List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[stormskye]

Petracca will be 29. He’s not 25. Even if he wants out, his age affects his value whether dees supporters like it or not.

It’s the same reason I always opposed Elliot trade etc. as good as he is, he was 29ish when talk of trade to Brisbane. Would have got us a second rounder. Not worth

Adam’s had f all value after 30.

 

[Dan Moody]

If he desperately wanted to come to Collingwood then I’d say a future 1st into a sweetener like Macrae/McInnes or Lipinksi would get it done if we guaranteed Melbourne to take on his wage.

LOL, I literally mentioned this exact scenario to another Pies supporter today.

 

[SchuPie]

Adelaide radio reporting Mark Keane has officially requested a trade back to Vic from the Crows

F3

 

[Doc1763]

looking at Trac 'jogging' on the news, looked like Cliffy Young would be able to lap him.

 

[Fat Jesus]

If Christian nominates us, it will happen.

 

[SchuPie]

If he desperately wanted to come to Collingwood then I’d say a future 1st into a sweetener like Macrae/McInnes or Lipinksi would get it done if we guaranteed Melbourne to take on his wage.

They can have all of them for Trac

 

[stormskye]

If Christian nominates us, it will happen.

Get the old man to work his magic

 

[Fat Jesus]

looking at Trac 'jogging' on the news, looked like Cliffy Young would be able to lap him.

Cliff young was a world champ dude. Lapped everyone going

 

[sr36]

Twomey said that Lukosius contract is two more years but heavily back ended and close to a million a season, who knows if we could afford that

Let's not get their list manager to replace Wright.

They've never made finals and their salary cap seems to always be stuffed.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Cliff young was a world champ dude. Lapped everyone going

Not sure gumboots would work in the midfield.

 

[Doc1763]

Cliff young was a world champ dude. Lapped everyone going

he just refused to stop

 

[thommo_legend]

Future first, hawks second and Allan, and its no where near enough for Trac. Can't see how we could get a deal done

 

[stormskye]

Let's not get their list manager to replace Wright.

They've never made finals and their salary cap seems to always be stuffed.

Unfortunately for them they have to offer overs to stay. Sadly it’s the same concerns I have for a tassie team. Retention.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Future first, hawks second and Allan, and its no where near enough for Trac. Can't see how we could get a deal done

Forget Edward mate. He's staying.
When a player nominates a club it always gets done.
Melbourne will enjoy the cap relief.

 

[pablo disco bar]

DO NOT TRADE MCREERY

Pick 44 an absolute steal

Young fast and a game changer

 

[sr36]

Unfortunately for them they have to offer overs to stay. Sadly it’s the same concerns I have for a tassie team. Retention.

I'm with you on Tassie. At least with GC they'll keep getting enough locals coming through that it shouldn't be the same problem for long. And once they're good, it'll disappear - Sydney and Brisbane keep them all and poach.

 

[VinnieB]

Did you mean Peatling? Perryman hasn’t played any midfield lately

Yes. Sorry about that. Peatling is the guy we should go for. Sporting the cave man look at the moment.

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

I mean, I don't wanna smash everyone's dreams, but Petracca just won't happen. Essentially Melbourne, in the window would be giving their best player to another team that wants to win next year's flag and wants to win now.

It's just stupid to believe in this. The Dees might as well trade Gawn, Lever and May as well, given Viney and ANB are on the way out.

And even if we get past all of this. Melbourne absolutely hate us. They haven't forgotten Brayshaw.

 

[sr36]

If he’s owed $2m that’s a pick 40+ or they’re paying a chunk of it.

If he's owed that much, it's a pick under 40 going out with him.

 

[sr36]

I mean, I don't wanna smash everyone's dreams, but Petracca just won't happen. Essentially Melbourne, in the window would be giving their best player to another team that wants to win next year's flag and wants to win now.

It's just stupid to believe in this. The Dees might as well trade Gawn, Lever and May as well, given Viney and ANB are on the way out.

And even if we get past all of this. Melbourne absolutely hate us. They haven't forgotten Brayshaw.

Viney?

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

Viney?

North looking at him

 

[GreekLunatic]

What happens if petrecca nominates us

 

[MooreDaicos]

Dogs board saying Macrae is out the door, wants more mid time.

 

[Scodog10]

If he's owed that much, it's a pick under 40 going out with him.

That feels unders because I think he’s a significant upgrade on Bowes, but I wouldn’t bat an eyelid if it was a goer.

 

[Piewithsauce13]

Caroline Wilson just said she doesn’t think he will leave or request a trade…..welcome to Collingwood Trac!!! Wooooooo