Does anyone still have even a smidgeon of respect for Carlton?

[huggy_b]

It depends on how much a smidgeon is.

But generally speaking, Carlton are more often than not disliked anyways....

 

[Bay Pie]

Poo > Carlton.

I stand corrected

 

[CJisJC]

Get over it! We formulated a plan that backfired, you got Nick Stevens, no-one else was affected. Carltank would have done the exact same thing and would do so repeatedly. This is nothing like rorting 3 drafts in a row and those 2 years where you stole christmas.

The only one who needs to get over "it"... is you flog. You haven't got any proof we tanked for 3 years, just dumb speculation. More importantly... you're a Western Bulldogs supporter... your opinion means sweet **** all... Quit using the attack carlton wagon as a way of trying to gain notice in the bigfooty community and find another route... this one has been done to death 100 times before

 

[huggy_b]

The only one who needs to get over "it"... is you flog. You haven't got any proof we tanked for 3 years, just dumb speculation. More importantly... you're a Western Bulldogs supporter... your opinion means sweet **** all... Quit using the attack carlton wagon as a way of trying to gain notice in the bigfooty community and find another route... this one has been done to death 100 times before

TANK - they coined the term especially for you. Why would you tun your back on it??

 

[sunnyTEE]

The only one who needs to get over "it"... is you flog. You haven't got any proof we tanked for 3 years, just dumb speculation. More importantly... you're a Western Bulldogs supporter... your opinion means sweet **** all... Quit using the attack carlton wagon as a way of trying to gain notice in the bigfooty community and find another route... this one has been done to death 100 times before

This post should be a reasonable indicator of what needs to change in your life.

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

Smidgeon!

Great word.

We need more thread titles utilising words like smidgeon.

Next word I would like to see included in a thread title is hubbub.

 

[CJisJC]

This post should be a reasonable indicator of what needs to change in your life.

Life's good - thanks for your concern

 

[walshy93]

Poo > Carlton.

Poo >>>> Carlton >>>> Collingwood

Round 4?
Round 12?

 

[Coondogs]

The only one who needs to get over "it"... is you flog. You haven't got any proof we tanked for 3 years, just dumb speculation

Speculation you tool? I've had countless admittance from Carltank fans of tanking in 2007 at least.

More importantly... you're a Western Bulldogs supporter... your opinion means sweet **** all... [

Why's this mate, because of the fact that we play with some honour and integrity both on and off the field. How about we lend your club some you worthless flog.

Quit using the attack carlton wagon as a way of trying to gain notice in the bigfooty community and find another route... this one has been done to death 100 times before

And it's having the desired effect. 15 clubs worth of supporters set Carltank fans up with bait that anyone with the mental age of about 10 would see through and each time you cretins dive upon it. Grow a backbone mate, and wear the critcism served upon you, until then you will be seen in all facets of life as a worthless imbecile

 

[BLUES82]

Speculation you tool? I've had countless admittance from Carltank fans of tanking in 2007 at least.



Why's this mate, because of the fact that we play with some honour and integrity both on and off the field. How about we lend your club some you worthless flog.

Scott West Board

 

[Coondogs]

Scott West Board

Nothing wrong with letting a player know his time is up. Wouldn't want it to turn out like Craig Bradley, literally carrying a 37 year old liability on and off the field.

 

[oogac]

Coondogs is on fire

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

Why's this mate, because of the fact that we play with some honour and integrity both on and off the field. How about we lend your club some you worthless flog.

Tony Liberatore played with integrity on the field didn't he.

And tampering with the draft by trading pick 6 for Lachlan Veale showed real integrity didn't it.

Don't come on here with your self righteous crap when your scummy club has it's own demons in the closet.

 

[Coondogs]

\

Tony Liberatore played with integrity on the field didn't he.

And tampering with the draft by trading pick 6 for Lachlan Veale showed real integrity didn't it.

Don't come on here with your self righteous crap when your scummy club has it's own demons in the closet.

This was all you could come up with on our club's history.

Libba must have been relatively fair, after all he did win a brownlow. More than I can say about the thuggery examplified by John Nicholls.

As i've said about our so called "draft tampering", it's a far cry from the lengths that Carltank goes to come draft season. Come back with something substantial if you wish for a dignified response.

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

\

This was all you could come up with on our club's history.

Libba must have been relatively fair, after all he did win a brownlow. More than I can say about the thuggery examplified by John Nicholls.

As i've said about our so called "draft tampering", it's a far cry from the lengths that Carltank goes to come draft season. Come back with something substantial if you wish for a dignified response.

So you have proof Carlton tanked last season do you?

OK......let's hear it then

 

[Coondogs]

Just turn back a couple of pages champ. If there's any remaining doubt about it, feel free to shoot any questions.

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

Just turn back a couple of pages champ. If there's any remaining doubt about it, feel free to shoot any questions.

Still didn't see any proof cob

Thought you might have something concrete

Guess not

 

[Coondogs]

Then again you would say that. If Carltank supporters like yourself are constantly trying to emphasise that they don't care about the opinions of opposition supporters, why not just entertain the fact that you were almost certainly tanking for at least 2 seasons. For a group of fans who think they stand above all others, you certaintly get wound up by any reference to tanking.

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

then again you would say that. If carltank supporters like yourself are constantly trying to emphasise that they don't care about the opinions of opposition supporters, why not just entertain the fact that you were almost certainly tanking for at least 2 seasons. For a group of fans who think they stand above all others, you certaintly get wound up by any reference to tanking.

can you provide concrete evidence that carlton has ever tanked a game of football?

 

[Coondogs]

This is pretty good evidence

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/afl-rocked-by-carlton-tank-claims/2008/03/13/1205126118754.html

Not everyday your very own assistant coach makes such a level of claims. Don't believe it has happened in any other professional sport in this country at least.

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

And when asked to provide concrete evidence he backed down

http://www.*************.com.au/article/news/38/

Because he didn't have concrete evidence

Anything else?

 

[Rockford]

I don't mind Carlton, they're trying to get competitive again, can't blame them for that. I think most peoples issues with the Blues stem from their supporters carrying on like they're bound for a top 4 finish when, realistically, they're still a way off making the 8.

 

[Rockford]

And when asked to provide concrete evidence he backed down

http://www.*************.com.au/article/news/38/

Because he didn't have concrete evidence

Anything else?

Evidence or not, Carlton supporters on BigFooty have stated that they were happy their side lost games to secure a better draft pick.

 

[JustKreuzin]

This is pretty good evidence

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/ne...ton-tank-claims/2008/03/13/1205126118754.html

Not everyday your very own assistant coach makes such a level of claims. Don't believe it has happened in any other professional sport in this country at least.

Hahahaha we were tanking and we still beat you guys last year! Doesn't say much for the dogs, not to mention how we beat you this year.

 

[Coondogs]

And when asked to provide concrete evidence he backed down

http://www.*************.com.au/article/news/38/

Because he didn't have concrete evidence

Anything else?

What the **** do you actually want. Brett Ratten to come online and personally endorse every tanking claim
Your assistant coach Tony Liberatore personally comes to the media and tells them they were not trying to win any of the last 4 games, including 2 very winnable ones. Playing players who didn't deserve to, refusing to make moves in the coaches box and sent players off for surgery that didn't need to.

This was pretty strong at the time, the first time i've ever seen such a claim in my life from an assistant coach in a professional sport.What sort of evidence do you bloody want.

And then what happens, the Carlton mafia pay a visit to Libba and all of a sudden he's retracting his comments. Why would he do that?

Libba meant every word he said, just as John Worsfold and Paul Roos and anyone else that was in the know at the time.