EDFL Premier Discussion 2024

[livefor saturdays]

He over ran yhe ball then had no opinion to brace for compact it was split second this is what's fkd afl now shits dribbling down to edfl stop being a soft **** this is footy it's good to see if hd hit him in head fine 4 weeks but he should not be playing gor next 2 weeks either protocol head nock but let's see I bet he plays so its just shoulder hit its play on

Elbow to the head mate
It was all in the vision !
Ran at him elbow up, collected his head with the elbow !
#19 got his right whack of 4 weeks pal

 

[sorloser]

Elbow to the head mate
It was all in the vision !
Ran at him elbow up, collected his head with the elbow !
#19 got his right whack of 4 weeks pal

He is right about if it was to the head
Maybe 21 days off
Maybe apw should let the league no
Sorry they already do
Let’s see if they act

 

[fkfooty]

Elbow to the head mate
It was all in the vision !
Ran at him elbow up, collected his head with the elbow !
#19 got his right whack of 4 weeks pal

So pacco bloke should miss 2 weeks concusion rule right no he will play did not get him in the head it soft as

 

[livefor saturdays]

So pacco bloke should miss 2 weeks concusion rule right no he will play did not get him in the head it soft as

Explain the egg on his head idiot !
Didn’t get concussed ( he’s got a head as hard as a cats head) but fact is, he is out for the first 4 games !
Go have a talk to him about how the tribunal went
Do you wonder why the vision is gone !
Have a think !

 

[fkfooty]

Explain the egg on his head idiot !
Didn’t get concussed ( he’s got a head as hard as a cats head) but fact is, he is out for the first 4 games !
Go have a talk to him about how the tribunal went
Do you wonder why the vision is gone !
Have a think !

That bullshit if his got egg on his head it's protocol to have 21 days of or its bullshit an his soft as no doubt he ratted out bloke at tribunal aswell

 

[sorloser]

Explain the egg on his head idiot !
Didn’t get concussed ( he’s got a head as hard as a cats head) but fact is, he is out for the first 4 games !
Go have a talk to him about how the tribunal went
Do you wonder why the vision is gone !
Have a think !

Didn’t have concussion
Are u a doctor now
Big egg on his head
Didn’t come back on
But right to go next week
21 days
Should of thought that threw before telling the tribunal

 

[livefor saturdays]

Didn’t have concussion
Are u a doctor now
Big egg on his head
Didn’t come back on
But right to go next week
21 days
Should of thought that threw before telling the tribunal

you’re delusional pal
Face it, 4 weeks for a thug act !
Vision said it all, tribunal went for record quick time, can’t dispute what they all saw in the room
Bloke had a brain fade, frustrated uncontrolled aggression.


Done
Dusted
See ya next season

 

[sorloser]

you’re delusional pal
Face it, 4 weeks for a thug act !
Vision said it all, tribunal went for record quick time, can’t dispute what they all saw in the room
Bloke had a brain fade, frustrated uncontrolled aggression.


Done
Dusted
See ya next season

The fact is 21 days
U keep bringing up the act
Not arguing that
Protocol is concussion rule
we had two players this year get hit high and sat them out for 21 days
It is the rule pal
Club responsibility

 

[the horse whisper]

Didn’t have concussion
Are u a doctor now
Big egg on his head
Didn’t come back on
But right to go next week
21 days
Should of thought that threw before telling the tribunal

Find it hard to believe he didn’t have concussion. I feel that he should be missing 2 weeks minimum if he copped an elbow to the head and developed an egg on his head. The league should ask for a head knock paper work to be completed by the doctor allowing him to play before he takes the field this weekend. Especially after the current court case involving the league and concussion.

 

[fkfooty]

Find it hard to believe he didn’t have concussion. I feel that he should be missing 2 weeks minimum if he copped an elbow to the head and developed an egg on his head. The league should ask for a head knock paper work to be completed by the doctor allowing him to play before he takes the field this weekend. Especially after the current court case involving the league and concussion.

