Help me with my top 20 Players of All time list

[masai]

It would seem Adam Goodes was a figment of imagination. Must not have played AFL. It was all make believe. He was sent from a higher being just to antagonise the whordes.

What position would you list him in ?.

Rucks - aint in the top 5 +.

Midfielders - aint in the top 5 +.

Forward Flankers - aint in the top 5 +.

Yep, Adam was a darn good player, but I wouldn't fit him in the Top 20, using the above criteria.

Personally from what I saw live, TI ( S. Michael ) was far superior to Adam in the Ruck / Midfield / Forward role.

 

[footyfan1978]

A few guys that should be in contention. Geoff Southby and Glen Jakovic as defenders. Cox in ruck group, perhaps replacing Nichols. Not sure I’d have Keith Greig or Nathan Buckley in the squad, as good as they were. Otherwise, good work OP

Yeah, it is not bad. I'd not have Buckely in there and dubious about Doug Wade even though before my time. I sense Bob Pratt should be in there.
Rom Barassi too.

Keith Greig. I torn on but I think Robert Flower is absolute must. David Dench and Southby maybe worthy but guess Regan and Silvagni probably trump them. just. I'd have Chris Judd and Wayne Johnston over Greiig and Buckley. Also have Maurice Rioli before Buckley.
Bartlett has to be in there as a forward even though hated the little prick

 

[Rusty Brookes]

What position would you list him in ?.

Rucks - aint in the top 5 +.

Midfielders - aint in the top 5 +.

Forward Flankers - aint in the top 5 +.

Yep, Adam was a darn good player, but I wouldn't fit him in the Top 20, using the above criteria.

Personally from what I saw live, TI ( S. Michael ) was far superior to Adam in the Ruck / Midfield / Forward role.

That's the problem with finding a spot for Goodes. If utility was a position he'd be a lock.

 

[footyfan1978]

oh, Kenny Hunter is a must too. Only second to Bruce Doull as a general defender. Could swap forward too.

 

[nineteen eighty]

interesting to see peoples thoughts on how they would rank voss hird buckley. those three were the 3 premier mids of their decade and often are listed one after the other in these types of lists.

voss hird buckley and robert harvey how would you rank them
Id lean toward Harvey, Voss, Buckley, Hird personally

Harvey for mine has them covered. Voss followed by Buckley as you have them. Hird is different as he could be a match winner across the park. He would almost be first picked amongst this lot due to his ability to play almost any position...and be a gun in all.

As a pure mid, Harvey for mine. Was a joy to watch https://www.afl.com.au/news/197068/versus-williams-v-harvey

 

[HollyValentine]

i'd say Buddy Franklin should be in there