Recruiting EFC Trade/Draft Talk II with F/A rules in OP - Billings for a fourth rounder the latest rumour

[Zach Package]

Trade Radio ‏@traderadio 31s31 seconds ago
BREAKING: @sydneyswans forward Tim Membrey has officially requested a trade to @stkildafc

We never land the quite literally medium sized fish

 

[eth-dog]

We never land the quite literally medium sized fish

Prismall

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Is Jake Long actually any good

 

[Fin ice Smuggler]

We never land the quite literally medium sized fish

Are u surprised??? Why would anyone nominate us, can't even make a firm decision on the coach after 2 years of debacle.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

We never land the quite literally medium sized fish

Plenty of fish in the sea.

 

[Zach Package]

Are u surprised??? Why would anyone nominate us, can't even make a firm decision on the coach after 2 years of debacle.

look, when it's us v the saints it's no contest. they can give him a buttload more money and guarantee him games. If he wants to toil away in mediocrity for the next 8 years then who are we to stop him.

We did get McKenna who could have had his pick of all 18 clubs and gone to ones with an established irish contingent but he chose us, that is saying something

 

[DonsRule]

Trade Radio ‏@traderadio 50s50 seconds ago
Dodoro on Ryder: We've told @PAFC what we want, that's a quality player in return. We're concerned about our list right now

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Lol at Purple flog on TWR

When you have other clubs wanting our good players for peanuts then you cant blame club for being stubborn

 

[Andronicus]

Meh.......mbrey

I kind of agree.

 

[Fear Boner]

when do we get a sympathy pick in the top ten from the afl

 

[rines]

FFS.. we should tank to the bottom of the ladder.. maybe we could get pick 3 for Howlett??

Ryder not worth 17 but Frawley is worth 3??? Shameful.. yet another stitch up from AFL.. and everyone knew it was happening.

How the **** is Frawley worth pick 3??? Disgusting.. a priority pick in disguise..

 

[Phone]

well it's a terrible comparison so

 

[Kong]

I'd happily take Giles if the price is right , he's not too bad around the ground for a ruckman !

He's a very decent back up ruckman.

 

[Skeeta Olly]

FFS.. we should tank to the bottom of the ladder.. maybe we could get pick 3 for Howlett??

Ryder not worth 17 but Frawley is worth 3??? Shameful.. yet another stitch up from AFL.. and everyone knew it was happening.

How the **** is Frawley worth pick 3??? Disgusting.. a priority pick in disguise..

Comparing trading to free agency.... might as well be comparing apples to peanuts.

 

[lenny2013]

FFS.. we should tank to the bottom of the ladder.. maybe we could get pick 3 for Howlett??

Ryder not worth 17 but Frawley is worth 3??? Shameful.. yet another stitch up from AFL.. and everyone knew it was happening.

How the **** is Frawley worth pick 3??? Disgusting.. a priority pick in disguise..

I think WB got pick 26 for Higgins.

Hawthorn got pick 20 for Buddy.

 

[Phone]

Comparing trading to free agency.... might as well be comparing apples to peanuts.

oh that is so terrible. come on man

 

[gillon]

I don't know how it's possible to get disappointed about not landing Membrey. I mean, I could understand if he was a former first round draft pick who's showed a bit but hasn't come on. But he was literally overlooked more than 40 times in the draft and has played one average game.

 

[rines]

Yeah.. I wouldn't have minded Membrey.. but not sure I would be crying into the corn flakes because he went to St Kilda.. good luck to him..

 

[Eleven 38]

Comparing trading to free agency.... might as well be comparing apples to peanuts.

Yes but when the Demons get pick 3 for Frawley and Collingwood/us will get less for Beams/Ryder it makes Free agency compensation a ****ing joke.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Yes but when the Demons get pick 3 for Frawley and Collingwood/us will get less for Beams/Ryder it makes Free agency compensation a ******* joke.

It's bullshit isn't it watch Melbourne pick a dud with #3

 

[rines]

Yes but when the Demons get pick 3 for Frawley and Collingwood/us will get less for Beams/Ryder it makes Free agency compensation a ******* joke.

Exactly this. Free Agency compensation wasn't meant to be the jackpot...

How the heck does anyone create a system where Frawley is worth more than Beams ffs..

AFL needed to give them an End of Round 1 pick (20 odd) at best..

 

[Halftimehero]

Damian Barrett ‏@barrettdamian 7m7 minutes ago
Winderlich wants out. Wants fresh start, new club, demoralised by drugs saga. I believe he is not facing show-cause notice @traderadio @AFL

 

[sacka]

Exactly this. Free Agency compensation wasn't meant to be the jackpot...

How the heck does anyone create a system where Frawley is worth more than Beams ffs..

AFL needed to give them an End of Round 1 pick (20 odd) at best..

Hawks only got 20 for Franklin, Saints got 13(?) for Goddard, the comp pick is a complete ****ing joke, Carlton got 11 for Dale Thomas lol, it's all over the shop and should be scratched straight away.

 

[Fin ice Smuggler]

look, when it's us v the saints it's no contest. they can give him a buttload more money and guarantee him games. If he wants to toil away in mediocrity for the next 8 years then who are we to stop him.

We did get McKenna who could have had his pick of all 18 clubs and gone to ones with an established irish contingent but he chose us, that is saying something

Who says we wont be mediocre for next 8 years, saints will be good in 5.

 

[Zach Package]

Who says we wont be mediocre for next 8 years, saints will be good in 5.

conventional logic