Autopsy Collingwood v St Kilda post match.

[Robroy22]

Missing all those goals in the first was the beginning of the end, just dropped their heads after that.

In for next week

Schenberg, Dunn, Daicos, Phillips, Wells

Please not Dunn, he's being beaten by VFL forwards and he's sooooo slow.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

We better work out the forwards.
Kills us dead.

I made this point last week, Moore might need time in the reserves to find confidence and form.

This to me is the start of our problems, not enough happens when the ball goes forward.
And those missed shots, they just kill.

Ball held, kicking for goal, kick ball between the two bigger sticks, hmmmm would help

This is precisely the reason you keep Moore in the side.. know what it feels like to hit rock bottom.. now work your way up.. be a man.. take responsibility.

Buck's ridiculous pressure bs game plan doesn't help of course.. but leave Moore in there. Let him experience the difference between a pathetic coach.. and a good coach. Learning curve is in the seniors.. dealing with Buck's politics.. etc.. and when a decent coach steps in.. he'll appreciate it more.

 

[Morganashlee]

I don't think he's terrible but he's too dumb for the backline.

If you don't think he's terrible then I'm sorry, but you're wrong lol

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Outside of Grundy. Everyone was Shit.

Our Style of play is Crap. We go backwards and sideways and go know where. Then we don't have any elite Kicks so we turn the Ball Over.

We have no Structure.

We are a Joke and Buckley might as well Re-Sign Now.

I just did not care who now as its beyond a Joke how Shit We Are

This time Dave, you don't want the hyphen or the meaning is opposite of what you intend. The last thing we want now is for Buckley to re-sign. Resign or be pushed, yes.

 

[ColinMochrie]

Pretty sure if Bucks go it will be the beginning of the end for Eddie to.

 

[ottoman]

Big rumour from the trainers is that at least 6 of the players were pissed that Blair was selected. Blair was selected yesterday and this is also why the AFL team played poorly. Leadership group were also not happy and played accordingly. Robert Harvey is a cancer on this club. Whatever team he has taken over has failed because he is not a communicator.

So the players were pissed off he was playing and showed it by passing the ball to him at every opportunity.

 

[gene clark]

Yeah with you... wouldv'e made him a real slippery customer - hard to tackle

I reckon his opponent would give him plenty of space too. I know I would.

 

[DWil6]

Does anyone honestly think Buckley will be coaching us next year? Surely not even he does. Time to stop wasting time and move him on now. He's had his shot, failed, and that's it.

I'll be honest. I've been hoping he'd come good but I seriously don't believe he thinks he's staying next season.

 

[DinoSoar]

Not a lot of positive things to say but Schade was good as was Howe. That's about it really.

 

[El cane]

Any chance we can trade our top 6 pick out for Freeman? That'd top off my season.

We needed Cathy Freemans run today, she would have been great off half back taking them on, none of that back and to the side crap. That one move by Broomhead in the last quarter was the only time I can recall where we took them on and got through and that resulted in Hoskings goal.

 

[mike123]

If you don't think he's terrible then I'm sorry, but you're wrong lol

He's a terrible defender then I'll leave it at that.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Bloody flat after that performance, truly baffling that they can produce that utter garbage.
Certainly not enjoying watching my club play footy anymore, can't remember When I last enjoyed watching a game during the actual game, the result last week hid a lot of underlining issues with this club!

Well l have been a member for over 10 years, my son has been a member all his 9 yrs of his life and in that time the last 4 to 5 yrs l cannot say l have enjoyed watching us play footy.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Man U has killed Man U itself.

Unbelievable all that money can't get it quite right.

I'm a Man U supporter, I remember them when they were on 7 titles, then they won 13 more, so it's been pretty good.

Do you put the blame on Bucks or the players. You're an advocate of Bucks right? 4 games of below par football. And you're still an advocate. Enough is enough.

 

[Morganashlee]

He's a terrible defender then I'll leave it at that.

