Vooligan
Norm Smith Medallist
You've been very harsh.I think it's not just the Menzel trade, I think our whole 2015 trade period in retrospect was shit.
Dangerfield + Kerridge for Menzel and Milera. Menzel has already been delisted and there are some huge question marks about Milera FAIL
Hampton for 2016 2nd rounder, massive overs for a mediocre injury plagued depth player FAIL
Seedsman for Pick 32, again massive overs and has not yet delivered. I still have hope for Seed, but at the moment this is definitely looking like a poor trade. FAIL
Menzel was a flop - agreed.
Jury is out on Hampton - spent a lot of time injured, but has looked good when he is in the side and has delivered some much needed pace.
Milera has had limited opportunity, but is a young and developing player and has only just turned 20 years old. Still plenty of time to develop, but he has a fine skillset. I'm expecting Milera to have a big year in 2018.
Seedsman spent a lot of this season injured, but he has been more than serviceable, if only for depth. I really enjoyed his finals series.
Clearly 2015 trade period/off season wasn't an amazing one, but it's a long way from being a fail. I'm surprised you didn't mention Doedee in there somewhere too.