If Carlton took Gibbs to the trade table...

[RoyalBlue]

...they'd want pick 1 right?

How the **** are they not handing pick 1 over for Judd?

WCE are getting screwed here if they dont get pick 1.

I think the Eagles should have made it clear they wanted pick 1 in return for saying they wouldn't seek a trade with any other club.

 

[retroparty]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

 

[Team Mo']

...they'd want pick 1 right?

How the **** are they not handing pick 1 over for Judd?

WCE are getting screwed here if they dont get pick 1.

I think the Eagles should have made it clear they wanted pick 1 in return for saying they wouldn't seek a trade with any other club.

who cares..is gibbs up for trade no..is judd ......yes .......can we get him for less then 1..yes, so why would we give them pick one

 

[tin can sam]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

Oky Doke, makes sense.

 

[smiddaz123]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

Oh my god.

 

[RoyalBlue]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

Makes complete sense.

 

[Team Mo']

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

oh yeh thats makes perfect sense... why would you want a worse pick..if you had pick 1 you can take anyone you want..its just luck that pick 3 or 4 sometimes are better its not a reoccuring thing

 

[smithos]

I can't believe we're not giving up 1,3, Murphy and Gibbs. How dare we seek a deal that's in the best interest of our club!

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

If Carlton took Gibbs to the trade table ... they'd be an even bigger joke.

 

[Dylan12]

...they'd want pick 1 right?

How the **** are they not handing pick 1 over for Judd?

WCE are getting screwed here if they dont get pick 1.

I think the Eagles should have made it clear they wanted pick 1 in return for saying they wouldn't seek a trade with any other club.

Why are the Eagles getting screwed? Judd went to the Eagles for Pick 3, so really Carlton are giving up more by throwing in whatever else, they simply are giving the Eagles what they paid for him in the first place. Don't understand your point mate.

 

[goodie23]

The polite answer? Because they're cheapskates trying to stiff the Eagles. That's pretty much what trade week's about these days

 

[captain amazo]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

 

[RoyalBlue]

Why are the Eagles getting screwed? Judd went to the Eagles for Pick 3, so really Carlton are giving up more by throwing in whatever else, they simply are giving the Eagles what they paid for him in the first place. Don't understand your point mate.

Yeah because by that logic Judd is worth Lachlan Hansen.

Where do we sign?

 

[TheWiseOne]

Why are the Eagles getting screwed? Judd went to the Eagles for Pick 3, so really Carlton are giving up more by throwing in whatever else, they simply are giving the Eagles what they paid for him in the first place. Don't understand your point mate.

I will give you Hawthorns pick 12 for J Brown.? Brown was a number 30 pick.... Thats fair right

 

[retroparty]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

OK I take back what I said that dosent make too much sense!

 

[Naish]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

Example: Pendlebury taken at pick 5, Murphy at pick 1.
Pendlebury finishes runner up in the B&F at a top 4 club and tears opposition midfields apart.
Point made.

 

[Jono B]

Example: Pendlebury taken at pick 5, Murphy at pick 1.
Pendlebury finishes runner up in the B&F at a top 4 club and tears opposition midfields apart.
Point made.

Murphy>Pendlebury

 

[Dylan12]

[deleted]

Would love to know what you reckon he is worth...how many first rounders and players...you lost him, deal with it, he won't be the last, just like the next Aka, Mal to leave. Either way you will get a gun player with pick 3 or whatever plus all your extras...seriously don't know what your complaining about...we lost Mal for nothing.

Look at the bright side...we lost Headland when he was at his best, taken with pick 1, 4 years later we lose him for pick 3, draft Brennan and all up it has worked out. Be a bit more opened minded and don't think by not getting pick 1 you have been screwed. Can't believe how niave alot of you BF posters are

 

[Sublime]

I rather pick 3 or 4.

Often the 1st pick is not as good as picks 3 or 4.

Well just get pick 1, then select the 3rd or 4th ranked player on your list. Simple.

 

[blue gunslinger]

The polite answer? Because they're cheapskates trying to stiff the Eagles. That's pretty much what trade week's about these days

Yeah
sorry
I will call Swann Icke and Pratt now.We insulted the Eagles and the AFL.Tell you what keep Judd and as a token of how sorry we are have pick 1 , 3 , 20 Kennedy and Fevola as well.
Cheapskates to get the best deal for Carlton.
At least we have something to offer.
What have the Saints got: players, draft picks, a stable and rich board, state of the art facilities?
Cheapskates to stiff the Eagles.Judd stiffed them when he decided to leave
I don't think we made Judd leave
Long days and happy nights

 

[Dylan12]

Yeah
sorry
I will call Swann Icke and Pratt now.We insulted the Eagles and the AFL.Tell you what keep Judd and as a token of how sorry we are have pick 1 , 3 , 20 Kennedy and Fevola as well.
Cheapskates to get the best deal for Carlton.
At least we have something to offer.
What have the Saints got: players, draft picks, a stable and rich board, state of the art facilities?
Cheapskates to stiff the Eagles.Judd stiffed them when he decided to leave
I don't think we made Judd leave
Long days and happy nights

About time...someone with logic...it is staggering people's ignorance regarding trading...every clubs win some, lose some...looks like Hooper will go to Tigers in PSD with us getting nothing...big deal, good player...but i support the club, not the player...if a Judd wants to go, stuff him - he obviously doesn't rate your club too highly, just like you shouldnt rate him anymore, get behind your new players...so quit whingeing, you know it is part of footy, don't get emotionally attached to the player, keep it for the club...is it that obvious!!!

 

[BlueDW]

Oky Doke, makes sense.

lol, couldnt have said it any better myself!!!

 

[HBF]

...they'd want pick 1 right?

How the **** are they not handing pick 1 over for Judd?

WCE are getting screwed here if they dont get pick 1.

I think the Eagles should have made it clear they wanted pick 1 in return for saying they wouldn't seek a trade with any other club.

Therein lies the problem mate. Judd chose Carlton ONLY, which meant West Coast had to deal with them. As Judd is still contracted to West Coast, he has to agree on any trade, and as he has only chosen Carlton to go to, West Coast don't have much choice here.

 

[d-mac3276]

...they'd want pick 1 right?

How the **** are they not handing pick 1 over for Judd?

WCE are getting screwed here if they dont get pick 1.

I think the Eagles should have made it clear they wanted pick 1 in return for saying they wouldn't seek a trade with any other club.

Realistically they should b getting picks 1 and 3 but thats Carlton for ya take take take but never give thats why everybody hates their ****ing guts

 

[BBFFC]

Carlton are doing nothing wrong, WCE are getting as good as they are going to get,

Had WCE said guess what we dont want Judd anymore and are offering him up, no doubt they would of got the no. 1 pick. But thats not the way it is and as such the Blues would be silly to not hold out.


Get over it, every team has to live with it.