- Jul 7, 2014
- 2,842
- 3,879
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Good post Misher I don't really disagree with any of that.
Only things I have to add to that are...
I don't think anyone does. A proper cull has been needed for years.
Shaw doesn't belong on this list. He's one of our best when he's fit and can do a job long term at LB or LCB. The rest I agree with.
Malacia picked up a LTI in pre season and is yet to return from it. He was only ever signed as depth, and as a depth option he's perfectly adequate. This is not a signing that United fans are concerned with.
I don't think a recent improvement in form is fooling anyone. The same problems with the gameplan and lack of identity are clear to see. What's changed though is that this recent run of results has coincided with the return of Martinez (albeit briefly) & Casemiro. This is currently the strongest team that United have been able to field this season and that's why we've seen some marginal improvement, but if you look closely the same problems still exist.
Only things I have to add to that are...
I don’t see title winning potential in your squad
I don't think anyone does. A proper cull has been needed for years.
Maguire, Varane, Rashford, Eriksen, Amrabat, Casemiro, Shaw, McTominay, Martial, Evans, AWB, Vindelof, etc. aren’t gonna get any better/are already trash so ideally you’ll boot a lot of them.
Shaw doesn't belong on this list. He's one of our best when he's fit and can do a job long term at LB or LCB. The rest I agree with.
Then there’s Malacia, but I’m not even sure he exists?
Malacia picked up a LTI in pre season and is yet to return from it. He was only ever signed as depth, and as a depth option he's perfectly adequate. This is not a signing that United fans are concerned with.
Just feels like such a long road back and your recent set of results are going to keep you in that never ending cycle that Sozabarus referred to above.
I don't think a recent improvement in form is fooling anyone. The same problems with the gameplan and lack of identity are clear to see. What's changed though is that this recent run of results has coincided with the return of Martinez (albeit briefly) & Casemiro. This is currently the strongest team that United have been able to field this season and that's why we've seen some marginal improvement, but if you look closely the same problems still exist.