Controversial - Cox shouldn't be AA ruckman!

[Quinz]

Is that all you can say.

You haven't adressed it yet.

 

[danzan22]

Is that all you can say.

"This song does get a bit repetitive"

 

[macdaddio]

Well Hille is AA at the moment for all of the reasons mentioned. Yes Cox is carrying an injury we all know and acknowledge that.

You made a poor comparasion/statement about how many finals or premierships Hille has played in compared to Campbell and Sandilands. Hence me calling you an idiot.

I didnt mention Sandilands at all, but fair point, i still dont think he is AA yet, but anways good luck...

 

[Quinz]

"This song does get a bit repetitive"

G'day Danzan, how you going?

 

[The Dustbin]

You haven't adressed it yet.

Address what?

The fact that the best you can come up (Twice) with is "Haven't seen any real reasons why yet. Not anything relating to the whole season anyway. "

You can start by getting a copy of the round 12 clash between Ess and WCE.

Hille>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Cox

 

[KaLL]

Address what?

The fact that the best you can come up (Twice) with is "Haven't seen any real reasons why yet. Not anything relating to the whole season anyway. "

You can start by getting a copy of the round 12 clash between Ess and WCE.

Hille>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Cox

Address the statement.

He beat cox once, well done to him.

 

[The Dustbin]

Address the statement.

He beat cox once, well done to him.

Has he. You might wanna confirm that champ.

 

[Quinz]

Address what?

The fact that the best you can come up (Twice) with is "Haven't seen any real reasons why yet. Not anything relating to the whole season anyway. "

You can start by getting a copy of the round 12 clash between Ess and WCE.

Hille>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Cox

If you continue to avoid adressing the statement, i'm going to have to claim victory and steal your avatar as a trophy.

So far you've failed to give an adequate reason why Hille is better than Cox for the season.

 

[MartyTHEMonster13]

sorry dude i no good with that lol but i taking a course to get better.

 

[danzan22]

G'day Danzan, how you going?

Can't complain, Essendon is on a 4 game winning streak, youngsters are coming along nicely, Hilles in AA form

 

[The Dustbin]

From the afl.com.au stats page.

Clearances:
Cox 63
Sandi 52
Hille 44

Contested possessions:
Sandi 132
Cox 130
Hille 122

Inside 50s:
Cox 49
Hille 45
Sandi 31

Hitouts:
Sandi 457
Cox 408
Hille 293

You base your arguement around that. Hille has been influential for Ess the last 4 weeks, been pretty consistent all year. Hille has been the domiant ruckman in the last 4 weeks, as already mentioned

This is going nowhere, you like Cox, I like Hille. Good luck to us both.

 

[Quinz]

You base your arguement around that. Hille has been influential for Ess the last 4 weeks, been pretty consistent all year. Hille has been the domiant ruckman in the last 4 weeks, as already mentioned

This is going nowhere, you like Cox, I like Hille. Good luck to us both.

Also this one:

Dean Cox is (compared to other ruckmen)

Second in hitouts
Second in contested possessions (2 behind sandi)
First in uncontested possessions
First in clearances
First in inside 50's
First in rebound 50's (by a fair margin)
First in running bounces
Equal third in goal assists (twice as many as Hille)
Kicked 9 goals (Hille 14, Sandi 6)
Has a higher effective disposal percentage than Hille or Sandi
Second in marks (behind Troy Simmonds)

Hille has been good for the last month but I can't see any way that he would get an AA spot ahead of Cox at this stage. Especially with his hitouts stats, a long way back from the other two ruckmen competing with him.

As you say, it's not going anywhere, we'll bring it up again in a few weeks though I'm sure.

 

[Quinz]

Can't complain, Essendon is on a 4 game winning streak, youngsters are coming along nicely, Hilles in AA form

Fail.

Good to hear, our mob is doing it a bit tough at the moment, but we'll be back up soon don't you worry about that.

 

[The Dustbin]

we'll bring it up again in a few weeks though I'm sure.

Looking forward to it Quinzate1.

 

[hoiley80]

---------------- Now playing: Fred Wesley & The Horny Horns - Discositdown via FoxyTunes

hille has beaten cox numerous times.

 

[weagles_fan]

Essendon supporters in this thread are idiots. AA is given over the 22 rounds. Cox has been clearly better than Hille in the first 15 rounds, even though Hille has had a very good last month. If there was an AA team given every month of the season Hille would be a monty for June/possibly July.

 

[Underdog]

---------------- Now playing: Fred Wesley & The Horny Horns - Discositdown via FoxyTunes

hille has beaten cox numerous times.

and....

Rafael Nadal has beaten Roger Federer numerous times too. Does that make him a better player?

 

[Crow-mo]

Address what?

The fact that the best you can come up (Twice) with is "Haven't seen any real reasons why yet. Not anything relating to the whole season anyway. "

You can start by getting a copy of the round 12 clash between Ess and WCE.

Hille>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Cox

I hope mum buys you a clue for your 14th birthday.

 

[Crow-mo]

Hille is the number 1 Ruckman in the competition over the last 6 weeks in every single stat except for hitouts.

not seeing any evidence for this claim?

 

[Red Black and Blue]

not seeing any evidence for this claim?

Was brought up when Hille was on 'On The Couch' last night

 

[The Dustbin]

I hope mum buys you a clue for your 14th birthday.

Your a quality poster. I guess you didn't bother to read (Where the issue was addressed and discussed) through the previous 8 pages as to why Hille is a possible AA. Here it is again, his form the last 4 weeks is the best of any ruckman in the AFL. He has been consistently good all year but his last 4 weeks have been exceptional.

You might understand if it was in Japanese.....
彼のフォームの最後の4週間は、最善の任意のラックマンは米国労働総同盟産別です。彼は常に良い一年しかし、彼の最後の4週間も 例外です。

I hope your mum buys you are a brain for your 10th b'day. Oh wait I forgot you just can't go into 7 eleven and buy a brain, can you? Looks like your going to be a dumb shit for the rest of your life.

 

[Willow_2000]

Cox just has a lazy 32 possies, 11 marks and 21 hitouts at 3 quarter time. Throw in all the defensive rebounds he has had and the inside 50's.

Maybe Cox saw this thread and thought he would turn it on the past few weeks to make the OP look like a complete tool?

 

[P.A.F.C]

What a hack.

 

[huggy_b]

If Cox and Hille where both at Essendon - who would be leading the ruck?

IMO Cox would be easily ahead to be the lead ruck ahead of Hille (not to say Hille is crap, but Cox is better).

 

[MickZu]

and....

Rafael Nadal has beaten Roger Federer numerous times too. Does that make him a better player?

So what you're saying is it doesn't matter how many times you beat some teams midfield during their peak, you are not better than them unless you win the premierships as well, yes?