Coach Emma Kearney - will join Clarko's coaching team as development coach and player development co-ordinator

[Del191229]

No shes not.

Emma Kearney won the equivalent of the Brownlow in a premiership year.

She's been All Australian every season she's played.

Barlow was a 6.5/10 dreamteam player, Lynch a handy mid/forward connector, 7.5/10

Neither of them are even close to her in footy achievements or ability.

That's she's learning to be a coach while still captaining a side to a grand final is like ... der.

Are Barlow and Lynch still playing?

No, they're not. Maybe that's why they have more senior roles, because they've retired after middling playing careers lol.

 

[Del191229]

Yes they have?

Tom Lynch has run a VFL program for 18 months and been a senior development coach for North during that time.

Mick Barlow was the VFL coach of the year last year and led a non aligned VFL club to the grand final on a 17 game winning streak. He's now Head of Development at North.

Emma has?

Yes, because they retired years ago, Emma is still playing.

 

[Del191229]

If some of our blokes had Emma's aggression and smarts onfield we'd be a different side.

 

[shinboner magic]

Oh gawd you ppl make me laugh.
The Horizons_00 just asked what she brings not that she’s not good enough.

We very part of the club is getting scrutinised at the moment - no need to jump at shadows

 

[hilly]

Now its Emma's fault according to Sphynx that these blokes put no effort in

Whos next?

The girl at the Roo Shop?

The MC on game day? Actually he might be to blame

Yet to blame his mate Rawling..

On SM-S901E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Colby Cheer Squad]

She was there last year mate in a coaching role.

I've watched plenty of training.

She's akin to a work experience kid getting some valuable experience to be a long term asset to the womens program imo.

She doesn't take drills, she's not vocal at all at training.

It's a mentorship, assistant coach in name only.


I have no problem with her position, but she's not Tom Lynch or Barlow, anyone who has watched even a second of training would realise that.

I've seen her run drills.

 

[koshari]

Now its Emma's fault according to Sphynx that these blokes put no effort in

Whos next?

The girl at the Roo Shop?

The MC on game day? Actually he might be to blame

the rot all started back in the 90s with this woman,














btw ^^^^ this is sarcasm for those that havnt realised

 

[koshari]

oh and while we are woman bashing, this lady has a lot to answer for. , if you cant control your elephant the flank is no place to be!!

 

[Sphynx]

Now its Emma's fault according to Sphynx that these blokes put no effort in

Whos next?

The girl at the Roo Shop?

The MC on game day? Actually he might be to blame

lol what?

I didn't even criticize her.

 

[koshari]

lol what?

I didn't even criticize her.

pppfffft,

there you go letting facts get in the way of a good story again!

 

[Sphynx]

pppfffft,

there you go letting facts get in the way of a good story again!

"Kearney's position is not a problem and the least of our issues, but stop making s**t up, she's been there for 2 years and she's not in any way an assistant coach or a line coach. Shes a "development coach" as in "watch and learn" shes very much a developing coach herself.

Hopefully one that I think will be a great asset to the AFLW program or maybe the AFL mens program long term."

 

[Sphynx]

Emma Kearney won the equivalent of the Brownlow in a premiership year.

She's been All Australian every season she's played.

Barlow was a 6.5/10 dreamteam player, Lynch a handy mid/forward connector, 7.5/10

Neither of them are even close to her in footy achievements or ability.

That's she's learning to be a coach while still captaining a side to a grand final is like ... der.

Are Barlow and Lynch still playing?

No, they're not. Maybe that's why they have more senior roles, because they've retired after middling playing careers lol.

Emma > Anthony Stevens then.

AFLW runs from September to November and is semi-professional.

I don't think her duties during this period have held back her coaching career.

In fact she left her full time role as a teacher to work for North.

I think that probably had a little to do with it. lol.

 

[Horizons_00]

Oh gawd you ppl make me laugh.
The Horizons_00 just asked what she brings not that she’s not good enough.

We very part of the club is getting scrutinised at the moment - no need to jump at shadows

I honestly didn’t mean it for everyone to get there knickers in a knot.

I don’t live in Melb, I can’t see much in regards to training etc

To call it woman bashing is insane. No one would be protected from criticism just because of what is between their legs haha

Everyone on this list needs to be questioned imo not just Emma. I should have made a seperate thread to tip toe around everyone’s sensitivity idk.

 

[Horizons_00]

Kearney is so, so far down the list of coaching/footy department concerns.

