List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion

[CasuallyDressed]

Taranto will cost plenty in terms of $$$ and trade.
I'd rather we held our first rounders for a little while yet.

The first rounder is looking like a pick in the teens, would gladly move it for a young stud like Taranto.

They'd want more, obviously.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

I think Taranto will go to Richmond as part of the Martin deal

Martin isn't leaving Richmond. I would be very surprised if Martin is in another club’s jumper next year. I would think he would retire before playing for another club....

 

[soreplums]

All of those clubs are also into JDG

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

So we're currently linked in the media to McStay, Logue, Taranto, Hill. Am I missing anyone?

Thats about it l think, but pretty sure someone else will be linked to us in the next month or two....

 

[Apex36]

Martin isn't leaving Richmond. I would be very surprised if Martin is in another club’s jumper next year. I would think he would retire before playing for another club....

Not really sure you’ve been paying attention for the past 6-8 months then. High chance Martin goes to Sydney next year.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Not really sure you’ve been paying attention for the past 6-8 months then. High chance Martin goes to Sydney next year.

I have been paying attention, and imo he won’t leave Richmond, and if he did want to live in Sydney, where he has family, does he need to be playing footy? He may want to do something completely different with his life, that's why l think he would rather retire then play for another club...

 

[neilk]

View attachment 1440493
Draft night 6 years ago…

So Nick is on Josh's right in the dark jumper. He's grown since then.

 

[soreplums]

Have we finished paying Beams’ salary yet?

 

[Apex36]

I have been paying attention, and imo he won’t leave Richmond, and if he did want to live in Sydney, where he has family, does he need to be playing footy? He may want to do something completely different with his life, that's why l think he would rather retire then play for another club...

Non of the noise around him indicates that. He’s already seriously considered leaving Richmond twice. I don’t think he has the loyalty to the club you believe he does.

 

[neilk]

If I was Mihocek, I would be pissed at the club at the McStay offer of $600k per year for 5 years. That deal should frankly be going to Mihocek as he is a far superior player to McStay and did the club a favor by staying on the rookie list for 3 years and getting paid unders while our salary cap situation was a mess.

McStay isn't good enough to elevate the team to being a contender. If we have money to spend, I would rather bank the savings for a better player in next year's free agency market.

We have zero idea what is, or is not, being offered.

 

[manicpie]

Martin isn't leaving Richmond. I would be very surprised if Martin is in another club’s jumper next year. I would think he would retire before playing for another club....

It's already pretty expected that he is leaving. He has more family and friends, as well as his dads old bike club in sydney.

 

[Jen2310]

So guessing

McStay as free agent
Taranto + Hill fir our 2022 1st
Logue…not sure how this gets done (2023 1st? Or it doesn’t get done

I was hoping we’d somehow be getting into / higher in the draft but the above isn’t a bad haul

We wont give away our 1st this year

But if de goey goes, we give GWS our compo pick instead.

 

[Apex36]

We wont give away our 1st this year

But if de goey goes, we give GWS our compo pick instead.

We won’t get a compo pick for JDG if we get McStay via FA. Or at least the compo won’t be anywhere near enough to satisfy GWS.

 

[Jen2310]

We won’t get a compo pick for JDG if we get McStay via FA. Or at least the compo won’t be anywhere near enough to satisfy GWS.

Right, I forgot. Or whatever we get when you force a trade with his club of choice.

 

[SchuPie]

We wont give away our 1st this year

But if de goey goes, we give GWS our compo pick instead.

I think we might use our first
I think we’ll be looking for ways to get back in higher than our original pick using a range of 2022/23 picks

If JDG leaves were not getting much compo w McStay coming in
If he leaves, I assume we’ll match and force a trade
Edit: in this scenario, the pick/s we receive JDG will be better than our first so I think we’ll trade it

 

[Queenie Hearts]

We wont give away our 1st this year

But if de goey goes, we give GWS our compo pick instead.

You can trade lower picks for McStay - Brisbane need picks for father/son points.

Get a first round compo for De Goey for a trade and still have 2022 first.

Judging by the way Wrighty moved around picks last year as a chess master, I back him in to get done what needs to happen. Seems to have good relationships with other clubs. He also moves quickly and early based on last year’s machinations.




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The Royal Sampler]

So we're currently linked in the media to McStay, Logue, Taranto, Hill. Am I missing anyone?

Bruhn.

 

[neilk]

We seem to have become a serious destination club.

 

[MyManLynch]

So Nick is on Josh's right in the dark jumper. He's grown since then.

I think he ate most of the cake…

 

[Jafo]

So we're currently linked in the media to McStay, Logue, Taranto, Hill. Am I missing anyone?

Wouldn’t be surprised if we somehow get linked to Dusty as well

 

[sideswipe]

Have we finished paying Beams’ salary yet?

Yes. Don’t be a clown.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[stormskye]

James hird was asked what GWS are doing to try and keep Taranto, he simply replied “whatever it takes”

 

[soreplums]

Yes. Don’t be a clown.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Serious question. Wasn’t sure if any of it was carried over to this year.
Disappointing from you.

 

[Go Woods]

What would it cost to get Taranto and Hill to come over?

And if we do land McStay, Taranto and Hill who’s spots in the 22 are they takings.

Rather we chase Taranto & Hill and forget about McStay. I don’t see how we could afford all three and re-sign JDG.....

 

[Basil brush]

I am a massive Jordy fan (as a player), but if we lost him for Taranto, that is almost a no brainer