-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA
- Thread starter Jen2310
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I’m just selfish and would like Sidebottom to play on next year, so that Pendles can break the ‘Most games with a teammate (Steele)’ record.
sr36
TheBrownDog
And where would you play him?
Apex36
Hall of Famer
- Mar 26, 2014
- 40,777
- 87,570
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
WHE’s problem has always been that his best position is deep forward, but he’s also more useful further up the ground when we have a full compliment of marking forwards available.
It’s no coincidence his best year statistically was in 2018 playing deep while Elliott was unavailable. Many on this board have been unable to see his value when he’s not kicking goals though.
Likely not to happen anyway.
Is his ego too big to play a role, or does he want to be FF/CHF?
Play him as a tall, not necessarily FF/ CHF
sr36
TheBrownDog
He's not great in the air. I think he's a wingman unless he improves in a contest
Sort of like Goldsack finals insurance?
Straight swap for ash Johnson
- Dec 16, 2013
- 9,225
- 9,501
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
For those saying trade mcreery last night showed to me how much his pace and pressure is important to us
To me he is a must keep
To me he is a must keep
Wingmen are runners first and foremost.
If he has the run/tank, ok then as a winger.
Is his value as forward only if he’s good in the air…what about playing him as a forward? Beau plays for his attributes, can’t the same apply for Lukocius? He had a good season last year?
What about Peter wright for cox role
I’ll put my hand up and say I was one who didn’t see his value and thought we needed to go past him.
I still think that last point is valid and we should expect youth on the list to force him out but I appreciate him holding the line and no one has jumped up to force him out.
He’s also been really solid this year so I’m all for him going on.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
will Brodie would still be an upgrade on any mids we have in reserve. Hes a b grader but an upgrade on long or sully. Freo would be keen to get him off the books as he’s got 2 years left.
His 22 and 23 stats aren’t bad. Would offer coverage for Mitchell and Degoey. Reckon we need degoey to be spending 70% forward from now on to prolong his career.
2022
2023
His 22 and 23 stats aren’t bad. Would offer coverage for Mitchell and Degoey. Reckon we need degoey to be spending 70% forward from now on to prolong his career.
2022
2023
Stuart1966
Debutant
- Jul 20, 2024
- 72
- 201
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Ben Hobbs would be a good 34 disposals in the VFL today
He is behind Merrett Parish and Cardwell was a high draft pick about 3 years ago and has played some good footy at AFL level
He is behind Merrett Parish and Cardwell was a high draft pick about 3 years ago and has played some good footy at AFL level
HoraceStrasbork
All Australian
- Dec 23, 2023
- 704
- 941
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Would a swap for Joe Tichards get the job done?
WHE is a highly skilled player that is an elite overhead mark for his size.
However, his really good games are not often enough. I think he is almost a victim of being asked to plug gaps for the team. I reckon if he was left forward for a season he would kick 40 goals.
Stuart1966
Debutant
- Jul 20, 2024
- 72
- 201
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Maybe Bomber need a good small forward that is creative around goals
My dream recruit, but unless I’ve missed something it was openly reported he had or was about to sign on? With North looking better and him looking like the type that wants out of the limelight we were always going to be a hard sell.
I agree with the poster that said yesterday and our past month confirms for me we are desperate for another mid. First of all our midfield is so weak that even when heavily tagged Nick is still the one that has to lift us up offensively. Pendles at times but he plays a specific defensive role in the midfield so can’t get too loose even if his body allowed it. Crisp did it for a couple of games and that’s it, no one else stood out.
We are constantly taking away from our forward line to play our +1 in the midfield (yesterday that was Jordy and Beau constantly around our midfield stoppages leaving 5 forward) and if you want further signs of desperation against Geelong a few weeks back we also had our defence playing 5 and sending Sidebottom to +2 in the midfield, hence why you saw our zone stretched and absurd situations like Moore on Stengle when the ball went that way.
Our stoppage work has been terrible and I can put our Essendon loss, Dogs loss, Hawks and Geelong loss down to our inability to get our hands on the bloody ball in the middle (think we were third last for possessions in the comp ahead of WC and Richmond only).
Not sure who and I don’t mind if they’re not an elite player like LDU but we need a high possession inside/out midfielder to complement Nick. Don’t mind us playing Mitchell if he had that release, Jordy half forward and +1 in the middle when needed and Pendles in the Sidey role.
- Sep 30, 2009
- 5,292
- 7,914
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yeah. Reckon on current projections McGuane is pretty much a lock for a bid in the top 10 IMO.
His accumulation and skills more than make up for his lack of size.
He was dynamic last night.
- Sep 30, 2009
- 5,292
- 7,914
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I’ve mentioned him as my own personal preference in terms of a trade target.
Reckon he’d be a great pickup.
But watch out you’ll get the ‘truth’ coming after you!
- Sep 30, 2009
- 5,292
- 7,914
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Not sure they’d let him go, but I’d have a crack.
He’s never going to be an elite player IMO. But he’s still the same player he was as a junior and that’s pretty good in the right team. A Taylor Adams clone who is an inside bull.
If we want an inside style mid not necessarily premium but solid enough to add to the mix, Berry from Adelaide seems to fit the bill.
Hobbs may be OK but unsure of contract status etc. to understand if thats realistic and he would look at it.
Hobbs may be OK but unsure of contract status etc. to understand if thats realistic and he would look at it.
We have no currency so we have to look at salary dumps so to speak.
Will Brodie is one.
Caleb Daniel has been mentioned. Even jack macrae from the doggies
Peter wright maybe on the outer at dons
No stars but slight improvements on what we have perhaps.
Will Brodie is one.
Caleb Daniel has been mentioned. Even jack macrae from the doggies
Peter wright maybe on the outer at dons
No stars but slight improvements on what we have perhaps.
