Comparing club lists by draft points values

[WCE_phil]

Tried to use objective judgement but obviously a lot of speculation. Rated Martin and O'Meara as equivalent to a number 1 pick as they were taken ahead of Hogan and Crouch. Rated Shiel as a number 1 based on his reputation when he was taken as a concession. Other values were more speculative.

Shiel was rated below treloar in his draft year. Treloar was considered pick 1-3 and Shiel pick 5-10.

 

[Big Animal]

someone at Adelaide should be getting a pay rise