Is Puopolo underrated?

[Upgrayedd]

Mat Kluezek kicked 5 in his first game for Adelaide and the ultimate 1997 GF S Ellen 5 goals puts Puopolo in perspective

Pop has played more games then both of them, kicked more goals then both of them, 3 of the 5 years Pop has kicked more goals in a season then either have in their short careers and has kicked 5 goals in a game before. What a terrible comparison. He's also gotten enough out of himself to even if people outside the club don't rate him as at least an average AFL player, Well he's done enough to break into a team which has won 3 premierships, So he does something right. he's not chucking on a wig stealing rioli's jumper and hoping Clarkson picks the team by pointing guys out from a pack thursday morning

Mate, what are you on about? I understand if your bitter, but not acknowledging that Puopolo is a solid AFL player is just...well. This isnt bae 13.

 

[Arc1]

Yeah but you barrack for Geelong , what else would you say, Like me and Selwood, I hate him , but he's a champ, almost not worth commenting on?

I think the correct summary was "Turnip posts same stupid opinion twice."

 

[Pessimistic]

High mark, diving mark, foot race and gather, body work and soccer goal

Along with pass offs, run downs and one percenters.

You could produce a 'how to afl' course on his one night alone.

He didnt hitout, but somewhere in the archives hes got a hit out or two

 

[mxett]

his compulsive ducking isnt under rated, it's well known. Can't stand the little campaigner

 

[Pessimistic]

his compulsive ducking isnt under rated, it's well known. Can't stand the little campaigner

It happens, but hes way down the list of campaigners. Didnt clarko once say if this becomes widespread in rthe afl, well have to get some skills?

 

[randyzany]

I'll reserve my judgement once hodge, mitchell, roughead and co retire. I really wanna see what he serves up then.

 

[marty36]

So far I rate him as a three time AFL premiership player.

Which means I rate him higher than most clubs.

So I think his rating is about right.

Must be better than Peter Daicos then, hey?

 

[mxett]

It happens, but hes way down the list of campaigners. Didnt clarko once say if this becomes widespread in rthe afl, well have to get some skills?

he's a Linday Thomas equivalent or maybe even worse. A horrible little cheat

 

[Pessimistic]

he's a Linday Thomas equivalent or maybe even worse. A horrible little cheat

So what was a cheat on friday.

 

[Pessimistic]

I'll reserve my judgement once hodge, mitchell, roughead and co retire. I really wanna see what he serves up then.

He may retire first, we have plenty more puopolos

 

[mxett]

So what was a cheat on friday.

Surprisingly he only dived a few times last night. The push in the back dive in the last few minutes was typical. No contact on his back but he dived forward like he was shot

 

[Randy Campbell]

Must be better than Peter Daicos then, hey?

If we are ranking them on AFL premierships won, yes.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I'll reserve my judgement once hodge, mitchell, roughead and co retire. I really wanna see what he serves up then.

Yes, those 17 contested possessions out of 23 in total....he wouldn't have done without Hodge and Mitchell telling him to from up the field...

Really?

 

[marty36]

If we are ranking them on AFL premierships won, yes.

Yes and Aaron Keating worst player ever to pull on an AFL guernsey has more premierships than Jimmy Stynes!

 

[Randy Campbell]

Yes and Aaron Keating worst player ever to pull on an AFL guernsey has more premierships than Jimmy Stynes!

Yes he does, he also has more AFL premierships then the Melbourne football club.

 

[romeohwho]

So what was a cheat on friday.

Don't think I have seen Puopolo duck at all this season, which is a welcome change from his previous antics. Good on him if he is getting it out of his game.
Possibly has handballed the ducking mantle to Sicily.

 

[marty36]

Yes he does, he also has more AFL premierships then the Melbourne football club.

Goes to show premierships as an individual honour mean jack, give me a Jimmy Stynes hobbling on one leg over a fully fit Aaron Keating everyday of the week!

 

[Randy Campbell]

Goes to show premierships as an individual honour mean jack, give me a Jimmy Stynes hobbling on one leg over a fully fit Aaron Keating everyday of the week!

It's a team game, individual honor means jack.

 

[STFU Donnie]

All right I have to ask, but I feel I'm missing something obvious.

Who is the baldy dude that everyone is putting in their profile pic?

 

[Upgrayedd]

I'll reserve my judgement once hodge, mitchell, roughead and co retire. I really wanna see what he serves up then.

Hes 29 and a bloke who relies on speed and strength rather then skill. I dont think he'll be around for another 4/5 years

 

[marty36]

It's a team game, individual honor means jack.

True, but individual awards like brownlows and Coleman's show the ability if the individual a premiership medallion doesn't as is proven in the case of Aaron Keating

 

[marty36]

All right I have to ask, but I feel I'm missing something obvious.

Who is the baldy dude that everyone is putting in their profile pic?

The fella, that won you the game!

 

[Randy Campbell]

True, but individual awards like brownlows and Coleman's show the ability if the individual a premiership medallion doesn't as is proven in the case of Aaron Keating

It also shows winning premierships is about more than individual ability.

 

[beta_condition]

Harry Taylor by a mile.

Mitchell and Priddis?

 

[marty36]

It also shows winning premierships is about more than individual ability.

Not always take out the norm smith medalists from those close GF s and would that team have won?