No Oppo Supporters General AFL and other clubs discussion thread. **Opposition fans not welcome** Part 2

[Ned Ryerson]

Stevie J had embarrassed himself today

Trying to get that guernsey over his gut would have been the start of the embarrassment.

 

[Davo23]

Greater Western Who?

 

[Arkadia]

Stevie J had embarrassed himself today

Not a good look when you mark the ball inside 50 and your looking to pass the pill because of the distance.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

This is great for Dimma. He can tell a lot of keyboard experts to eat a dick now.

 

[Wandering Hawk]

Nankervis has been ok for Richmond - must have been the $yds 5th best ruckman so they let him go.

I love how their big buddy deal just keeps coming back to haunt them.

 

[Arkadia]

Stevie J had embarrassed himself today

Not a good look when you mark the ball inside 50 and your looking to pass the pill because of the distance.

 

[jenniferHAWKinS]

So? Cotchin was going for the ball, and Shiels was too, an accident happened. Boo Hoo. Move on.

You're not a smart poster so please don't respond until you've taken the bias out of your posting.

Cotchin had a an option to tackle but instead tucked himself up and collected Shiel in the head. Not sure how he gets off with Shiel suffering concussion.

 

[hypertaze]

Cotchin had a an option to tackle but instead tucked himself up and collected Shiel in the head. Not sure how he gets off with Shiel suffering concussion.

Agree. Think if he was going for the ball he would keep his eyes on it. He didn't.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

LOL did they just start playing the Giants song for a quick second?

 

[Xtreme]

This is great for Dimma. He can tell a lot of keyboard experts to eat a dick now.

Hasn't won it yet!!!

Could end up like Rossy Lyon......

 

[madhawksfan]

Nervous waits for Cotchin and Ellis. Hopefully both play and it's a cracking contest.

Crows have been the best side all year and I'll be cheering for them as Tigers supporters are feral and will be unbearable if they win.

 

[Wandering Hawk]

I'm happy for the Richmond faithful - even if they stuff up next week they've had a few games in September to roar about.

Clearly means a tonne for the players.

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

Cotchin had a an option to tackle but instead tucked himself up and collected Shiel in the head. Not sure how he gets off with Shiel suffering concussion.

I just had a look at the vision since so many were raising the suspension possibility. I can't say I would be happy if a Hawk got rubbed out for that in a H and A game let alone the Grand final.

I hope he plays. I will be cheering for the Crows regardless. Best team all year

 

[Arkadia]

Cotchin had a an option to tackle but instead tucked himself up and collected Shiel in the head. Not sure how he gets off with Shiel suffering concussion.

Correct!!!! The question also is what impact did the knock to the head have on Shiels?

Shiels was concussed, did not take any further part in the game.

Cotchin should not play next week if MRP are fair dinkum.......

 

[jenniferHAWKinS]

Any doubt on COTY has been removed today. Well done Dimma for getting a middle of the road team into the big one!

 

[KermitJagger]

I just had a look at the vision since so many were raising the suspension possibility. I can't say I would be happy if a Hawk got rubbed out for that in a H and A game let alone the Grand final.

I hope he plays. I will be cheering for the Crows regardless. Best team all year

The suspension possibility is because it would be his third strike, like Hodge early in the year. Wouldn't have thought Hodge would miss a game for what he did, but it happened.

 

[Franko Armani]

This is great for Dimma. He can tell a lot of keyboard experts to eat a dick now.

Me included

 

[Lotus]

Since 2012 at least 1 of Rioli or Roughead in the Grand Final. Not important trivia .

 

[kimbopen]

Stolen from FB - think I'll just leave this here ...

 

[Arkadia]

Greater Western Who?

For all the number one draft picks there skill level is below par when put under pressure........

 

[eldorado]

Irrelevant him going for the ball. Head contact , .

No, it's not irrelevant.

They will decide if he was 'going for the ball' or if he 'chose to bump'. If they decide he was going for the ball, no charge; if they decide he chose to bump, he's in trouble

If going for the ball was irrelevant, every time someone copped a knock to the head in a marking contest, it would be a report

 

[Spursfan]

Correct!!!! The question also is what impact did the knock to the head have on Shiels?

Shiels was concussed, did not take any further part in the game.

Cotchin should not play next week if MRP are fair dinkum.......

100% agree. I'd have no problem if he did something worth 2 weeks in H&A and they manufactured a reprimand so he could play. But he simply cannot get off scott free

 

[Spursfan]

No, it's not irrelevant.

They will decide if he was 'going for the ball' or if he 'chose to bump'. If they decide he was going for the ball, no charge; if they decide he chose to bump, he's in trouble

If going for the ball was irrelevant, every time someone copped a knock to the head in a marking contest, it would be a report

Well the ball was in Shiel's possession he either had the option to tackle or bump. He tried a bump and unfortunately he made head contact

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Any doubt on COTY has been removed today. Well done Dimma for getting a middle of the road team into the big one!

They’ll get flogged next week if the umpiring is half decent. They just don’t use the ball well enough

 

[Bumpswithagrin]

Now Dimma really DOES have a smile on his face