EDFL Div 1 Discussion 2023

[Grechy Bombers]

Westy Vs Tulla will be a good game.

It will be interesting to see Tulla's team selection as I suspect up to ten players who would normally be in their best side will be missing due to injury.

 

[BlueJet]

When have you ever known any organisation to absorb an expense without offsetting it, would be poor financial management if this was the case.

Given their balance sheet, they're offsetting without bothering to absorb the cost, which is the problem.

 

[Informant]

Been told DP reserves played with 6 on the bench against WM, website has the game as a draw.. no scores up.. must not have read the rule book during their code switch

 

[oldone1]

Been told DP reserves played with 6 on the bench against WM, website has the game as a draw.. no scores up.. must not have read the rule book during their code switch

Westy should get the 4 points then, lets see how the league handles

 

[Turbos mail]

Been told DP reserves played with 6 on the bench against WM, website has the game as a draw.. no scores up.. must not have read the rule book during their code switch

Played with 6 or named 6? Maybe trying to cheat the system and qualify players who are not actually there.

 

[The Defender]

Played with 6 or named 6? Maybe trying to cheat the system and qualify players who are not actually there.

East Keilor special learnt off DP

 

[StormRider]

Played with 6 or named 6? Maybe trying to cheat the system and qualify players who are not actually there.

Played with 6

 

[stars alive]

Played with 6

Apparently west meadows played an unregistered player as well..can the story get any better

 

[Executioner]

Been told DP reserves played with 6 on the bench against WM, website has the game as a draw.. no scores up.. must not have read the rule book during their code switch

Code switch? Rugby over to Footy?

 

[stroketurboego]

Apparently west meadows played an unregistered player as well..can the story get any better

SA thirds as well
Loss of score


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[StormRider]

Apparently west meadows played an unregistered player as well..can the story get any better

They started game with about 15 on field, they would have played me in my 50's if i put my hand up

 

[torpfrom50]

Been told DP reserves played with 6 on the bench against WM, website has the game as a draw.. no scores up.. must not have read the rule book during their code switch

Just checked WRFL and the reserves play with 24 so appears DP didnt check the EDFL rules

 

[nosecondprize]

Just checked WRFL and the reserves play with 24 so appears DP didnt check the EDFL rules

Well that's nobody's fault but Deer Parks. Points should be stripped straight away. No matter the margin.

 

[Jessie]

Been told DP reserves played with 6 on the bench against WM, website has the game as a draw.. no scores up.. must not have read the rule book during their code switch

That is so funny. Just trying to get an extra guy qualified.

 

[3040bandobandit]

SA thirds as well
Loss of score


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

anyone one know how this actually goes down like once the game is done how do the league know and then loss of score occurs?

 

[Colonel Sanders 3036]

anyone one know how this actually goes down like once the game is done how do the league know and then loss of score occurs?

 

[BEST OF EDFL]

Just checked WRFL and the reserves play with 24 so appears DP didnt check the EDFL rules

All new clubs read the rules back to front
Common sense is club should retain points the two extra on the bench didn’t decide the result .not hard

 

[nosecondprize]

All new clubs read the rules back to front
Common sense is club should retain points the two extra on the bench didn’t decide the result .not hard

And what about the qualification of players? You've just given 2 players an extra game they wouldn't have played.

 

[stroketurboego]

View attachment 1664996
View attachment 1664998

If you can not select the player on Gameday, he or she isn’t registered, not that hard.
If you hand write it in, and he or she isn’t registered, and takes the field and plays, then ditto- you have just played an unregistered player….. again not that hard!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Just deduct them the points, set a precedent and I am sure it will have minimal impact on their ladder position.

 

[MPMonkeys]

Hillside by 40
DP by 25
MV by 30
Rupo by 20
WC by 60
Tulla by 25

 

[Vlodrive]

Hillside by 40
DP by 25
MV by 30
Rupo by 20
WC by 60
Tulla by 25

HS by 53
MV by 29
DP by 35
RP by 9
WC by 88
WM by 9


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Colonel Sanders 3036]

Who's on Tulla this Tuesday? Recruited a lot of 2s, but what chance in the 1s? Playing Westy. I reckon WM ("go westy") - they shoud really stop those 'local' women screeching that at games

 

[Turbos mail]

How go are the away jumpers for both Deer Park and St Albans. I guess the WRFL do have something that the edfl dont. Like the away strips

 

[Bashen]

How go are the away jumpers for both Deer Park and St Albans. I guess the WRFL do have something that the edfl dont. Like the away strips

It was a pre requisite by the EDFL before they joined that they must have away kits


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com