Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[eugene_tomas]

Yeh fair enugh, Im guessing all should get a go round 1 but after that

Also most people are saying nicoski over ellis, any reasons, of wat ive seen ellis should get a consistent go in the hawks this year?

nicoski has been there just got som injuries.. x ellis is stil a slight frame only averages 40-50 and it remained the dame in pre season.. i dnt think he can improve that. nicoski i for sure think so

 

[Mickeybee]

Hey guys, i'm a supercoach virgin, so any help on my team would be very much appreciated..


1. Waters (DEF) 02. Cornes (DEF) 03. Ryder (DEF) 04. Birchall (DEF) 05. Shaw (DEF) 06. Hansen (DEF) 07. Bradshaw (DEF) 08. Proud (DEF) 09. Nicoski (DEF) 010. Dal Santo (MID) 011. Johnstone (MID) 012. Cornes (MID) 013. Bird (MID) 014. Houli (MID) 015. Embley (MID) 016. Stevens (MID) 017. Palmer (MID) (Emerg) 018. Kreuzer (RUC) 019. Simmonds (RUC) 020. Cox (RUC) 021. Hampson (RUC) (Emerg) 022. Jetta (FWD) (Emerg) 023. Rioli (FWD) 024. Fevola (FWD) 025. Tippett (FWD) 026. Pavlich (FWD) 027. Porplyzia (FWD) 028. Hall (FWD) 029. Brown (FWD) 030. Thompson (FWD) 0

Thanks very much in advance..

 

[sdsdsdsd]

worth using my last 10k to trade kornes to ablett?

 

[dazy]

hey guys should i get jonno brown or brett deledio with 126k left

 

[NewmanFoley08]

Backs - P.Burgoyne H.Shaw A.Mcloed C.Newman G.Birchall N.L-Murrey L. Hanson (Emer) A.Proud D.Phieffer

Centres - A.Goodes L.Hayes D.Cross N.Stevens J.Selwood B.Houli (emer) C.Bird R.Palmer

Rucks - T.Simmonds M.Leunberger (emer) M.Meeson Hampson

Forwards - J.Brown S.Johnson N.Brown B.Hall A.Didak J.Porplyzia L.Jetta (emer) K.Tippet C.Rioli

Please give me some feedback not totally convinced! Your thoughts would be appreciated thanks

 

[dazy]

worth using my last 10k to trade kornes to ablett?

nope there both good

 

[dazy]

Backs - P.Burgoyne H.Shaw A.Mcloed C.Newman G.Birchall N.L-Murrey L. Hanson (Emer) A.Proud D.Phieffer

Centres - A.Goodes L.Hayes D.Cross N.Stevens J.Selwood B.Houli (emer) C.Bird R.Palmer

Rucks - T.Simmonds M.Leunberger (emer) M.Meeson Hampson

Forwards - J.Brown S.Johnson N.Brown B.Hall A.Didak J.Porplyzia L.Jetta (emer) K.Tippet C.Rioli

Please give me some feedback not totally convinced! Your thoughts would be appreciated thanks

wow i think that is a really strong team i am suprised they all fit in the salary cap well done m8

 

[dazy]

Backs - P.Burgoyne H.Shaw A.Mcloed C.Newman G.Birchall N.L-Murrey L. Hanson (Emer) A.Proud D.Phieffer

Centres - A.Goodes L.Hayes D.Cross N.Stevens J.Selwood B.Houli (emer) C.Bird R.Palmer

Rucks - T.Simmonds M.Leunberger (emer) M.Meeson Hampson

Forwards - J.Brown S.Johnson N.Brown B.Hall A.Didak J.Porplyzia L.Jetta (emer) K.Tippet C.Rioli

Please give me some feedback not totally convinced! Your thoughts would be appreciated thanks

2 things sub n brown for brett deledio and there is better value than joel selwood like embly, vanberlo,pearce, jones, murphy

 

[NewmanFoley08]

Backs - P.Burgoyne H.Shaw A.Mcloed C.Newman G.Birchall N.L-Murrey L. Hanson (Emer) A.Proud D.Phieffer

Centres - A.Goodes L.Hayes D.Cross N.Stevens J.Selwood B.Houli (emer) C.Bird R.Palmer

Rucks - T.Simmonds M.Leunberger (emer) M.Meeson Hampson

Forwards - J.Brown S.Johnson N.Brown B.Hall A.Didak J.Porplyzia L.Jetta (emer) K.Tippet C.Rioli

Please give me some feedback not totally convinced! Your thoughts would be appreciated thanks

plus still have 143,900 left ova

 

[Windas_Magic]

I have the choice between Mattner, Lovett-Murray, Mcmahon and Mackie. I'm slightly leaning towards Mackie but im interested too see what you think

 

[NewmanFoley08]

2 things sub n brown for brett deledio and there is better value than joel selwood like embly, vanberlo,pearce, jones, murphy

thx 4 the advice Nathan Brown Deledio and Franklin is a toughie im a fan of consistancy u really think Deledio will explode this year I'm a tiger supporter and i jus really dont know and Nathan Brown is classy u think sliding??

