Geelong and Hawthorn record monumentally embarrassing 800 page shitfight thread.

[Lethality]

One good thing about Billie. He's not very smart, but he knows the difference between a kick and a handball.

Good to see you reverting back to that particular deflection every time you get owned here No wonder I keep hearing about it.

 

[dean31]

No opinion old mate ... only facts. They're there in black and white.

Hawthorn supporters can form a line at the "Lick my plums" queue...

You do realise your stats only show that Geelong under achieved? H&A dominance followed by an even mix of success and choking.
As for the individual honours they mean absolutely nothing in team vs comparisons. All the highlights is that Geelong depended on a larger number of individuals to perform, Hawthorn had a more balanced and even output from their entire team. Many capable of taking Brownlow votes etc off each other week to week.
Dynasties are measured in Premierships with consecutive GF wins internationally accepted as been a greater achievement than no peat Gf wins.

 

[Josh_hawk]

One good thing about Billie. He's not very smart, but he knows the difference between a kick and a handball.

That gag still going? facepalm.gif

By all means keep it going though - just shows you light on material - which is understandable

Hawthorn is greater

You should know that greatness is not our ambition, it is our reality

13 > 9

Which could've been 11 = 11 but the Cats didn't know the difference between a kick and a handball and spudded, not one but two GFs against us!

 

[Josh_hawk]

You do realise your stats only show that Geelong under achieved? H&A dominance followed by an even mix of success and choking.
As for the individual honours they mean absolutely nothing in team vs comparisons. All the highlights is that Geelong depended on a larger number of individuals to perform, Hawthorn had a more balanced and even output from their entire team. Many capable of taking Brownlow votes etc off each other week to week.
Dynasties are measured in Premierships with consecutive GF wins internationally accepted as been a greater achievement than no peat Gf wins.

Im sorry Deano I'm going to have to interject here mate

Don't you realise that Football is an individual game played by many individuals all striving to be the best out of their own group of individuals

Thats where HFC have gone and f23ed it up!!!

By the way the dynasty thing is a done argument because humans in essence should not compare between a potato and a pumpkin nor a club which may or may not be better than another - because you can't compare

 

[Smedts_2]

Good to see you reverting back to that particular deflection every time you get owned here No wonder I keep hearing about it.

Lol - owned by Hodgepodge. Basically that would be lost property.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

You do realise your stats only show that Geelong under achieved? H&A dominance followed by an even mix of success and choking.
As for the individual honours they mean absolutely nothing in team vs comparisons. All the highlights is that Geelong depended on a larger number of individuals to perform, Hawthorn had a more balanced and even output from their entire team. Many capable of taking Brownlow votes etc off each other week to week.
Dynasties are measured in Premierships with consecutive GF wins internationally accepted as been a greater achievement than no peat Gf wins.

Nope, not at all. Those stats show Geelong's dynasty to be marginally better than Brisbane's and a lot better than Hawthorn's.

 

[Lethality]

Lol - owned by Hodgepodge. Basically that would be lost property.

Your ramblings would amount to as much.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Nope, not at all. Those stats show Geelong's dynasty to be marginally better than Brisbane's and a lot better than Hawthorn's.

Thats a whole lot of comparing going on there mate

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

By the way the dynasty thing is a done argument because humans in essence should not compare between a potato and a pumpkin nor a club which may or may not be better than another - because you can't compare

Did chortle.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Thats a whole lot of comparing going on there mate

I'm MCing at a house party tonight, you coming?

 

[Josh_hawk]

Nope, not at all. Those stats show Geelong's dynasty to be marginally better than Brisbane's and a lot better than Hawthorn's.

You really should have a toilet paper dispenser on your chin when carrying on with this argument

Does the opinion of a journalist mean more to you than Ex Premiership Captains that did so much for you dynasty-less club

I mean really dude, come on

Please explain yourself

 

[Josh_hawk]

I'm MCing at a house party tonight, you coming?

hmmm nup

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Does the opinion of a journalist mean more to you than Ex Premiership Captains that did so much for you dynasty-less club

I prefer the 'facts' from said journalist thanks.

 

[Josh_hawk]

I prefer the 'facts' from said journalist thanks.

http://www.geelongadvertiser.com.au...t/news-story/58fe58f57a71d6717ffdd16ccd2a2f15

^^^^^^^^^ and its the bloody Advertiser, shame on them for knowing the truth and they didn't need to resort to colourful tables about AA's


Some nice reading if you're up to it
http://www.upstart.net.au/2015/10/09/comparing-eras/


Not only Lingy and Harley but now Kelly ... but their opinions should not matter because effectively they know nothing
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-ne...mply-better-than-geelong-20150403-1me96p.html

"I think Hawthorn are a better side than us," Kelly said on Friday. "It's hard to put a finger on what it is, they've just had the better of us the last few times. I think the ones we've won we've been maybe a little bit lucky."

Mark Riccutio has chirped in as well, fair to say he's got a greater understanding of the game than most journalists....
http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport...l/news-story/4899e35e0ee85c58fd290f4f5efbf83d

But I like how your article has pictures

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

http://www.geelongadvertiser.com.au...t/news-story/58fe58f57a71d6717ffdd16ccd2a2f15

^^^^^^^^^ and its the bloody Advertiser, shame on them for knowing the truth and they didn't need to resort to colourful tables about AA's


Some nice reading if you're up to it
http://www.upstart.net.au/2015/10/09/comparing-eras/


Not only Lingy and Harley but now Kelly ... but their opinions should not matter because effectively they know nothing
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-ne...mply-better-than-geelong-20150403-1me96p.html

"I think Hawthorn are a better side than us," Kelly said on Friday. "It's hard to put a finger on what it is, they've just had the better of us the last few times. I think the ones we've won we've been maybe a little bit lucky."

Mark Riccutio has chirped in as well, fair to say he's got a greater understanding of the game than most journalists....
http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport...l/news-story/4899e35e0ee85c58fd290f4f5efbf83d

But I like how your article has pictures

That's opinion old boy, I only deal with facts.

 

[A Cut Above]

I will see you on Monday. Young and Jackson's.

Don't take any chances Josh_hawk. For a mere $1,000 your family will rest easy knowing you're safe:
http://www.defencesystemsaustralia.com.au/product/stab-resistant-vests/

 

[Josh_hawk]

Don't take any chances Josh_hawk. For a mere $1,000 your family will rest easy knowing you're safe:
http://www.defencesystemsaustralia.com.au/product/stab-resistant-vests/

Thats actually very good

 

[Josh_hawk]

That's opinion old boy, I only deal with facts.

So the "opinions" of former players and ex premiership captains are meaningless??

They don't mean anything at all??

 

[RedVest4]

Is Vesty going?

Yep I'll be there

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

So the "opinions" of former players and ex premiership captains are meaningless??

They don't mean anything at all??

Facts Boy, facts, in case you missed it the previous 5 times.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Woof Woof!

 

[Josh_hawk]

Facts Boy, facts, in case you missed it the previous 5 times.

I understand thats your angle but what about Harley, Ling and Kelly - do they know nothing

This is what Im asking

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

I understand thats your angle but what about Harley, Ling and Kelly - do they know nothing

This is what Im asking

Listen here mate, I've already explained why 'fact' counters 'opinion'. You keep running with that angle because you realise so too.

 

[Packedlunch]

Facts Boy, facts, in case you missed it the previous 5 times.

It's clear to me that sustained excellence can only mean consecutive premierships, maybe GF appearances if you must widen the scope. Cats fail miserably in both.

Fact.

 

[RedVest4]

Remember when Carey said Mitchell wouldn't get a game at Carlton?