-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Deepthroat Trade talk.
- Thread starter Bombers_Insider
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Would be good to see what Shuey could do if fit for all 22 rounds.
Back to the main topic - Would love Clark at Freo but I can't see it happening....maybe next yearKeep hearing talk of Thursfield to Freo and wouldn't mind him at the right price.
could be a three way trade with Collingwood for Tarrant.
Pendlebury goes alright.
- Banned
- #29
Is Linda Lovelace an AFL follower?
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
I rate shuey highly.
Guys like Hill and Selwood have been on the park and delivered in spades - so clearly they have him covered - and from a balance of odds point of view - clearly you'd take those players for shuey in a second.
Whilst Shuey doesn't have the burst of speed that Judd had - he does have significant core strength and was shrugging tackles against geelong.
Plus, for fear of bias I'll stick to my own club - he's probably the best disposer of a ball by both feet our club has had, with the exception of tommy kemp. All in all - he's the onballer I'm most excited about in our team - and would be gutted to lose him
At least with judd - we got to cheer him on for 6 years and see him deliver us a flag - to lose someone before they hopefully do that - and see them do it elsewhere would be torture!!
Guys like Hill and Selwood have been on the park and delivered in spades - so clearly they have him covered - and from a balance of odds point of view - clearly you'd take those players for shuey in a second.
Whilst Shuey doesn't have the burst of speed that Judd had - he does have significant core strength and was shrugging tackles against geelong.
Plus, for fear of bias I'll stick to my own club - he's probably the best disposer of a ball by both feet our club has had, with the exception of tommy kemp. All in all - he's the onballer I'm most excited about in our team - and would be gutted to lose him
At least with judd - we got to cheer him on for 6 years and see him deliver us a flag - to lose someone before they hopefully do that - and see them do it elsewhere would be torture!!
Interesting that the official Essendon FC twtter account and 3AW are following this guy though.
Better than half the tripe on this board.
Better than half the tripe on this board.
grizzlym
Premium Platinum
I know how I'd be using Twitter if I was a journalist.
He said "could" - that sounds like him speculating what type of deal might interest West Coast, not basing it on sources inside West Coast.
A mid-late first round pick is a reasonable price for an outsider to value Luke Shuey at given the query over his durability that exists based on the past 2 seasons and having played only 6 AFL games.
What a load of sh1t.
I know why he calls himself Deepthroat...
I know why he calls himself Deepthroat...
Ha! That doesn't mean shit - I have Hawthorn following me and I've made 2 tweets in 2 years.
Asgardian
Bigfooty Jedi
This is surely a joke??????????
Tom Sculley, Jack Trengove, Dustin Martin, Anthony Morabito, Stephen Hill, Hamish Hartlett, Daniel Rich, Jack Ziebell, Steele Sidebottom, Trent Cotchin, Patrick Dangerfield, Travis Boak, Joel Selwood, Marc Murphy, Dale Thomas and Scott Pendlebury are all from the last 5 drafts.
Each of them has Shuey covered.
When Shuey plays an entire season those who have no idea on his abilities might learn to comment on things they are actually informed on.
Shuey>>>>>>Reimers straight swap.
- Banned
- #39
Spreading false rumours to entrap the competition, conducting ongoing feuds with various enemies, maintaining one's coke dealing business and flirtring with other journalists?
swansfan51
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 3, 2007
- 12,602
- 21,357
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- The Exers
Does "no idea on his abilities" include saying you'd take him over Selwood and Pendlebury?
Perhaps not Judd, but Shuey is the only certain A+ grade mid on the eagles list. This doesnt measure Shuey against other great young players. It does show his value to WC.
Pick 1 looks ok for a Shuey trade but Shuey is less of a risk as he is known. The trade would demand a low risk sich as Swallow
- Aug 8, 2009
- 10,087
- 12,047
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Agree. Asking for pick 1 is an absolute joke. Even a top 10 pick is pretty questionable. There is a reason he was pick 17 and not a top 5 pick. Good young player but hasn't really shown it at senior level yet considering he has only played 6 games. Thought he was a DT golden pick this year but injuries destroyed his season.
Rance + pick 28 for Shuey. Just throwing it out there...
West Coast knows Shuey is one of the few players on its list with currency, and would land it the teens pick it'd need if it were desperate to get Darling.
grizzlym
Premium Platinum
All of that and more!
Barnzy
Premium Platinum
They would also know he's probably the midfielder on their list with the most potential so unless they're incredibly dumb he wouldn't be traded unless it was a very early pick. Shuey won't be going anywere so don't know why people are discussing it. Thought he just signed a new deal?
- Jan 14, 2008
- 14,827
- 31,828
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Clutching at straws syndrome
I heard he signed a new deal and I don't think they'll trade him either, but they'll have to if they want Darling. They don't have anyone else worthy of the top-15 pick it'll take to ensure they get Darling (who could even go to Melbourne at 12, or Gold Coast any time). So, in summation, I reckon Shuey stays and Darling goes elsewhere, probably to GC.
If we got rid of Shu with the goal of getting Darling then the club would've truly lost the plot.
- Status
Similar threads
