List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[JLC]

My dad has pictures of your dad on his wall.

Just beautiful.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

You've clearly missed the point.
We're not giving up a daicos. It's not happening.
And doesn't matter what they're worth it's a moot point. We are not trading him in any way shape or form nor in the market for or in any realistic way getting Christian petracca. So stop wasting our ****ing time contemplating it.

My advice is to not hang out in this thread if you don't want to read ridiculous trades.

 

[NMBB]

So Mark Keane left Collingwood because he was homesick and now wants to leave Adelaide because I presume he is homesick back to the place he left because he was homesick.

He is Irish and has lived in Adelaide

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

My dad has pictures of your dad on his wall.

Just beautiful.

After watching that, get him to the Pies. He needs to be in a black n white guernsey. Just seems natural.

Imagine the commentary of ...." Josh Daicos handballs to Petracca, Petracca to Nick Daicos back to Petracca and Petracca with a thumping kick from 50 kicks a brilliant goal"......

 

[BEEG]

Battle would be perfect and doesn't cost a thing.

Real missed opportunity.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

My dad has pictures of your dad on his wall.

Just beautiful.

Had to stop himself saying "I'm a Collingwood supporter."

 

[Run n Spread]

My advice is to not hang out in this thread if you don't want to read ridiculous trades.

Cleaned up the post. Was annoyed at something else and just venting on here.
Anyway I doubt he even requests a trade. It wouldn't go through and he'd be left with egg on his face.
Imo I reckon he's pissed how his injury was handled and the club and this is strategic leaking by someone close tonhim

 

[Run n Spread]

The ones I reckon are replaceable and maybe currency are mcreery Noble or Schultz (but doubt the club would do that)
Priority is.mids a k p d and kpf. Or we just rebuild with what we have.

 

[unplugged]

Had to stop himself saying "I'm a Collingwood supporter."

"The reason why I'm a WAS A Collingwood supporter "

 

[cfc19902010]

don’t ruin the fun

the one thing about Caz is she's consistent

consistently wrong

 

[The Phantom]

After watching that, get him to the Pies. He needs to be in a black n white guernsey. Just seems natural.

Imagine the commentary of ...." Josh Daicos handballs to Petracca, Petracca to Nick Daicos back to Petracca and Petracca with a thumping kick from 50 kicks a brilliant goal"......

You left JDG out of the chain.

 

[cakewalk06]

Harley Reid would be a Jeremy Cameron type trade with 3 first round picks needed...

no it would require a lot more. The Jeremy Cameron trade is a bit of a myth. Was three shitty first-round picks … 13,15,20. A bargain for Geelong. We paid more for Treloar for example… 2 x pick no.7s

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Yeah, it's unlikely we get him, but honestly... if we got him, he and Nick Daicos would be one of the best 1-2 punches the AFL has ever seen.

I think Harley Reid & Nick would be.

Iirc, Harley embarrassed Petracca (& Oliver, not so hard to do) last time they met Eagles.

 

[cakewalk06]

Battle would be perfect and doesn't cost a thing.

Real missed opportunity.

Except a grossly inflated a-grade salary for a decent, b-grade defender. It could blow up our hopefully disciplined pay structure.

 

[JuniorB]

It's obvious that Petracca would love to be at Collingwood (and we would love to have him), but getting him here would be difficult.
We simply don't have the trade capital, given what Melbourne would want for him.

On the AFL's Gettable segment, a possible trade of Lukosius to Adelaide was mentioned, and they raised Collingwood as another possible destination.
Again, trade capital would be a major stumbling block.

 

[NMBB]

Mate we support the Pies, were accustomed to disappointment in trade week

Are you missing an apostrophe or are you reassuring us that disappointments in trade week are now a thing of the past for us?

 

[sam_e]

no it would require a lot more. The Jeremy Cameron trade is a bit of a myth. Was three shitty first-round picks … 13,15,20. A bargain for Geelong. We paid more for Treloar for example… 2 x pick no.7s

Exactly right. And how is 20 a first rounder .. it ain't!!

the actual trade:

• Geelong gave up two middling 1st rounders (13 & 15), a 2nd rounder (20) in 2020 and a future 4th rounder (2021)
• Geelong received Cameron + two future 2nd rounders (one from GWS & one on-traded from Ess).

GWS finished 7th and Ess finished 8th in 2021 so Geelong received back picks 24 & 25 in 2021 draft in addition to securing Cameron, arguably the best forward in the game.

that might be close to the best trade value ever extracted in the history of the afl or perhaps a close run second to their trade with GCS, receiving Bowes + 7 in exchange for a 3rd rounder!!

Geelong
What Geelong Gave	What Geelong Got
						Jeremy Cameron	80 games		53 XG
Pick 13	Pick not used	1212 points	79 XG
Pick 15	Pick not used	1112 points	71 XG
Pick 20	Pick not used	912 points	66 XG
					2021R2 (Essendon) (estimate: pick 24)	Pick not used	785 points	56 XG
					2021R2 (Greater Western Sydney) (estimate: pick 27)	Pick not used	703 points	51 XG
2021R4 (Geelong) (estimate: pick 71)	Pick not used	29 points	5 XG
4 picks	0 players	0 games	3265 points	221 XG	2 picks	1 player	80 games	1488 points	160 XG

 

[Apex36]

no it would require a lot more. The Jeremy Cameron trade is a bit of a myth. Was three shitty first-round picks … 13,15,20. A bargain for Geelong. We paid more for Treloar for example… 2 x pick no.7s

Not only that, but they got two second rounders back in the trade too iirc. It was actually a pretty sweet deal for Geelong.

 

[sideswipe]

Exactly right. And how is 20 a first rounder

Free agency compo picks, matching academy, f/s picks, etc. can all push the first round out into the 20s.

 

[SchuPie]

Exactly right. And how is 20 a first rounder

True, but if we’d had another pic in the 20s, Logan Morris would be on the list now
They can still have great value

 

[Pistol Night]

Are you missing an apostrophe or are you reassuring us that disappointments in trade week are now a thing of the past for us?

I left it like that deliberately to cover both bases when we do/don’t land Petracca.

 

[NMBB]

I left it like that deliberately to cover both bases when we do/don’t land Petracca.

 

[Pistol Night]

I thought I had nothing to loose by posting that but your to good

 

[sr36]

How were you similar to bullshit?

 

[sam_e]

True, but if we’d had another pic in the 20s, Logan Morris would be on the list now
They can still have great value

nah that's not my point, in fact, we're in vehement agreement.

you're preaching to the holy converted here, i've been bemoaning our confetti strategy with 1st & 2nd round draft picks for years.

my point was highlighting (as cakewalk06 did) the myth that Cameron was traded in by Geelong at a net cost of 3 * 1st rounders, he simply wasn't ..they received 2 * future 2nd rounders back. quite staggering when you think about it.

now that's how you pull off a big trade deal.

List Mgmt. - COLLINGWOOD Trade & FA 2024

My dad has pictures of your dad on his wall. Just beautiful.

www.bigfooty.com