goal per game shit truck ruck when played forward but Cameron is a much better 1st ruck, wait for King/Naughton.

 

[Mick F]

There was a bloke who played for the Cats VFL side George Stephens I would not mind trying to get him as he already has the body for it.
He also looks like he knows how to play, someone on here said just give me george Stephens I will be happy after watching him in action I agree with that sentiment, he looks like a bull in there.

George Stephens???

 

[RobJD]

There was a bloke who played for the Cats VFL side George Stephens I would not mind trying to get him as he already has the body for it.
He also looks like he knows how to play, someone on here said just give me george Stephens I will be happy after watching him in action I agree with that sentiment, he looks like a bull in there.

Agree, thought he was their best player - bit of a worry for the Cats, they lost on Friday night when we were effectively without our best two players (Moore and Naics), they lost badly on Saturday and their best player in the VFL isn't even on the club's list. This year they've currently got a first round and a forth round pick, so not a strong draft hand.

 

[Jen2310]

Agree, thought he was their best player - bit of a worry for the Cats, they lost on Friday night when we were effectively without our best two players (Moore and Naics), they lost badly on Saturday and their best player in the VFL isn't even on the club's list. This year they've currently got a first round and a forth round pick, so not a strong draft hand.

They have no depth, Geelong. Outside their best 22-26 players, it falls away really dramatically. Given their VFL team lost to ours, who are a bunch of kids by over 70 points.

 

[Harry O]

George Stephens???

George Stevens played for Vic Country in this years under 18 titles and is expected by some to be drafted in the 20-50 range.
Good player but with mature body is the scope for improvement less than others ?

 

[Bianconeri]

George Stevens played for Vic Country in this years under 18 titles and is expected by some to be drafted in the 20-50 range.
Good player but with mature body is the scope for improvement less than others ?

I’d prefer to get someone in with a body to compete especially as our midfield is ageing rather than someone who’s going to take three to four pre seasons to become AFL ready.

 

[Mick F]

George Stevens played for Vic Country in this years under 18 titles and is expected by some to be drafted in the 20-50 range.
Good player but with mature body is the scope for improvement less than others ?

Thank you.

 

[TradeDraft]

Someone posted a rumour that Jhye Clarke has told the Cats that he won't sign another contract with them and wants to be traded to us. Grain of salt.

Like 99% Rumors like that

 

[Primetime Pricey]

Any key defenders available via FA? its our weak point so i hope we target that area. We need a FB. Its obvious when we come up against big fwds like Curnow, Cameron, Lynch etc. Moore is awesome but is undersized sometimes.

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[Oddzonfavourite]

Wouldn't mind Ned and the Iron Maiden from that lot, not overly expensive either you'd think.

 

[No SPIN]

Spot on, but at least one of them can be excused for being played out of position. Grundy would improve us coming back as an 85% ruckman on a reduced salary. The improvement would just be marginal.

If he plays like he did during Gawns absence it will be well above marginal improvement.

 

[MooreDaicos]

O Hollands from the GCS is up for trade too. Any good?

 

[MooreDaicos]

Can anyone make a list of the young fellas, 19-22, who have speed, bulls in the midfield, x factor and potential midfielders that might be up for a trade for this year and next? There are unknowns that I would like to check out and keep an eye on. An excel sheet, maybe?

 

[RobJD]

Can anyone make a list of the young fellas, 19-22, who have speed, bulls in the midfield, x factor and potential midfielders that might be up for a trade for this year and next? There are unknowns that I would like to check out and keep an eye on. An excel sheet, maybe?

Tarryn Thomas

 

[MooreDaicos]

Tarryn Thomas

He would be an asset, only thing is his treatment of women and if the club wants to have that sort of person in the team. Would it ruffle the feathers of the other players creating tension between them?

 

[sr36]

Wouldn't mind Ned and the Iron Maiden from that lot, not overly expensive either you'd think.

Who? Are you channeling Rex Hunt?

 

[adammania9]

Can anyone make a list of the young fellas, 19-22, who have speed, bulls in the midfield, x factor and potential midfielders that might be up for a trade for this year and next? There are unknowns that I would like to check out and keep an eye on. An excel sheet, maybe?

Finn Callaghan. But every side in Vic would be hoping to have a crack when he's OOC next year.