Monkhurtst, Clarke, and Adcock would be where I'd start if you want to start peeling back assistant coach performance issues.

Ok but why is she so far down on the list of concerns?

My bad, I thought she was a development coach as in she is responsible for developing our players / youth haha

 

[koshari]

Ok but why is she so far down on the list of concerns?

My bad, I thought she was a development coach as in she is responsible for developing our players / youth haha

so was gavin brown!

 

[Sphynx]

Ok but why is she so far down on the list of concerns?

My bad, I thought she was a development coach as in she is responsible for developing our players / youth haha

She needs to be separate from the others, because she is separate from the others.

She isn't included within the soft cap, so the alternative would need to be another female coach.

Given her contribution to the AFLW program, she is deserving of the post.

It's an initiative to develop the female coaching ranks, which is a good one.

 

[Horizons_00]

so was gavin brown!

My mistake, she is developing under Clarko to be a coach. Makes sense

 

[koshari]

I honestly didn’t mean it for everyone to get there knickers in a knot.

I don’t live in Melb, I can’t see much in regards to training etc

To call it woman bashing is insane. No one would be protected from criticism just because of what is between their legs haha

Everyone on this list needs to be questioned imo not just Emma. I should have made a seperate thread to tip toe around everyone’s sensitivity idk.

View attachment 1968147

i was sort of referring to myself sarcastically in the 3rd person with the woman bashing quip... wasnt directed to you,

 

[Heaps of fun]

Emma Kearney won the equivalent of the Brownlow in a premiership year.

She's been All Australian every season she's played.

Barlow was a 6.5/10 dreamteam player, Lynch a handy mid/forward connector, 7.5/10

Neither of them are even close to her in footy achievements or ability.

That's she's learning to be a coach while still captaining a side to a grand final is like ... der.

Are Barlow and Lynch still playing?

No, they're not. Maybe that's why they have more senior roles, because they've retired after middling playing careers lol.

Comparing AFLW to AFL players on ability is insane. The worst AFL players would dominate. Mick Barlow was an absurdly good footballer, went from playing for Werribee to winning 13 Brownlow votes in his first 12 games of footy and Tom Lynch contributed to changing how tall forwards play the game, averaging near midfield numbers while still good for over a goal a game. Kearney wouldn't get a touch in AFL, she would be too slow and weak by magnitudes.

She might end up a decent AFL coach but it'll have nothing to do with her ability as a player compared to the men she's coaching.

 

[Sphynx]

Comparing AFLW to AFL players on ability is insane. The worst AFL players would dominate. Mick Barlow was an absurdly good footballer, went from playing for Werribee to winning 13 Brownlow votes in his first 12 games of footy and Tom Lynch contributed to changing how tall forwards play the game, averaging near midfield numbers while still good for over a goal a game. Kearney wouldn't get a touch in AFL, she would be too slow and weak by magnitudes.

She might end up a decent AFL coach but it'll have nothing to do with her ability as a player compared to the men she's coaching.

Careful.

If you don't consider Erin Phillips as good as Gary Ablett Jnr in the eyes of some, you risk being labelled a misogynist.

 

[Chadwiko]

Ok but why is she so far down on the list of concerns?

Before we start, let's just clarify something; what is it you think a development coach does?

 

[Teen Wolf]

Careful.

If you don't consider Erin Phillips as good as Gary Ablett Jnr in the eyes of some, you risk being labelled a misogynist.

"Erin Phillips is as good a 14-year old as I've ever seen play football" says John Cahill.

When it was a fair fight, she ran rings around the boys, and so did other freak players like Emma Kearney. To say they aren't all-time great footballers is the same as discrediting Manny Pacquiao for not being a heavyweight.

 

[koshari]

Before we start, let's just clarify something; what is it you think a development coach does?

would i be naive to suggest "develop" ??

 

[Horizons_00]

Before we start, let's just clarify something; what is it you think a development coach does?

I got it wrong mate, as i said i misinterpreted her role

 

[tazaa]

Kearney is so, so far down the list of coaching/footy department concerns.

Monkhurtst, Clarke, and Adcock would be where I'd start if you want to start peeling back assistant coach performance issues.

I think Patch taking over Jordan Russell's role has been one major **** up we made over summer.
Patch has shown nothing to be promoted to handling the midfield and so far it looks like an absolute shit show.

Reality is he is not getting any heat because hes a much loved son of the club.