 

[pieman123]

which one out of -
embley, m murphy,pearce, van berlo, johnstone should i get?

 

[hussey1337]

Backs: J.Bowden, L.Gilbee, C.Cornes, H.Shaw, G.Johncock, X.Ellis
Interchange - Pfeiffer,Grimes

Midfield: J.Bartel, A.Simpson, C.Judd, N.Stevens, C Morton, T Cotchin
Interchange: R.Palmer, C.Bird

Rucks: D.Cox, H.Mcintosh.
Interchange: M.Kreuzer, S.Hampson

Forwards: J. Brown, B.Deledio, S.Lucas, K.Tippett, N.Thompson, J Porplyzia, L.Jetta
Interchange: C.Riolo, R.Tarrant


Not sure about Simpson, but had him in DT last year and had <100 average. And dont know if i should take the risk on judd/bartel.
Any suggestions?

 

[sammy_18]

Backs: Shaw, S.Fisher, Mcphee, Birchall, King, Symes, Nicoski EMG: Hansen, Proud

Midfielders: Swan, Stanton, Priddis, Embley, Reilly, Stevens EMG: Palmer, Valenti

Rucks: McIntosh, Simmonds EMG: Hampson, Carteledge

Fowards: J.Brown, B.Johnson, Richardson, Hall, Didak, Porplyzia, Tippet
EMG: Tarrant, Rioli

Thoughts on my team. suggestions will be appreciated. Thanks!

 

[lamaros]

Fowards: J.Brown, B.Johnson, Richardson, Hall, Didak, Porplyzia, Tippet
EMG: Tarrant, Rioli

I spotted the odd one out. What do I win?

 

[Burly FF]

Backs: Shaw, S.Fisher, Mcphee, Birchall, King, Symes, Nicoski EMG: Hansen, Proud

Midfielders: Swan, Stanton, Priddis, Embley, Reilly, Stevens EMG: Palmer, Valenti

Rucks: McIntosh, Simmonds EMG: Hampson, Carteledge

Fowards: J.Brown, B.Johnson, Richardson, Hall, Didak, Porplyzia, Tippet
EMG: Tarrant, Rioli

Thoughts on my team. suggestions will be appreciated. Thanks!

Good looking team mate - be aware re S Fisher that when Hudghton/ Maguire are out he often is asked to play more of a lock down role.

 

[Tomberlang]

Backs: Shaw, S.Fisher, Mcphee, Birchall, King, Symes, Nicoski EMG: Hansen, Proud

Midfielders: Swan, Stanton, Priddis, Embley, Reilly, Stevens EMG: Palmer, Valenti

Rucks: McIntosh, Simmonds EMG: Hampson, Carteledge

Fowards: J.Brown, B.Johnson, Richardson, Hall, Didak, Porplyzia, Tippet
EMG: Tarrant, Rioli

Thoughts on my team. suggestions will be appreciated. Thanks!

An ok side, if u had the cash i think you should upgrade brown to pav.I dont think tarrant will get a gig round 1, better options like gamble. I think it is a pretty solid side anyway.

 

[Sizza]

hey i was just wondering if you feel that its too risky to have both mattner and kennelly in the backline

 

[Sizza]

thoughts on my team guys
backs:
shaw, johncok, m.johnson, birchall, lovett-murray, mattner, nicoski (proud, urquhart)

midfield
k.cornes, swan, salopek, jones, griffen, stevens (bird, ebert)

ruckmen
fraser, simmonds (hampson, graham)

forwards
brown, johnson, lucas, hall, r.murphy, porplyzia, hansen (rioli, tippett)

 

[dazy]

hey guys who shou i get out of j brown and brett deledio if i get deledio i will get a spare 126k to upgrade another player but i cant find any one to upgrade

 

[Sizza]

who are you looking to upgrade????

 

[Harmonic_9]

hey guys who shou i get out of j brown and brett deledio if i get deledio i will get a spare 126k to upgrade another player but i cant find any one to upgrade

I would definately go with deledio+cash. Deledio is in for a big one
Does anyone know a site where i can see the lineups for round 1 after they have been anounced wednesday night??
Thanks

 

[Sizza]

I would definately go with deledio+cash. Deledio is in for a big one
Does anyone know a site where i can see the lineups for round 1 after they have been anounced wednesday night??
Thanks

the afl website usually has lineups

 

[sdsdsdsd]

I would definately go with deledio+cash. Deledio is in for a big one
Does anyone know a site where i can see the lineups for round 1 after they have been anounced wednesday night??
Thanks

Deledio is a gun but i dont see him getting much of the ball this year, i would go with brown

 

[Sizza]

hey guys who shou i get out of j brown and brett deledio if i get deledio i will get a spare 126k to upgrade another player but i cant find any one to upgrade

i dunno who you wanna upgrade but i reckon ya better off gettin lucas and still having some spare cash