Geelong and Hawthorn record monumentally embarrassing 800 page shitfight thread.

[Jhye Clark 13]

It's clear to me that sustained excellence can only mean consecutive premierships, maybe GF appearances if you must widen the scope. Cats fail miserably in both.

Fact.

It's clear that you're at the back of the suck my plums queue... push your way forward.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Listen here mate, I've already explained why 'fact' counters 'opinion'. You keep running with that angle because you realise so too.

Quite the opposite actually

I just want to hear you admit that the opinions of former Geelong greats carry no weight in football discussions. I understand if you think what leigh Matthews or Jason Dunstable is BS but when its one of your own....

Just answer the question - its really not that hard

 

[11sjw]

So selective use of certain facts outweigh the opinion of the heavily educated.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Quite the opposite actually

I just want to hear you admit that the opinions of former Geelong greats carry no weight in football discussions. I understand if you think what leigh Matthews or Jason Dunstable is BS but when its one of your own....

Just answer the question - its really not that hard

Facts always counter opinion. I'm not sure why it's so hard interpreting my answer.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Remember when Carey said Mitchell wouldn't get a game at Carlton?

Yeah I also remember when he gave it to Mrs Stevens, belted his GF and got done with coke all over him in a drug scanner

Im talking about Geelong ex premiership captains and players who are a lot more respectable than him - unless you've got some mail for us as to why these blokes opinions shouldn't be listened to.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Facts always counter opinion. I'm not sure why it's so hard interpreting my answer.

So ill agree with you in theory then

So by your own logic Hawthorn is greater than Geelong because success is measured in Premierships

This fact is undeniable

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Yeah I also remember when he gave it to Mrs Stevens, belted his GF and got done with coke all over him in a drug scanner

Im talking about Geelong ex premiership captains and players who are a lot more respectable than him - unless you've got some mail for us as to why these blokes opinions shouldn't be listened to.

Funny that! I bore witness to a one James Kelly snorting cocaine from a kitchen bench.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

So ill agree with you in theory then

So by your own logic Hawthorn is greater than Geelong because success is measured in Premierships

This fact is undeniable

3 premiership is neither greater or less than 3 premierships ... fact.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Funny that! I bore witness to a one James Kelly snorting cocaine from a kitchen bench.

Geelong James Kelly?

He must have needed something to help him deal with the PEDS

 

[Josh_hawk]

3 premiership is neither greater or less than 3 premierships ... fact.

But 13 is greater than 9 (with a headstart)... fact

But it could've been 11 = 11 but the greater beat the lesser twice on the big day

D'oh!!!

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Geelong James Kelly?

He must have needed something to help him deal with the PEDS

Ah the old 'I've conceded' PED's line. You're a lot smarter than the need to go down that path mate.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

But 13 is greater than 9 (with a headstart)... fact

But it could've been 11 = 11 but the greater beat the lesser twice on the big day

D'oh!!!

I'm not arguing with the entire history of both clubs am I? If I were to do that the mediocre Hawks would be exposed to have had more spoons than flags up until a few years ago.

This is about respective dynasties though, isn't it?

 

[Packedlunch]

3 premiership is neither greater or less than 3 premierships ... fact.

2 premierships only for the cats soz. Can't count 2011 as they shit the bed and missed the GF in 2010.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Ah the old 'I've conceded' PED's line. You're a lot smarter than the need to go down that path mate.

And yes, Geelong's James Kelly. With two other triple premierships players. 2004 was the year.

How on earth is that conceding?

Why you making public that Geelong are on the drugs when you and the Swedish geelong follower in particular carry on so much about HFC players and drugs

Bit weird - but thanks for the intel

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

2 premierships only for the cats soz. Can't count 2011 as they shit the bed and missed the GF in 2010.

Nice try.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

How on earth is that conceding?

Why you making public that Geelong are on the drugs when you and the Swedish geelong follower in particular carry on so much about HFC players and drugs

Bit weird - but thanks for the intel

Um, you'll hear a great deal more about drugs soon enough pal. Brace yourself.

 

[Josh_hawk]

I'm not arguing with the entire history of both clubs am I? If I were to do that the mediocre Hawks would be exposed to have had more spoons than flags up until a few years ago.

This is about respective dynasties though, isn't it?

Dude - success is measured in Premierships not over a year span decided by you

And the fact that we have had so many spoons only amplifies how great we actually are to rise from the ashes to dominate the VFL and AFL

 

[Packedlunch]

Nice try.

It's fact. Consecutive GF's at a minimum constitutes sustained success.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Dude - success is measured in Premierships not over a year span decided by you

And the fact that we have had so many spoons only amplifies how great we actually are to rise from the ashes to dominate the VFL and AFL

Exactly! Since we've formed the conclusion that 3 premierships is equal to 3 premierships, statistics, etc, then come into play.

Those pretty tables I posted paint a true picture.

I'll ignore the zoning concessions and high draft picks needed to do it for now.

It's fact. Consecutive GF's at a minimum constitutes sustained success.

You're edging closer to the front.

 

[TallyHawk]

Ah the old 'I've conceded' PED's line. You're a lot smarter than the need to go down that path mate.

And yes, Geelong's James Kelly. With two other triple premierships players. 2004 was the year.

Oh cool so ruling out Stokesy, Pops and 2 other premiership stars were on the gear. Was it SJ and Moondog?

 

[Josh_hawk]

Exactly! Since we've formed the conclusion that 3 premierships is equal to 3 premierships, statistics, etc, then come into play.

A child would agree that 3 = 3
The same child would agree that 13 is more than 9

 

[Josh_hawk]

Oh cool so ruling out Stokesy, Pops and 2 other premiership stars were on the gear. Was it SJ and Moondog?

Must be Lingy and Harley - thats why he doesn't respect their opinions ,,,,,

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

A child would agree that 3 = 3
The same child would agree that 13 is more than 9

Actually, any sane person would agree that 3 equals 3.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Actually, any sane person would agree that 3 equals 3.

Dude i am not disagreeing with you but it seems you are disagreeing that 13 is greater than 9 which is kind of bizarre

But back to the 3 = 3 business so what you are saying, even though we as humans should not compare, is that because 3 = 3 that Geelong's (so called) dynasty is equal to Hawthorn dynasty ??

I don't agree I know ours is greater but glad you got that out

But but what about your pictures

 

[A Cut Above]

Actually, any sane person would agree that 3 equals 3.

No need to speculate on the opinions of others mate, tell us what you think.