Geelong and Hawthorn record monumentally embarrassing 800 page shitfight thread.

[Nuggets73]

What you call a sh1t joke is clearly a reality

And whats more theres been plenty of Geelong chest puffing about Pokies - how is it our fault that yours do so badly?

Locals blew all the money on meth!! ;-)

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Yeah you have a few screws loose no doubt about it, but I thought I'd be classy and not keep referring to your obvious instability.

Hypocrisy means what I said it does. You're being a hypocrite, case closed. It's not like it's even in your Top 10 worst attributes, so I'd just accept it if I were you.

Cease quoting me you fruit loop.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

We have established that Geelong play home games at the MCG therefore making it your second home ground (like Hawks in Tasmania)
So therefore you did have a home ground advantage over StKilda and Port Adelaide.
The Collingwood game, we shall call that a neutral venue as both teams host home games at the MCG.

Now you've reverted back to being silly again.

 

[RedVest4]

We have established that Geelong play home games at the MCG therefore making it your second home ground (like Hawks in Tasmania)
So therefore you did have a home ground advantage over StKilda and Port Adelaide.
The Collingwood game, we shall call that a neutral venue as both teams host home games at the MCG.

2 week sig bet says you're wrong Deano...

 

[A Cut Above]

That screw loosened again?

I find it utterly ironic that at one time or another you've accused almost every Hawthorn poster in this thread of having a screw loose.

Its not hard to imagine what Freud would say about that.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

I find it utterly ironic that at one time or another you've accused almost every Hawthorn poster in this thread of having a screw loose.

Its not hard to imagine what Freud would say about that.

Just Podgey and yourself. You've been wrong that many times in this thread there's no other explanation. Not to mention you're the only person I know who has melted after their team has won ... and a final too I might add.

Between the both of you you've had 5 accounts which says more about you than it does me.

Freud would agree, most definitely. I've had many a patient that share many a similarity to the both of you and they eventually recovered so there's hope.

 

[Josh_hawk]

St Kilda and Collingwood were both great sides those years, theres no denying that. Plus we didn't get home ground advantage against them...

Geelong were a great side in 2008 fair to say 21/1 wasn't it?
Fremantle exceptional in 2013 - purple haze were going to?
Sydney finished minor premiers in 2014
And WCE last year were a great side no denying that.

It is what it is.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Geelong were a great side in 2008 fair to say 21/1 wasn't it?
Fremantle exceptional in 2013 - purple haze were going to?
Sydney finished minor premiers in 2014
And WCE last year were a great side no denying that.

It is what it is.

You played 3 average interstate sides on the MCG. Hardly noteworthy when you consider what happened when you played West Coast on their home turf a few weeks prior.

The fact that you walked away from 4 consecutive grand finals against interstate sides with only 3 flags speaks volumes of the credibility of your dynasty, and it only goes to confirm how much superior Geelong's dynasty was in comparison.

You're just unlucky Geelong will never have the stigma of losing a final en route to a flag.

 

[RedVest4]

Geelong were a great side in 2008 fair to say 21/1 wasn't it?
Fremantle exceptional in 2013 - purple haze were going to?
Sydney finished minor premiers in 2014
And WCE last year were a great side no denying that.

It is what it is.

Lol West Coast a great side

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Lol West Coast a great side

Port Adelaide of 07 would have beaten that West Coast side by 10 goals.

 

[Josh_hawk]

You played 3 average interstate sides on the MCG.

But not in 2008....




or 1989

 

[Josh_hawk]

Port Adelaide of 07 would have beaten that West Coast side by 10 goals.

Theres that fruitful imagination again...

 

[A Cut Above]

Just Podgey and yourself. You've been wrong that many times in this thread there's no other explanation. Not to mention you're the only person I know who has melted after their team has won ... and a final too I might add.

Between the both of you you've had 5 accounts which says more about you than it does me.

Freud would agree, most definitely. I've had many a patient that share many a similarity to the both of you and they eventually recovered so there's hope.

Number of times Leathality has threatened to stab opposition supporters: 0
Number of times A Cut Above has threatened to stab opposition supporters: 0
Number of times Nakia has threatened to stab opposition supporters: At least once

So you're half right, one of us is a bit nutty.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

But not in 2008....

It's a pity 08 is irrelevant with Hawthorn dynasty discussions.

Theres that fruitful imagination again...

