Speculation Denver Grainger-Barras

[ChairmanZia]

So he is a tagger now? We have a better one in Maginness who can't get a game

See results on daicos and oliver...

 

[Stratton_Gun]

I know he looked good at the time but iko you just don't take a 3rd tall defender with a premium pick.

He's rubbish and if he wasn't a top draft pick would have been delisted already lol

 

[BIGHAWK23]

See results on daicos and oliver...

Would say the same for Finn

 

[Vindicater]

Will make a move you would think.

 

[FB19]

Will make a move you would think.

Will be moved on you would think.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

With McCabe coming in next week

And he becoming a liability via attitude issues as the weeks go on

I honestly could only see a North getting him for depth (wouldn't get a game either)

But even that would be a stretch

 

[Cleric]

I would think both WA clubs would be circling him. People forget how good he did at WAFL level as a 17 year old.

 

[fnerd]

I would think both WA clubs would be circling him. People forget how good he did at WAFL level as a 17 year old.

I can assure you freo wouldn’t be

Key defenders is our least required list position bar none

Can’t get a game at the hawks who are screaming out for a kpd and are offering Josh battle 800k a year , tells you all you need to know about this guy

 

[THE_GUN]

He's not replacing Sicily, Frost, Scrimshaw or Weddle.
We've also got McCabe, who will debut shortly.
Plus Serong and Ethan Phillips, who can't get games.
Then Blanck coming off an ACL.

If thats the case he should be looking to get out of the hawks and head to North

 

[Makeshift Park]

If thats the case he should be looking to get out of the hawks and head to North

But then he's not replacing Logue, Comben, or the Dawsons.
To say nothing of Corr, who at least offers experience, or Pink, who can play as a decoy forward, or Goater, who can play half of the positions on-ground.
For North to consider it, DGB'd have to be on the barest of minimum chips and done with a fourth rounder for it to make sense.

 

[HairyO]

I can assure you freo wouldn’t be

Key defenders is our least required list position bar none

Can’t get a game at the hawks who are screaming out for a kpd and are offering Josh battle 800k a year , tells you all you need to know about this guy

He is more HBF than FB or CHB. With a full healthy list he would never be on the FF or CHF. We are overflowing with defenders and have even more if we get Battle.

He has had injuries so may get more, or we see if a team offers an F3 or F4 but could easily see him delisted. Which is a shame because he showed glimpses in his limited chances but never any consistency.

 

[Monocle]

I would think both WA clubs would be circling him. People forget how good he did at WAFL level as a 17 year old.

After he is delisted.

The only WA Club that will be circling him is Swan Districts, his original WAFL Club.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I thought he showed a few glimpses last year before injury. Wouldn't mind him under the tutelage of Weitering but hearing about his attitude/lack of professionalism is a bit of a concern.

 

[TylerDurden]

I thought he showed a few glimpses last year before injury. Wouldn't mind him under the tutelage of Weitering but hearing about his attitude/lack of professionalism is a bit of a concern.

Thats not a problem. Just naturally doesn't have a tank. If we get Battle (and/ or Perryman), then he's done.

 

[Chief Hopper]

But then he's not replacing Logue, Comben, or the Dawsons.
To say nothing of Corr, who at least offers experience, or Pink, who can play as a decoy forward, or Goater, who can play half of the positions on-ground.
For North to consider it, DGB'd have to be on the barest of minimum chips and done with a fourth rounder for it to make sense.

North need more options in defence. More defenders playing in the VFL that can build into form and then fill gaps in the AFL squad.
I agree any trade should be done at a minimum, but what you currently have needs bolstering.

 

[Sphynx]

If thats the case he should be looking to get out of the hawks and head to North

And where does he exactly fit?

 

[Sphynx]

North need more options in defence. More defenders playing in the VFL that can build into form and then fill gaps in the AFL squad.
I agree any trade should be done at a minimum, but what you currently have needs bolstering.

Will Dawson is already a better defender at VFL level and he’s the youngest player in the AFL this year.

Key defenders aren’t a massive priority with the emergence of Comben and Logue back

 

[ChairmanZia]

If thats the case he should be looking to get out of the hawks and head to North

We are quite flush with key back, it's key forward.

Sick and tired of these bs acadmey, ugle hagan, jed walter all academy picks, bs crap.

 

[Ge3ks]

Sick and tired of these bs acadmey, ugle hagan, jed walter all academy picks, bs crap.

A North supporter whinging about another club getting AFL help? Spare me.

 

[ChairmanZia]

A North supporter whinging about another club getting AFL help? Spare me.

oh so what help did we get? lemme guess, pick 3 for ben mackay right...

Anything else? like pick 2 for kosi at saints or thomas at pick 2 at pies or roughead at 2 for hawks or pick 2 at melb tigs?

Try name a few and see how you go.

 

[Dangerousfield]

We are quite flush with key back, it's key forward.

Sick and tired of these bs acadmey, ugle hagan, jed walter all academy picks, bs crap.

You should be ashamed, just had three years of handouts from the AFL, none was deserved after you fouled your own nest!

 

[Bald]

oh so what help did we get? lemme guess, pick 3 for ben mackay right...

Anything else? like pick 2 for kosi at saints or thomas at pick 2 at pies or roughead at 2 for hawks or pick 2 at melb tigs?

Try name a few and see how you go.

Was a talented bloke named Tarryn Thomas that was on your list until this year.

 

[Obeanie1]

You should be ashamed, just had three years of handouts from the AFL, none was deserved after you fouled your own nest!

Pretty hard rebuilding at the bottom when when other clubs ahead of you are getting handouts year in year out under BS AFL priority access rorts.

AFL needs to balance the books at some point.

 

[ChairmanZia]

Was a talented bloke named Tarryn Thomas that was on your list until this year.

And that was a compo pick?

 

[ChairmanZia]

North need more options in defence. More defenders playing in the VFL that can build into form and then fill gaps in the AFL squad.
I agree any trade should be done at a minimum, but what you currently have needs bolstering.

You do realise we have logue, comben, dawson, corr as key defenders right.