100% if he got him in the head an his got a egg yes 4 weeks an he miss 21 days simple as that move on

 

[sorloser]

100% if he got him in the head an his got a egg yes 4 weeks an he miss 21 days simple as that move on

What do think turbo
U are a big advocate of rules and regulations

 

[livefor saturdays]

The fact is 21 days
U keep bringing up the act
Not arguing that
Protocol is concussion rule
we had two players this year get hit high and sat them out for 21 days
It is the rule pal
Club responsibility

You can be hit in the head and not have concussion!!
Player did go to Bundoora head check, ran tests and no concussion
That’s the club responsibility which was carried through as per protocols via EDFL/VFL.
Same, had 3 players out for 21 days one out for 2 months… can’t muck around with heads, given recent advances in research.
Not worth it for long term effects.
100% agree gotta protect the head.

 

[Gremlin77]

You can be hit in the head and not have concussion!!
Player did go to Bundoora head check, ran tests and no concussion
That’s the club responsibility which was carried through as per protocols via EDFL/VFL.
Same, had 3 players out for 21 days one out for 2 months… can’t muck around with heads, given recent advances in research.
Not worth it for long term effects.
100% agree gotta protect the head.

Pretty weird to see people campaigning for a player to miss a final. I’m sure Pascoe Vale are not going to put a player out there that’s at risk, and hasn’t passed a medical.

 

[livefor saturdays]

Pretty weird to see people campaigning for a player to miss a final. I’m sure Pascoe Vale are not going to put a player out there that’s at risk, and hasn’t passed a medical.

Correct
How about dickheads don’t try and run through opposition players front on, with their elbow raised, and idiots say it was legal and the player/ football is now soft !
Player health has to be No 1
Protect the head always

 

[Turbos mail]

What do think turbo
U are a big advocate of rules and regulations

Where is the vision?

 

[livefor saturdays]

Where is the vision?

Happened in the last 5 mins of Q3, just watched the whole Q again, the incident has been cut out, was there on Sunday arvo.

 

[Gym junkie]

Where is the vision?

Vision is at 19.25 minutes third quarter. Listed on website as (Part1)

 

[Turbos mail]

What do think turbo
U are a big advocate of rules and regulations

Hey mate, he went straight at the player and looked to be an elbow or shoulder so that’s weeks every day of the week. Player got up and waked off so that probably helped Edwards in fact. 4 weeks might be harsh ( but if it was an elbow then 4 is fair) but in todays footy if you choose to run at the player instead of going the ball your gone.

 

[sorloser]

Hey mate, he went straight at the player and looked to be an elbow or shoulder so that’s weeks every day of the week. Player got up and waked off so that probably helped Edwards in fact. 4 weeks might be harsh ( but if it was an elbow then 4 is fair) but in todays footy if you choose to run at the player instead of going the ball your gone.

Last week young got punched in the face and u all say suck it up and move on
Bloke get not one week
U blokes are f##ked

 

[BlueJet]

Young gave one & got one back, hardly a victim but they can both cop a week if it helps..

Edwards bumped & caught someone high with what looked like a raised arm, I wouldn't think anyone is too shocked if he has been suspended.

 

[sorloser]

Young gave one & got one back, hardly a victim but they can both cop a week if it helps..

Edwards bumped & caught someone high with what looked like a raised arm, I wouldn't think anyone is too shocked if he has been suspended.

So a push to chest and a hit to the face all good
Just trying to get my head around your thought of thinking or the lack of it
Maybe u high end clubs might be a little scared of apw

 

[BlueJet]

So a push to chest and a hit to the face all good
Just trying to get my head around your thought of thinking or the lack of it
Maybe u high end clubs might be a little scared of apw

This has to be a pisstake,
I refuse to believe that you're actually this stupid.

 

[sorloser]

This has to be a pisstake,
I refuse to believe that you're actually this stupid.

There it is
No answer just put out a insult

 

[Turbos mail]

Last week young got punched in the face and u all say suck it up and move on
Bloke get not one week
U blokes are f##ked

Hey mate, you’re very passionate. On the vision from last week I seen young punch the other guy in the stomach first which triggered the incident. Not sure there was to much in all that tbh. On this incident Edwards is a pretty fair player but goes hard. Think he would admit he just made an error of judgement and if it’s an elbow it’s definitely around 4 but if not I reckon 3 weeks is probably fair. The Pacco player walking off has probably saved him a few weeks mate!! My judgement is based on the it’s known to ALL that these incidents are not part of our game any longer. You need to go the ball rather than the player.

APW had a great year imo, so be happy.
Stay well and safe old mate..It’s finals time!

 

[Turbos mail]

This has to be a pisstake,
I refuse to believe that you're actually this stupid.

His a sore loser alright.