NMBB
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 3, 2021
- 8,615
- 14,107
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yes - therefore we're deep in talks with his manager
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA
- Thread starter Jen2310
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Might be some players
I am sure I posted this somewhere ages ago - one of the dads that I know, his son played with Wardlaw and against Sheezel if I remember correctly.
He watched one carnival - maybe at 16s level? And he likened Allan to Patrick Cripps. Reckoned he would be a gun. I think the older carnival Allan was injured?
Allan is meant to have a good tank??
So yeah I don't view them as similar. I see Allan as much more likely to become a midfielder. And people may doubt that from what we have seen but let's wait and see.
I am sure I posted this somewhere ages ago - one of the dads that I know, his son played with Wardlaw and against Sheezel if I remember correctly.
He watched one carnival - maybe at 16s level? And he likened Allan to Patrick Cripps. Reckoned he would be a gun. I think the older carnival Allan was injured?
Allan is meant to have a good tank??
So yeah I don't view them as similar. I see Allan as much more likely to become a midfielder. And people may doubt that from what we have seen but let's wait and see.
I'd like to revisit obtaining Ollie Wines. After Tay's exit and successful transition into a Sydney side brimming with midfielders I'd like to think that we could offer Wines more midfield time than he's currently getting at Port.
He's tough, big and would compliment our younger outside runners (both Daicos's, McGuane, Allan etc....) if we could give him 4 years.
He's tough, big and would compliment our younger outside runners (both Daicos's, McGuane, Allan etc....) if we could give him 4 years.
jathanas
Premium Platinum
'We're not there yet': Pies face tough list decisions on star veterans
Craig McRae has been chatting to premiership veterans Scott Pendlebury and Steele Sidebottom regularly about their future beyond this seasonwww.afl.com.au
...
"But we're not there yet ... respectfully, we want to honour our greats and those two in particular, they live in that bracket.
"Funnily enough when it's a premiership list it's bulletproof, and then when it's not, it's got holes everywhere in it.
"But we're going to have a bit more of a futuristic look at that ... I'll leave that to others to make all those finite details.
"We'll be collective on making sure we get the right direction for this footy club."
...
To translate:
We'll let Steele and Pendles enjoy the next few games because they've earned it.
We'll make a call on them at the end of the year with our focus firmly on the best interests of the club.
Keep in mind that Fly's arse is getting roasted by the media (and some fans) yet he will come across as respectful and well-considered.
Yeah last night against Carlton he was like the Ollie wines of old. We are definitely lacking in the inside grunt dept without Mitchell, Adams etc.
Who’d want to be a coach..
if we had youngsters coming through to replace them, and we dont think we can contend next year, then by all means it could be time
but we really dont have anyone young coming through and we have poor depth, there is no point going into freefall like north did.
much better to have a managed hand over and use them strategically for a final year
Carlthetruth
All Australian
- Sep 14, 2021
- 705
- 853
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
What is it with Wil Brodie, we have Bytel and Long and adding Brodie! Ffs, not good enough!! Vanilla upon vanilla with more vanilla.
could be. so who would you keep from the older brigade?
sr36
TheBrownDog
We talk a lot on here about all these half backs we have and recruit, meanwhile we've had no injuries to the area, Markov and Noble are pretty ordinary and we've only got blokes who aren't ready and probably will never be ready as depth behind them. It's probably our weakest area. And it's showing with our inability to transition.
Jen2310
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #9,737
Prob pendles for 1 more year
Howe has the trigger, so one more for him
Ideally sidey should be the first to go, we gotta start the transition, otherwise come 2025 we will have so many to retire at once
Elliott, mitchell, Cox, mihocek all ending their contracts.
sr36
TheBrownDog
We need to keep Howe.
We’ve got a good one but we need him in the midfield
I have a feeling jamie will call time a bit earlier than we might hope
On the other hand I hope we keep Cox on the list for another five years. I cant see why his game would drop off any time soon
I always wanted to see sidey finish his career with an easy run in the fwd line. I think he could do that at the level for a while. The problem is we have guys in the fwd line who should be graduating into the midfield but arent up to it
anyway, id prefer to see the transition while these guys are still on the list for depth, rather than delisting them and being caught short
On the other hand I hope we keep Cox on the list for another five years. I cant see why his game would drop off any time soon
I always wanted to see sidey finish his career with an easy run in the fwd line. I think he could do that at the level for a while. The problem is we have guys in the fwd line who should be graduating into the midfield but arent up to it
anyway, id prefer to see the transition while these guys are still on the list for depth, rather than delisting them and being caught short
- Aug 16, 2009
- 4,387
- 8,097
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Celtics, Canucks
Happy that there’s no intel leaking from the club at this point as to possible targets
Really hope the club has some interesting names in mind as the names we’re floating on here kind of scare me about the state of our list if they’re being mentioned
Just hoping we either bring in or draft young talent (somehow)
Really hope the club has some interesting names in mind as the names we’re floating on here kind of scare me about the state of our list if they’re being mentioned
Just hoping we either bring in or draft young talent (somehow)
I would give WHE 2 more years
I would go 1 year contracts from here on....
1 year with triggers for a 2nd
Problem is our older guys are often our best players. Steele and Pendles have had a couple dud games this year but they have games where they are still in our top 5.
We don’t win the GF without Pendles and Howe’s 4th qtr.
With Howe’s injury run the last couple years you’d think it’s him and Steele to finish this year. They should make that call now so they can have the send off game they deserve.
Pendles, Mitchell and Cox to go the end of 2025.
We don’t win the GF without Pendles and Howe’s 4th qtr.
With Howe’s injury run the last couple years you’d think it’s him and Steele to finish this year. They should make that call now so they can have the send off game they deserve.
Pendles, Mitchell and Cox to go the end of 2025.
Because he’s a fairy that relies on being the 3rd option floating in from the side. With Hawkins out there is more attention on him being the 2nd option.
To be fair to Berry he has been played a lot as a defensive mid (tackling beast & HF). That could be because as you rightly point out he doesn't get enough of it. However our mids offer nothing defensively.
On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Some big decisions ahead.
Who is the person in charge? Who is the decision maker?
Sam Mitchell on SEN was fascinating. He talked about their strategy meetings and how they revisit it etc It sounded like they spent a hell of a long time putting together their long term vision. It's not surprising they are doing well.
If they all wanted to go around again then they would let them but on the knowledge that there are no guarantees. In a finals game I will trust Pendles, Howe and Steele over most of our list.
Who is the person in charge? Who is the decision maker?
Sam Mitchell on SEN was fascinating. He talked about their strategy meetings and how they revisit it etc It sounded like they spent a hell of a long time putting together their long term vision. It's not surprising they are doing well.
If they all wanted to go around again then they would let them but on the knowledge that there are no guarantees. In a finals game I will trust Pendles, Howe and Steele over most of our list.
satanshoof101
Team Captain
- May 22, 2022
- 435
- 632
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Max Gruzewski has 3 goals in a half hopefully a future 2nd could get it done, perfect Mihocek replacement.
Edit: 5.1 goals for the whole game
Edit: 5.1 goals for the whole game
Last edited:
