List Mgmt. Ivan Soldo requests trade

[Dazalinko1988]

Nah go f*#k a goat soldo ya sour gremlin ya can't handle being second to sweet so ya have a cry and run home catchya c*nt !

 

[cmpower]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

 

[Schulzenfest]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

How the **** is the out of contract 25 year old with single figure career games and goals worth pick 27?

 

[cmpower]

How the **** is the out of contract 25 year old with single figure career games and goals worth pick 27?

I think Richard’s is better than ANB who went for Pick 28

 

[davo999]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

Collingwood getting too much for Richard’s . We should probably ask similar to what we paid for Soldo

 

[VineValerian]

How the **** is the out of contract 25 year old with single figure career games and goals worth pick 27?

I think it was a typo.
He meant 47.

 

[VineValerian]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

Port certainly is.

 

[all seeing eye]

Port soldo +57
Sts 27

 

[philthy05]

I think Richard’s is better than ANB who went for Pick 28

Based on what?

Anb, while I think an average player has a body of work far bigger and arguably better exposed form , and he’s contracted.

Joe may surpass anb in time, but that isn’t now, and it’s not a given.

 

[Schulzenfest]

I think Richard’s is better than ANB who went for Pick 28

Okay let's recap:

ANB - 176 games, 116 goals, best 22, premiership player, just finished 3rd in Melbourne's B&F, contracted
Richards - 9 games, 6 goals, not best 22, finished so low in Collingwood's B&F that he doesn't show up on their published results, uncontracted

You do realise trade value isn't determined by subjective determinations about who is 'better', right?