Game Day Geelong vs Adelaide, Friday 21st July, 7:50pm @ Adelaide Oval

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Hey, slate him for his performance but as cats_09 pointed out the hair is for a good cause.
Should be lauded for it not criticised.

Even if *weren't* for a good cause, it would still be absolutely ridiculous for people to actually raise the "issue" of Guthrie's hair as if it matters in the slightest. It's cringeworthy beyond belief that it gets brought up at all.
 
Menegola is a VFL player and Selwood is basically a write-off. Guthrie and Motlop are the ones who should have started hitting their peak and producing better, more consistent football, but have seemingly regressed rather than improved. Murdoch is another one. Overall, the side lacks depth of talent, which is a result of them committing so much to trading in a few decent players and a gun and failed trades like pick 21 for Stanley.

that's a pretty hard line, but not without substance.

the thing is, this list will still be good enough to get us a top 4 finish.

the comp is not what it used to be, been saying that for a while now and I'm not the lone ranger in that regard.
 
must be something wrong with Scott Selwood
what's wrong is he was selected. We are trying to get game time into our important players like Parfitt, SS, Stewart, but it doesn't always pay.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The problem with Geelong is not the bottom of 4-6 players as is normally the case, the problem is the players 6-12. Guthrie, Stanley, Motlop, Menegola, Scott Selwood. Can all play on their day, but capable of turning in shockers too offen. These guys seem to let us down the most when we lose.

The problem is players 6-30 they are almost cooked, soft or always injured.
 
Menegola is a VFL player and Selwood is basically a write-off. Guthrie and Motlop are the ones who should have started hitting their peak and producing better, more consistent football, but have seemingly regressed rather than improved. Murdoch is another one. Overall, the side lacks depth of talent, which is a result of them committing so much to trading in a few decent players and a gun and failed trades like pick 21 for Stanley.

Good evening sir.

Seen you bob up more than ever in this game.

Tad bit excited??
 
Just asking how we rate both after 6 games are 5-1 .....

We're 5-1 because pound for pound we've got better players. But I wouldn't put too much thought into anything before this year. So we're 1-1.

But my point was their coach has a bunch of role players sitting clear on top of the ladder. That comes back to the coach and what he's got them doing.

A bit like Ross Lyon, he has coached a large number of spuds into grand finals.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top