Rumour GFC 2017 Player Trading, Drafting, FA, Rumours, and Wish lists.

Who would you rather at the Cats?


  • Total voters
    253
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am fairly confident Abbott is ready to go and at 26 he should be.

I agree getting a really good ruck to sit behind smith is no go but getting an ok cheap depth one is doable i think.

I think having a real young number 1 on your list ..say a 3-4 year project that can chip in your stuck is ideal. Darcy at Freo shows that young guys can play if they have to..... but versatile tall guy who can chip is probably a better way to go. Buzza showed that type can get games before legit ruckmen. There was a kid playing for VicC in the champs who had great leap ..cant remember his name
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm firmly in the keep Stanley camp unless we get a competent proven ruckman at some other point in the trade period, you can't run with Smith,Blicavs and Abbott when Smith already has one ACL in his injury history.
 
Whatever club he nominates, they will have the leverage.
Should it be us, and that is unclear currently, then it will be reasonable ( as we always tend to be) but the dreams of getting a top 10 pick are exactly that... dreams.

GO Catters

Hey Wellsy, long time no see!




Go Dogs
 
Good chance that the WCE will be looking to bolster midfield stocks given retirements, who knows, maybe they were happy with Vardy and may look at some of our - Motlop, GHS, Murdoch, Lang...

Just speculating here...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Menzel and Stanley can gtfo and should do.

Wish we hadnt resigned kolo so we could have traded him.

Lang murdoch and ghs are trade for whatever we can get.

Parfitt and Cockatoo the future.

Motlop will probably go.

We need to get better forward line pressure and more run and carry.

Smith must be an in and we need a few more like that.
 
Letting Motlop go is a disgraceful decision if we do indeed allow it to happen.

And no, this isn't a kneejerk response to his impressive finals series either, I've been consistent on this all year. We need more of Motlop's quality, not less.

Its not really our call he is a free agent so he can do what he wants.
 
I'm firmly in the keep Stanley camp unless we get a competent proven ruckman at some other point in the trade period, you can't run with Smith,Blicavs and Abbott when Smith already has one ACL in his injury history.
Still think that?
 
Menzel and Stanley can gtfo and should do.

Wish we hadnt resigned kolo so we could have traded him.

Lang murdoch and ghs are trade for whatever we can get.

Parfitt and Cockatoo the future.

Motlop will probably go.

We need to get better forward line pressure and more run and carry.

Smith must be an in and we need a few more like that.
Add to the Wishlist, players who can kick the ball well.
We really need to improve our ball use, so many times we get killed by sides on the back of simple turnovers
 
Menzel and Stanley can gtfo and should do.

Wish we hadnt resigned kolo so we could have traded him.

Lang murdoch and ghs are trade for whatever we can get.

Parfitt and Cockatoo the future.

Motlop will probably go.

We need to get better forward line pressure and more run and carry.

Smith must be an in and we need a few more like that.
Agree with first line.
Kolo is getting played out of position on the wing
Lang i would keep he needs games and will be ok.
Murdoch did have a good patch during the year but can he handle the heat?
Motlop we need to stay especially for the run and carry.
We need speed its been a constant for a while.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top