Let's agree to agree

 

[Temploar]

Man U has killed Man U itself.

Unbelievable all that money can't get it quite right.

I'm a Man U supporter, I remember them when they were on 7 titles, then they won 13 more, so it's been pretty good.

Money can't buy you happiness success.

 

[Sunbot]

I watched a half of that crap and was so frustrated that I turned to a replay of last week. I cannot understand why so so so many times over the years there are the great games and the shockers and seemingly nothing in between. Bucks - football like any skill is about consistency and although you mouth it in the pressers it ain't happening after 4 years.
Seeing us "turn up" against the swans one week and then lay down that Etihad crap the next is only one step next to corruption. Oh yeah Bombers tanked in Adelaide so we have to to? BS!!
I had to turn off the replay seeing today's score coming through on my phone feed and go for a seething walk. Wasn't interested in the last quarter at all - why should I? After all it was obvious that the players and therefore the coach wasn't interested in producing a product worthy of the ****load they are paid to produce. Is this the quality fan experience that Eddie and Pert want us to pay for?
I won't watch the replay of today. Not interested. I don't care what the excuse is or how many emails the club sends out trying to convince me that the Club can hold its head high and it deserves to have my respect. Trashed. And what really pisses me off is that I have a non-refundable flight to Melbourne this year to watch a game. Oh well I might as well go to the theatre, at least I'll walk away afterwards knowing my money was well spent.

 

[DogCoffee]

Please not Dunn, he's being beaten by VFL forwards and he's sooooo slow.

Why we bring in Dunn then ? Just a VFL role to help the young fella's ? He's got a good kick - how about the other young backman - McClarty ? or is he still injured ?

Be good to have Brown and Daicos to debut for Anzac Day - as long as we don't get smashed by 10 goals.

 

[Gungadin]

I'm bingeing on Easter eggs to get the taste out of my mouth. I'm genuinely shattered after that effort.

 

[gene clark]

Pretty sure if Bucks go it will be the beginning of the end for Eddie to.

Eddie reckon Bucks outcoached Beveridge and Hardwick in RD's 1-2.

I'd say he reckoned Buck's worked over Richo today too but again the players let him down again.

I think the only way Buckley goes is if Eddie goes too.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Well l have been a member for over 10 years, my son has been a member all his 9 yrs of his life and in that time the last 4 to 5 yrs l cannot say l have enjoyed watching us play footy.

Even in 2012 there was barely a handful of games we played well in.. it was just pure talent that got us the points.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I don't bag players on a personal level.

Perhaps it's time to have certain players move to the

"suitable for VFL play only "

Blair, Oxley

"Perhaps Needs a spell in the VFL to gain confidence and form"

Moore, Crisp

"Play in the VFL because it's time to move to next generation"

Goldsack.

Not saying everyone must go, but we may as well look and consider:

Scharenberg (a must for me, we can see where he's at this season), Daicos

 

[30yearpie]

Do you put the blame on Bucks or the players. You're an advocate of Bucks right? 4 games of below par football. And you're still an advocate. Enough is enough.

Everyone at the club, including supporters are responsible.

 

[swoop42]

Lol he won last week and he was the coach then. How do you explain that?

But but but we beat the Swans last week.

The good judges of football put that game into perspective even before the first bounce and knew we were a good chance against a Sydney A side.

After the game those same people knew a 1pt victory wasn't overly impressive.

 

[El cane]

Yes Adams had a stinker but no way should he be dropped. He won us the game last week against Sydney.

I have a short memory but thought we were lucky last week against 6 senior players and a bunch of kids.

 

[doodles98]

I haven't been sitting on the fence doodles......I just will never disrespect Bucks.

So pissed off......lucky I am sitting at the Chinese restaurant for my Easter dinner.

My wife just told me off for being on Bigfooty.......f...k you Collingwood!

I feel your pain. I recommend that you smash a couple of kilos of crispy fried chicken feet and wash it down with a mix of beer, red wine and straight whisky.... you'll feel better for sure.