EDFL Premier Discussion 2024

[Trent the flight Steward]

You do know mick poaches every junior that’s half decent from rival clubs. Can’t consider them home grown

I think there's the feel they'll develop better at keilor and why juniors go there. Then one parent think if that kids going to keilor, my sons just as good so I'll send him too. Does mick still coach a junior team? Look at keilor reserves too, right up.there, the kids don't leave.

I'd love to see edfl clubs play off 35 points. If it's good enough for the ovens and murray premiers it should be for metro footballers. Deer Park wouldn't know what a home grown junior looked like. If the points system is tightened up you don't need a salary cap. If your playing under 19s your good enough to be full time in the ones

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

I think there's the feel they'll develop better at keilor and why juniors go there. Then one parent think if that kids going to keilor, my sons just as good so I'll send him too. Does mick still coach a junior team? Look at keilor reserves too, right up.there, the kids don't leave.

I'd love to see edfl clubs play off 35 points. If it's good enough for the ovens and murray premiers it should be for metro footballers. Deer Park wouldn't know what a home grown junior looked like. If the points system is tightened up you don't need a salary cap. If your playing under 19s your good enough to be full time in the ones

On the topic of Keilor reserves players leaving, Jhett Gaskett has joined Aberfeldie.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

On the topic of Keilor reserves players leaving, Jhett Gaskett has joined Aberfeldie.

If I was a country club I'd pay him 650 a game in the Bendigo league and any league north of that he'd get four figures

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

A junior like that should be a core player in keilors senior side. It shows the points system isn't working, if a 20 year midfielder can't crack the senior side and would be a regular in other sides in the comp

 

[Turbos mail]

A junior like that should be a core player in keilors senior side. It shows the points system isn't working, if a 20 year midfielder can't crack the senior side and would be a regular in other sides in the comp

Hey mate, it’s not the fault of the points system in this case, it’s a case of keilor not playing their own. They recruit others and chase juniors when they have enough of their own talent but continue to ignore them. Cassar gone as well. A club like keilor shoukd be playing on under 40 points every week but they recruit and ignore their own.

 

[TheFootballWhisperer]

This isn’t meant for politics but with the US election today i thought id share who im voting for.

I will be voting for 5.Mick McGuane to be my president #M#MightyMick2024

 

[dandy redlegs]

This isn’t meant for politics but with the US election today i thought id share who im voting for.

I will be voting for 5.Mick McGuane to be my president #M#MightyMick2024

will he take a pay cut if gets the job.

 

[Orbit]

Hey mate, it’s not the fault of the points system in this case, it’s a case of keilor not playing their own. They recruit others and chase juniors when they have enough of their own talent but continue to ignore them. Cassar gone as well. A club like keilor shoukd be playing on under 40 points every week but they recruit and ignore their own.

What would change in the EDFL if the max points allowed was 30? Or are we suggesting different points for different clubs?

 

[danger_wood]

If I was a country club I'd pay him 650 a game in the Bendigo league and any league north of that he'd get four figures

And therein lies the issue with local footy these days.

650 a game for a fringe 1’s player… spare me!

 

[jontyrohdes]

Hey mate, it’s not the fault of the points system in this case, it’s a case of keilor not playing their own. They recruit others and chase juniors when they have enough of their own talent but continue to ignore them. Cassar gone as well. A club like keilor shoukd be playing on under 40 points every week but they recruit and ignore their own.

What a load of crap, if he was good enough he would’ve been getting a game at Keilor….surely there’s enough evidence to suggest McGuane plays their own if good enough. Let’s see how many games he plays at Aberfeldie!

 

[MortlockWatcher]

No pies in paper bags next season at DP, saving them for new recruits

Sounds like they need hessian sacks more than paper bags.

 

[MortlockWatcher]

Deja vu

Exactly. We read all this sh1t last year.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

What a load of crap, if he was good enough he would’ve been getting a game at Keilor….surely there’s enough evidence to suggest McGuane plays their own if good enough. Let’s see how many games he plays at Aberfeldie!

They play over 40 points, so they actually don't play their young guys enough. A club like keilor could easily play in the low 30s and win the flag. The ovens and murray have just made the premiers play on 36 points and it goes up a point for each spot up the ladder. Edfl should be 34 points for the premiers and go up each ladder spot

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

And therein lies the issue with local footy these days.

650 a game for a fringe 1’s player… spare me!

He'd win deer parks best and fairest and their players don't get out if bed under 4 figures

 

[MortlockWatcher]

What would change in the EDFL if the max points allowed was 30? Or are we suggesting different points for different clubs?

Ovens & Murray have staggered points based on the previous years final placings (Corowa has extra points having come out of recess).

 

[weapons#again]

I think there's the feel they'll develop better at keilor and why juniors go there. Then one parent think if that kids going to keilor, my sons just as good so I'll send him too. Does mick still coach a junior team? Look at keilor reserves too, right up.there, the kids don't leave.

I'd love to see edfl clubs play off 35 points. If it's good enough for the ovens and murray premiers it should be for metro footballers. Deer Park wouldn't know what a home grown junior looked like. If the points system is tightened up you don't need a salary cap. If your playing under 19s your good enough to be full time in the one

Deer Parks coach home grown?

 

[Jerry gee]

Sounds like they need hessian sacks more than paper bags.

The pies will also come with a golden ticket inside bag if you are lucky to win head straight over ballarat Rd to claim the jackpot

 

[Jerry gee]

Deer Parks coach home grown?

Yes legend of the club

 

[jontyrohdes]

They play over 40 points, so they actually don't play their young guys enough. A club like keilor could easily play in the low 30s and win the flag. The ovens and murray have just made the premiers play on 36 points and it goes up a point for each spot up the ladder. Edfl should be 34 points for the premiers and go up each ladder spot

I’m pretty sure I said there’s enough evidence to suggest that McGuane will play them if they’re good enough. I don’t think he’s in the game of gifting games to satisfy some outsiders