I'll go further by saying Port would have comfortably beaten all of Sydney, Fremantle and West Coast.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Are you actually a Lunch Lady called Doris?

Yes. But that's a pretty boring reply bro.

 

[RedVest4]

Number of times Leathality has threatened to stab opposition supporters: 0
Number of times A Cut Above has threatened to stab opposition supporters: 0
Number of times Nakia has threatened to stab opposition supporters: At least once

So you're half right, one of us is a bit nutty.

I'm actually curious about this, what's the story with Nakia and the stabbing?

 

[RedVest4]

It's a pity 08 is irrelevant with Hawthorn dynasty discussions.


I'll go further by saying Port would have comfortably beaten all of Sydney, Fremantle and West Coast.

I'll go even one step further and say a best 22 of West Coast, Sydney and Freo would have lost to Port 07...

 

[dean31]

Now you've reverted back to being silly again.

You played 3 average interstate sides on the MCG. Hardly noteworthy when you consider what happened when you played West Coast on their home turf a few weeks prior.

The fact that you walked away from 4 consecutive grand finals against interstate sides with only 3 flags speaks volumes of the credibility of your dynasty, and it only goes to confirm how much superior Geelong's dynasty was in comparison.

You're just unlucky Geelong will never have the stigma of losing a final en route to a flag.

Who is been silly again??
The fact that the Hawks won 3/4 Premierships against teams that were ranked higher on the ladder speaks volumes of their wins.
Going the long way around to win the Premiership just makes it a lot more impressive and the experts agree.
Perhaps if Geelong didn't straight set they to could have had the glory of going the long way to win a Premiership.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Yes. But that's a pretty boring reply bro.

27.9/5
Fair dinkum unbelievable

 

[Josh_hawk]

Who is been silly again??
The fact that the Hawks won 3/4 Premierships against teams that were ranked higher on the ladder speaks volumes of their wins.
Going the long way around to win the Premiership just makes it a lot more impressive and the experts agree.
Perhaps if Geelong didn't straight set they to could have had the glory of going the long way to win a Premiership.

Straight sets twice
Atleast the Tiges got one on them

 

[dean31]

I'll go even one step further and say a best 22 of West Coast, Sydney and Freo would have lost to Port 07...

Port Adelaide 2007 finished 2nd

Port Adelaide
15W 7L 113.54



Clearly inferior to any of the Hawks grand final opposition.
They didn't set that abysmal record losing margin without reason. Geelong 2007 were not even as good as Geelong 2008 and we all know what happened in 08.

 

[A Cut Above]

I'm actually curious about this, what's the story with Nakia and the stabbing?

Stabby threatened to go loco with a knife on any Hawthorn supporter he came across in a Bay thread, in the aftermath of the 2013 prelim.

Which was the catalyst for me 'encouraging' Hawthorn supporters to vote for him in last year's AWOTY. He's over that now though.. I think.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Hypocrisy means what I said it does.

Unless Nakia runs a pokie venue, he isn't a hypocrite.

 

[dipper86]

The Geelong tin rattle is officially on.
Extract from AFL.com.au article.

"GEELONG hopes to raise $13 million in an ambitious fundraising project intended to make the club debt-free for the first time in almost 50 years.

At the club's season launch on Tuesday night, Cats president Colin Carter said the once-in-a-generation initiative would be called 'Our Ambition'

So what we have is a minnow confirming its football club is a minnow by having a tin rattle to help its minnow football club be debt free for the first time in 50 minnow years.

Why is it so hard for peasant Geelong supporters to accept its Minnow status, To our amusement we have been reminding them for over 270 pages and now the head of it football club has all but confirmed its football clubs minnow status.
Burnt by its very own football club.
Thank You.

 

[dipper86]

You played 3 average interstate sides on the MCG. Hardly noteworthy when you consider what happened when you played West Coast on their home turf a few weeks prior.

The fact that you walked away from 4 consecutive grand finals against interstate sides with only 3 flags speaks volumes of the credibility of your dynasty, and it only goes to confirm how much superior Geelong's dynasty was in comparison.

You're just unlucky Geelong will never have the stigma of losing a final en route to a flag.

But in reality, the 2008 Hawthorn side which beat Geelong in the prime of its dynasty was inferior to the Hawthorn sides of 2013-2015.
So ultimately that makes Geelong an inferior team and its dynasty inferior in every facet....No back to back or 3pete.

Unlucky, your greatest ever era has been overshadowed by Hawthorn