Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[Beau_Waters for PM]

kozi or franklin?

I'm not the biggest Franklin fan, but I think he is a better prospect that Kosi this season.

 

[TigerGlory]

Who would be the third best forward rookie behind Rioli and Tippet?

Ive come to the realisation that i should start a rookie in my forwardline.

I can purchase Stuart Dew though, if people think thats a better option.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

so do you reckon hes worth it then, if not who u suggest

I had him in my initial squad but have since squeezed him out.
I think he is worth the risk. Will score well I think probably average somewhere around 70-75 points. Depending on injuries and such I'd expect him to spend most of his tome across half forward and perhaps half back at times.


Worth the risk at his price however don't expect miracles.

 

[eugene_tomas]

jetta mayb tigerglory

c demsey or x ellis??

 

[Sizza]

Who would be the third best forward rookie behind Rioli and Tippet?

Ive come to the realisation that i should start a rookie in my forwardline.

I can purchase Stuart Dew though, if people think thats a better option.

id go either L.hansen or ryan gamble

 

[Sizza]

jetta mayb tigerglory

c demsey or x ellis??

ellis

 

[Ricketts]

I don't agree with your reasoning. A player can be in a dud team and still be a fantasy superstar. BJ has been one of the greatest fantasy players of the last decade, and during that time the Bulldogs haven't set the world on fire.
As for you saying "BJ is another year older" - that's exactly what people were saying of BJ and Milburn this time last season, and they ended up being in the top few scorers in their positions.

That's cool. I just disagree.

 

[Sizza]

does anyone think its risky to have both mattner and kennelly in the backline

 

[sdsdsdsd]

List A
Birchall
Waters

B
Ellis
Nicoski

Pick one from A and one from B thnx

 

[TheVelourFog]

Now todays problem concerns Chris Judd and Gary Ablett.

Looking back at 2006 Judd had two games where he scored 200+ and last year he started off really well and then fell away due to injury while Ablett was awesome all year. My question is would Judd be better value for an entire year than Ablett.

My current midfield is Dal Santo, Ablett, Stanton, Griffen, Stevens and Houli

I'm also contemplating Gibbs over Griffen but I don't want too many Carlton players.

Any thoughts are appreciated.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Now todays problem concerns Chris Judd and Gary Ablett.

Looking back at 2006 Judd had two games where he scored 200+ and last year he started off really well and then fell away due to injury while Ablett was awesome all year. My question is would Judd be better value for an entire year than Ablett.

My current midfield is Dal Santo, Ablett, Stanton, Griffen, Stevens and Houli

I'm also contemplating Gibbs over Griffen but I don't want too many Carlton players.

Any thoughts are appreciated.

possibly

 

[Blackhawk03]

Pick two of the following:
Johnstone
N. Jones
Reilly
Tambling
Nash

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Pick two of the following:
Johnstone
N. Jones
Reilly
Tambling
Nash

Johnstone
Jones

List A
Birchall
Waters

B
Ellis
Nicoski

Pick one from A and one from B thnx

 

[eugene_tomas]

i wld choose birchall and nicoski

otherwise A

 

[sdsdsdsd]

kk thanks, who are the best 3 out of this lot

J Macnamara
R Palmer
T Tuck
C Bird
C Morton

 

[Hard Ball Get]

kk thanks, who are the best 3 out of this lot

J Macnamara
R Palmer
T Tuck
C Bird
C Morton

Its all opinion at this stage.
No one really knows.

The best advice anyone can give is... CHOSE YOUR OWN TEAM

 

[treefingers]

Can I pm someone my team for advide? Im better at DT don't know a lot about SuperCoach, I would like an opinion on my team.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Can I pm someone my team for advide? Im better at DT don't know a lot about SuperCoach, I would like an opinion on my team.

go ahead

 

[eugene_tomas]

kk thanks, who are the best 3 out of this lot

J Macnamara
R Palmer
T Tuck
C Bird
C Morton

palmer the only safe one if u wana call it that

 

[sacka]

List A
Birchall
Waters

B
Ellis
Nicoski

Pick one from A and one from B thnx

A-either one about the same in my book
B-nicoski

 

[JDizzle]

JAMES KELLY or KANE JOHNSON?

Both look to step it up!

 

[sdsdsdsd]

palmer the only safe one if u wana call it that

Yeh fair enugh, Im guessing all should get a go round 1 but after that

Also most people are saying nicoski over ellis, any reasons, of wat ive seen ellis should get a consistent go in the hawks this year?

 

[JDizzle]

Akermanis or Hall?

 

[Spartan]

Akermanis or Hall?

Smack-her-manis will get you consistent scores but I don't think he will crack the hundred too often. He's safe.

BBB if he gets going will give you nice big scores with the rare pathetic score. Bit of a roller coaster.

Your call. I'd go BBB but Aker is very tempting.

Tell you what get both.

 

[Robert Khouri]

Can someone refresh the formula to work out players break even ive forgot it.