I have been around GV for a fair few years and NEVER seen a punch on on the rooms. If you KNOW what happened (if anything) then share the news otherwise, don't speculate or cast dispersions on a nameless player/person!!!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
EDFL "A" Grade - 2010
- Thread starter the git
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I have been around GV for a fair few years and NEVER seen a punch on on the rooms. If you KNOW what happened (if anything) then share the news otherwise, don't speculate or cast dispersions on a nameless player/person!!!
Is not in my nature to Speculate as you say , hard to deny when it comes from within your own club and was witnessed by others
This official has the score on the board and could very well not be there next year , dissension on and off the field !!!!
If you have been "around" for as long as you have said obviously you are not privy to what went on in the visitors rooms late after the loss to Oak Park
I clearly wasn't there this week otherwise I would know!?!? You wrote that this is a habit for one of the parties involved after a loss... Given this is the clubs second H&A loss in 4 years, when was the last incident??? You clearly know more than your saying about what apparently happened so why don't you shed some light?? 'Official' could mean anyone??
Dead right there . Does narrow the field a tad
May be after a Keilor game ?????
mickdundee
Senior List
Greenvale is not used to losing! Sorry only in Grand Finals, sounds like bad losers when they loose.
They will fail again this year, and maybe then get rid of the coach!
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,785
- 11,540
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
I was in the rooms after the game and I didn't witness anything..
A Marby fan talking about losing Grand Finals, interesting..
Perhaps Marby will appoint MacPherson if he's not at Greenvale next season?
Marby have lost one. How many have Greenvale lost?????
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,785
- 11,540
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
The number where they've gone in as overwhelming favourites is 1 all.
Although I was more refering to Marby Parks enviable recent history.
Lucky to be there this year from what i hear , did footy opps know the president resigned him mid year without there knowledge ???????
Large Pinorcle
Debutant
what are you talking about?
your are an absolute goose. i haven't missed a game in the last 7 years and there has never been a scuffle after any game let alone a fight.
Stop coming on the site and making up crap, trying to stir up trouble.
clearly you have no idea & are just a sh it stirrer.
Maggot!!!
mickdundee
Senior List
Why would Marby want to appoint MacPherson for? , he has been out coached in every Grand Final and Finals for that matter.
He has had clearly the best list of players to coach over the past 5 years , but I think under achieved.
I heard that he is a bad looser as well!
Greenvale should have got rid of him last year.
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,785
- 11,540
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
Was tongue in cheek about Marby taking on Greenvales previous coach.
As for having the best list.. It's not like the Marbys, the Keilors and Strathmores were exactly fielding dud sides.
It's unfortunate and hopefully they'll work out what's preventing them from taking the next step but from a league perspective it's better than one side winning it year in, year out.
For now though probably best not to deal with rumour so unless people have something factual to say probably best to leave it alone.
I was outside the away rooms waiting for a mate, and did not notice any scuffle or hear of anything
Move on, think this rumour is dead and buried
When i want lip of you boy i will get it off your dogs rectum
Until then pull your head in
My info comes from within your club , just puting it out there for discussion
- Dec 21, 2005
- 23,638
- 14,971
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Struggled to get out of B grade in a few final series.
Craig Hutchy
Debutant
well things have certainly spiced up in here! So did anything happen or not? Surely somebody knows??
Back to the facts and nobody could in their right mind pot greenvale for the way they go about it. Some of it must be jealousy. They actually have more juniors than most. It's also a bit rich for blokes from Marby to be taking pot shots about coaches, playing talent etc etc. Greenvale weren't the best team in it last year. The best team by far won the comp last year. They have recruited more and are still a cut above the pack.
The coaching one is the one I find strange and infactual. I agree they seemed to be outcoached in 08 in the GF but they haven't lost to Keilor before or since for a long time. I watch Keilor a lot and Mick v McPherson would have to sit 6 or 7 v 1 and some Keilor ppl have questioned some of the dicisions there esp that game this yr. Plus from the outside it takes a pretty good coach to get that level of consistancy out of basically the same group. That doesn't happen without good leadership
Back to the facts and nobody could in their right mind pot greenvale for the way they go about it. Some of it must be jealousy. They actually have more juniors than most. It's also a bit rich for blokes from Marby to be taking pot shots about coaches, playing talent etc etc. Greenvale weren't the best team in it last year. The best team by far won the comp last year. They have recruited more and are still a cut above the pack.
The coaching one is the one I find strange and infactual. I agree they seemed to be outcoached in 08 in the GF but they haven't lost to Keilor before or since for a long time. I watch Keilor a lot and Mick v McPherson would have to sit 6 or 7 v 1 and some Keilor ppl have questioned some of the dicisions there esp that game this yr. Plus from the outside it takes a pretty good coach to get that level of consistancy out of basically the same group. That doesn't happen without good leadership
deepinsidefifty
Rookie
Brad Sutcliffe you owe Sammy Sarkis an apology for a weak effort of taking a dive, rumour is that you did your best to tell the lads at the tribunal that you were staging but to arrive in a wheel chair was taking it to another level...!
Oak Park boys should be very careful of the Damaging Brad Sutcliffe, he is one of the all time greats at sniping behind play and not getting a kick. Not sure why he team mates call him Witches Hat.........!!!!
As for Fat Mocca bagging Kurt McLynn we find this a massive rumour, as we all know its hard to talk with a mouth full of SH1T.....
Oak Park boys should be very careful of the Damaging Brad Sutcliffe, he is one of the all time greats at sniping behind play and not getting a kick. Not sure why he team mates call him Witches Hat.........!!!!
As for Fat Mocca bagging Kurt McLynn we find this a massive rumour, as we all know its hard to talk with a mouth full of SH1T.....
Short memories. How many goes did Greenvale take to get out of B Grade?
Also a short memory... GV were only in existence a few years before being promoted and (correct me if I'm wrong) haven't missed a finals series since?? (maybe one??) There is no question that GV let a couple of opportunities slip in GF's, that is just fact. But to try and question the way the club goes about it is just ludicrous.
And for you Mick Dundee - Maybe Super is a bad loser, probably because he's not had much practice at it!!!
Large Pinorcle
Debutant
two things:
Get a new source cause whoever it is he is feeding you crap or your making it up. i thing it's the later.
secondly get some new trash talk cause that dogs recum line was horrible
exogenesis
Rookie
Oak park looking good with three premiership players to come back to the team, team of the year ruckman Tom white hasn't played yet, goal kicking leader Ray Harrison back from the bush, and grand final best on ground Andy smith back from gold coast
Lets see how good my source is ?
did footy ops or the committee know the president had resigned the coach half way through last year when footy ops wanted the position opened at the end of the year to see who was out there ???
- Status
