Recruiting EFC Trade/Draft Talk II with F/A rules in OP - Billings for a fourth rounder the latest rumour

[Mercuri Rising]

Whose position does he take as that one dimensional inside midfielder? Heppell? No Watson? Please BJ? Nope Myers? Doubt it

I wasn't saying he was demanding a spot at full-strength, but with Jobe having ~10 weeks off, Howlett and Melksham having bad patches...and there were games when he was an odd vest choice (and yes, I know he wasn't vested all that much). That's all.

 

[Ess_don]

Trade Radio ‏@traderadio 50s50 seconds ago
Dodoro on Ryder: We've told @PAFC what we want, that's a quality player in return. We're concerned about our list right now

That first sentence is great, but the second part is slightly concerning.. Im hoping Im just reading that wrong or out of context?
Why exactly is our list manager concerned about our list??

 

[Ben the Gooner]

That first sentence is great, but the second part is slightly concerning.. Im hoping Im just reading that wrong or out of context?
Why exactly is our list manager concerned about our list??

Ridiculously malicious misquote. "We're just worried about our list"

 

[Mercuri Rising]

That first sentence is great, but the second part is slightly concerning.. Im hoping Im just reading that wrong or out of context?
Why exactly is our list manager concerned about our list??

..as in "we're just focussed on our list", I think.

 

[citizen-erased]

That first sentence is great, but the second part is slightly concerning.. Im hoping Im just reading that wrong or out of context?
Why exactly is our list manager concerned about our list??

1 identified ruck
short on key position forwards.
not a lot of pace in the middle
and we don't have much in the way of small forwards.

Im concerned too.
The Ryder trade will suck, but Dodoro looks in control of what we want/need.

 

[efcboy]

Are you sure? I thought that he could be picked up in the ND like normal, and we get him if he gets to the RD. Would like to be wrong though

Not sure i can't recall a father son rookie nomination previously.

 

[hollywood23]

I actually cannot believe Winderlich will play elsewhere in 2015.

Really shattering to hear that a heart and soul type bloke 'retired' and is thinking of coming back only to play somewhere else.

The clouds are getting darker and winter is coming.

 

[Old Campaigner]

The clouds are getting darker and winter is coming.

The worst thing is its a winter of our own making.

 

[ghostdog]

I actually cannot believe Winderlich will play elsewhere in 2015.

Really shattering to hear that a heart and soul type bloke 'retired' and is thinking of coming back only to play somewhere else.

The clouds are getting darker and winter is coming.

As long as winter is coming I may not mind so much... nope, shattering.

 

[fronkalicious]

Hey guys

Do you think there'd be any interest in trading pick 17 from the Ryder trade for picks 26 and 27 and we could upgrade your 3rd rounder as well. So:

Dogs get - 17 and 52
Ess get - 26, 27 and 44.

Gives you an additional early second rounder for dropping back 9 places (17 to 29).

Cheers

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Hey guys

Do you think there'd be any interest in trading pick 17 from the Ryder trade for picks 26 and 27 and we could upgrade your 3rd rounder as well. So:

Dogs get - 17 and 52
Ess get - 26, 27 and 44.

Gives you an additional early second rounder for dropping back 9 places (17 to 29).

Cheers

There is no way we will be trading the Ryder pick.

 

[Aussie Assault]

Hey guys

Do you think there'd be any interest in trading pick 17 from the Ryder trade for picks 26 and 27 and we could upgrade your 3rd rounder as well. So:

Dogs get - 17 and 52
Ess get - 26, 27 and 44.

Gives you an additional early second rounder for dropping back 9 places (17 to 29).

Cheers

Quantity > Quality right?

 

[hollywood23]

Hey guys

Do you think there'd be any interest in trading pick 17 from the Ryder trade for picks 26 and 27 and we could upgrade your 3rd rounder as well. So:

Dogs get - 17 and 52
Ess get - 26, 27 and 44.

Gives you an additional early second rounder for dropping back 9 places (17 to 29).

Cheers

No.

 

[Zach Package]

Hey guys

Do you think there'd be any interest in trading pick 17 from the Ryder trade for picks 26 and 27 and we could upgrade your 3rd rounder as well. So:

Dogs get - 17 and 52
Ess get - 26, 27 and 44.

Gives you an additional early second rounder for dropping back 9 places (17 to 29).

Cheers

Not the first time it's been brought up. I think it's a bit dependent on what else we land in a deal for Ryder and how many list spots we need to fill though. It becomes a better idea if we end up losing say 8 off the main list, if it's 4-5 then I can't really see the benefit for us tbh.

 

[Kakkle]

Has Tyler Keitel dropped big time? Don't even see him in some phantom drafts anymore.

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Not sure i can't recall a father son rookie nomination previously.

He's treated as a normal player in the ND, and can be picked anywhere from pick 1 to pick 1001. If no one picks him, he's automatically selected as our final rookie pick.

 

[Keystone agony]

Has Tyler Keitel dropped big time? Don't even see him in some phantom drafts anymore.

Yes unsure why, buts drooped off the rictor. Did he not get a combine invite?

Also Clem Smith is another who is dropping.

 

[yaco55]

Disappointing that we missed out on membrey as there was something to be developed.

I am surprised,actually staggered that Waterman didn't get a bid - he's a good chance to play round 1.

 

[yaco55]

I know it's not all that likely but the #exodus that was mooted months ago may actually be coming to fruition through a variety of reasons.

Paddy Ryder (Port Adelaide)
Jason Winderlich (rumoured Richmond now)
Kyle Hardingham (WA)
Ben Howlett (Carlton)
Leroy Jetta (quit the club)

The only one's that could be linked with the supplements program are Ryder and Winderlich - And Winder's doesn't have a Show cause.

 

[fronkalicious]

Thanks for the responses guys. Agree that quality>quantity. But look at the quality you got at 27 last year, and if guys like licker do leave, maybe two picks in the late 20s and one in the early 3rd round, is more valuable than a pick 17 and another in the 50s. Cheers for the chat.

 

[Howard Moon]

Insane in the membrey to go for a 4th rounder ! Gutting.

Stk come out and said they nearly drafted him originally....Sydney drsfted him with they pick they got from Stk for Trent Dennis lane.

So hes just been lay by

 

[lenny2013]

Jonathan Giles manager was on Trade radio and said he was interested in Adelaide & Essendon.

His manager also said he was waiting for the Ryder trade to play out before making a decision.

 

[CourtzMajora]

I'd rather we not go for Giles.

 

[Seagrave_Holmes]

I hope we get Giles.

 

[Kakkle]

I could go either way with Giles.