-
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Semi Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round FW1 Winner: TBA!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA
- Thread starter Jen2310
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I know you have to give something to get something but that would kill me. I love Bobby Hill. He electrifies our army and is in our hearts for ever after that grand final performance.
- Mar 28, 2023
- 13,350
- 25,966
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
No. That's not happening. We're not giving Normie away.
There is not a hope in hell. New rumour please- one that at least is a one in a million chance of coming off.
Christian Petracca 'wants to go' | "The truth is that he wants to go. What I don't know, is whether that will lead to a trade request." Tom Morris' BIG update on Christian Petracca and... | By Footy on NineFacebook
"The truth is that he wants to go. What I don't know, is whether that will lead to a trade request." Tom Morris' BIG update on Christian Petracca and...www.facebook.com
Apex36
Hall of Famer
- Mar 26, 2014
- 40,031
- 84,911
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Not sure Melbourne would be that interested in Allan tbh, I don’t think he’s shown enough at this point where they’d feel he has a lot of value. Also he’s contracted which means he’d have to agree to the trade too, and I can’t see him happily leaving the pies to go anywhere other than Freo or maybe Hawthorn given his Dad’s history.That in a weird way actually makes sense! As much as SOTY’s post does seem to hold weight I can’t get my head around what a deal for Petracca looks like when most have ruled us out of the Smith chase due to a lack of currency
Best I have is a 2025 1st + Allan + ? which is obviously a simplified version of what a deal could look like. The curveball would be if the Petracca’s have made up their mind that he’s out. It has the potential to be the ugliest trade ever.
True
- Apr 17, 2017
- 1,787
- 2,492
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Friz, a Doubting Thomas?
How on earth could we satisfy Melb's hefty trade demands? 2024 2nd plus 2025 1st plus 2025 2nd? Offering all that would screw us for any father-son picks next year.
Surely another Premiership contending team could come up with two 1sts without too much trouble?
- Apr 24, 2013
- 2,014
- 4,270
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Melbourne have apparently been sniffing around McInnes, so him, this years 2nd rounder, F1st, plus ? - starting to get close to an equitable trade.
Hoping that Trac has a case for breach of duty of care or similar that can be used as leverage.
Hoping that Trac has a case for breach of duty of care or similar that can be used as leverage.
Gee, AFL not having the guts to bring in two year trading might have some ramifications for us. Would make things a fair bit easier in this hypothetical.
Might save us in this situation
- Mar 11, 2018
- 523
- 450
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Petracca will be 29 in January and there's no chance Collingwood could get him,I personally wouldn't chase him anyway
Scodog10
Brownlow Medallist
No neither am I it’s mostly me flying a kite at this stage (as we all are with it firmly in the rumour column) although there is the potential to move Ed to Freo for something, but not sure how that looks.
If by some miracle this were all true I think our best bet would be ANB nominates Adelaide and we get involved in the Houston trade. A 1st + Houston is enough for Petracca if he forces the deal so you’d have to unlock that one for Port which feels more achievable.
Do_Beta_Rapport
Club Legend
- Jun 23, 2022
- 1,419
- 2,689
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Tend to agree. I think it will take him an entire season to find fitness and form.
Still can’t get his HR over 110 for extended periods.
Ed Allan l'm not sure about using in any trades. He seems one player, clubs would go for, but on the other hand l just feel he's now realising his talent and we have seen that in the VFL over the past month or so.
Another preseason and l think he could become a very good AFL player over the next 12 months.
We seem to like the idea of rehabbing players over the years- Tangles, Dawes, Scharenberg, Begg so who knows and hopefully Trac’s injury isn’t too bad. Namely for him. Forget what club he might play for in future.
Though I think the one we did miss out on after a medical was Stevie J.
I'm not sure in what world a trade for Petracca gets done if he were to come on the market. Our only realistic case would be if he (Petracca) is steadfast in his desire to leave publicly, and nominates only Collingwood, it may force Melbourne's hand a little.
I'm not concerned about his age or the length of contract. Is a matchwinner on his day and to have him play alongside Naicos, Degoey, Pendles etc in the middle - oh my goodness.
He is one of handful of players I think you move heaven and earth to get should he be available.
I'm not concerned about his age or the length of contract. Is a matchwinner on his day and to have him play alongside Naicos, Degoey, Pendles etc in the middle - oh my goodness.
He is one of handful of players I think you move heaven and earth to get should he be available.
Agreed with the bolded here - even though I highly doubt a move happens, as these tend to have a habit of fizzling out as most of what we hear is media "over-hype" and rumors, and after a while everyone forgets about it within a month or two.
However, on the off-chance it's a real possibility to happen, we have to make sure we put ourselves in the box seat for him.
Players in the top 5-10 bracket league wide, seldom get on the move - I can only really think of a handful since 2000 (Buddy, Judd, Gaz and maybe a Danger/Jez Cameron?), so can't afford to miss this opportunity if it truly presents itself.
Scodog10
Brownlow Medallist
McInnes was doing the same at VFL level 12 months ago ditto Macrae. It’s a big step up from knowing what you’re capable of at that level to doing it at the top level. If this were to become a live discussion on acquiring the best forward of centre mid in the game given what else we have to offer I think views will soften.
Will Trac be missing a block of footy early next season. I thought he said on Nova, that he wouldn't be doing anything to physical for another few months or early into next year.
The only concern would be the weight loss and muscle mass, and how long it takes for him to be able to get back into full fitness and ready for the physicality of AFL footy...
The only concern would be the weight loss and muscle mass, and how long it takes for him to be able to get back into full fitness and ready for the physicality of AFL footy...
Normally I would agree with you - that it's a bit of gamble taking on a player at a high value of the back of a significant injury.
However Trac seems a very determined and professional bloke - he's very big on looking after his body/recovering well, works hard on his nutrition and exercise - and as reference idolizes our own Scott Pendlebury for his work and diligence to recovery and health etc
If there was a player you'd be comfortable taking a bit of the injury risk on - it's these caliber players that you know will do everything in their power to be top-shape every time they step on the field.
Don't be surprised if McInnes is at the Saints next year
- Sep 30, 2009
- 5,242
- 7,783
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Personally I think it’s a last Hail Mary at a premiership before the absolute cliff comes for this team. It’s one I’d rather not take.
We need to rebuild our list with youth. As great as Petracca is right at this stage, he will be 29 years old before the start of next season and is on a massive contract with 5 years left.
Given his playing style I can’t see him maintaining his output until the end of that deal. Similar to Dusty, who only just turned 33 and dropped off a cliff in terms of performance for the last couple of years, I can see the same happening with Petracca.
Ultimately IMO we’d be paying a ridiculous amount for 3 years of top shelf football from him.
Last edited:
