Traded Jack Lukosius - Joins Port Adelaide as part of a 3-way trade with Collingwood and Gold Coast

[Kane McGoodwin]

People are under estimating what the trade value for Lukosius will be
When trade time comes both Port & Crows will be looking to get him into their clubs

The value of the trade will still be a pick inside 15 imo

Hopefully Lukosius wants to play for Richmond if they are thinking of playing crazy overs like you.

 

[THE_GUN]

Hopefully Lukosius wants to play for Richmond if they are thinking of playing crazy overs like you.

I would happily take him at Richmond for pick #15

You guys are really talking him down with expectation of a bargain but he is a quality player
Worl has gone mad when Tom Barrass 2 x 1st rounder at 29 but Luko is worth cents in a dollar

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I would happily take him at Richmond for pick #15

You guys are really talking him down with expectation of a bargain but he is a quality player
Worl has gone mad when Tom Barrass 2 x 1st rounder at 29 but Luko is worth cents in a dollar

Imo, you are still thinking he is pick #2 quality.

If he went back into the draft, no way would a club draft him for a 1st rounder.

Further, he is currently overpaid at $950k pa which drops any trade value... or are you claiming he worth being one of the highest paid players? Would make him AFC''s highest paid. More than Rankine & Dawson, which is ridiculous.

 

[Rob R]

I would happily take him at Richmond for pick #15

You guys are really talking him down with expectation of a bargain but he is a quality player
Worl has gone mad when Tom Barrass 2 x 1st rounder at 29 but Luko is worth cents in a dollar

only deluded WC supporters think Barrass is worth that much. Late first is fair.

On SM-A136B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[THE_GUN]

Imo, you are still thinking he is pick #2 quality.

If he went back into the draft, no way would a club draft him for a 1st rounder.

Further, he is currently overpaid at $950k pa which drops any trade value... or are you claiming he worth being one of the highest paid players? Would make him AFC''s highest paid. More than Rankine & Dawson, which is ridiculous.

You are really just going by his games this year
there is a reason he went #2 and he has played alot of good games at a crap team and until this year would have had every club jumping at him.

The contract is not really an issue if he moves and players level them out
Im sure list managers wont be writing him off and draft picks are over rated

pick #15 + is still a massive risk to not play 50 games as you would know with recent 1st rounders that have been flops at the crows

#15 v Luko ill take luko

 

[THE_GUN]

only deluded WC supporters think Barrass is worth that much. Late first is fair.

On SM-A136B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Even that Luko v Barrass im taking Luko every day

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

You are really just going by his games this year
there is a reason he went #2 and he has played alot of good games at a crap team and until this year would have had every club jumping at him.

The contract is not really an issue if he moves and players level them out
Im sure list managers wont be writing him off and draft picks are over rated

pick #15 + is still a massive risk to not play 50 games as you would know with recent 1st rounders that have been flops at the crows

#15 v Luko ill take luko

You are very much in the minority... & I doubt any club considering to trade him in would be in agreement with you.

Time will tell though as pretty sure he will be at a different club next season as not wanted by Hardwick.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Even that Luko v Barrass im taking Luko every day

Lol, what?

Barrass is a proven gun.

No way would anyone sane take Lukosius over Barrass.

 

[THE_GUN]

Lol, what?

Barrass is a proven gun.

No way would anyone sane take Lukosius over Barrass.

29 year old proven gun that could be finished in 2-3 years

Luko has 8 years ahead of him
Luko was averaging 1.8 goals a game last year as a foward in a crap team and the same as Fogarty this year
Would love to know what you would want in a trade for DF who is 12 months older

Anyway its opinions

 

[Pistol Night]

Even that Luko v Barrass im taking Luko every day

Ya ****n what now?

 

[1970crow]

You are really just going by his games this year
there is a reason he went #2 and he has played alot of good games at a crap team and until this year would have had every club jumping at him.

The contract is not really an issue if he moves and players level them out
Im sure list managers wont be writing him off and draft picks are over rated

pick #15 + is still a massive risk to not play 50 games as you would know with recent 1st rounders that have been flops at the crows

#15 v Luko ill take luko

You have to consider what's given up to get 15 though. Big difference between using a couple of picks in the 20s to trade up and splitting 4 to trade down. I'm not sure either club has the appetite or ability to get a pick around that spot. We've signed up everyone with trade value and are too weak a club to nudge contracted players. Not sure Port can work their way there, although future first, if they're allowed to trade it, would be around the mark.

 

[THE_GUN]

You have to consider what's given up to get 15 though. Big difference between using a couple of picks in the 20s to trade up and splitting 4 to trade down. I'm not sure either club has the appetite or ability to get a pick around that spot. We've signed up everyone with trade value and are too weak a club to nudge contracted players. Not sure Port can work their way there, although future first, if they're allowed to trade it, would be around the mark.

Thats a different story altogether
Im just looking at what i would be happy to trade for him as in an outright pick number
for example if Geelong have pick #15-#17 and traded it for Luko we would be saying 'Geelong have done it again"

individual teams having to sacrifice players or multiple picks would have to be another discussion

 

[PeterSalt]

Thats a different story altogether
Im just looking at what i would be happy to trade for him as in an outright pick number
for example if Geelong have pick #15-#17 and traded it for Luko we would be saying 'Geelong have done it again"

individual teams having to sacrifice players or multiple picks would have to be another discussion

I think a lot of people are still fixated he'll return to Adelaide

I still think he'd be open to a either staying or a move pretty much anywhere. Though I doubt he'd be that keen to be spending a lot of time at club that realistically won't least be playing finals in the shorter term

I'm genuinely not convinced he actually wants to come back to SA

 

[1970crow]

I think a lot of people are still fixated he'll return to Adelaide

I still think he'd be open to a either staying or a move pretty much anywhere. Though I doubt he'd be that keen to be spending a lot of time at club that realistically won't least be playing finals in the shorter term

I'm genuinely not convinced he actually wants to come back to SA

Bit like Gibbs in that he didn't have any desire to leave Carlton. Circumstances conspired.

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

only deluded WC supporters think Barrass is worth that much. Late first is fair.

On SM-A136B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Happy to just keep him if that's all that's on offer .

 

[LoBu]

Apparently he's waiting on an offer from Port before he decides.

If Smith is worth pick 16-18 from Geelong luko is worth a third rounder.

 

[Cleric]

Apparently he's waiting on an offer from Port before he decides.

If Smith is worth pick 16-18 from Geelong luko is worth a third rounder.

Port can't offer either the salery or picks we can.
He's still deciding if he wants to stay on the Goldie or not.

 

[sunsofanarchy]

Port can't offer the picks we can

Lol a f2? That's all im hearing from crows

 

[THE_GUN]

Happy to just keep him if that's all that's on offer .

I think its gone beyond keeping
the relationship is severed

 

[Crow till I die]

Port can't offer either the salery or picks we can.
He's still deciding if he wants to stay on the Goldie or not.

They can offer him the freedom of their forward line though as port don't have anything like the forwards we do and Luko does see himself as a forward

 

[PeterSalt]

Bit like Gibbs in that he didn't have any desire to leave Carlton. Circumstances conspired.

That's a depressing memory

Sometimes wondered if he'd come a year earlier when Reid screwed up the trade if it would've panned out any better. Probably not

 

[ABAB]

Port can't offer either the salery or picks we can.
He's still deciding if he wants to stay on the Goldie or not.

They can offer a F1, would you want us to offer a F1? I wouldn't.

 

[ABAB]

They can offer him the freedom of their forward line though as port don't have anything like the forwards we do and Luko does see himself as a forward

An "ITK" Port Power poster said they will recruit him provide he plays the Westhoff role.

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

I think its gone beyond keeping
the relationship is severed

What ?
I doubt it . It's not about the extra $ its about the extra years . He is our vice captain and from the yeo interview on the radio the other day the boys are keen for him to stay .

I don't get the he is worth more than his contract .
If he was injured long term would he return money from his salary ?

 

[sunsofanarchy]

What ?
I doubt it . It's not about the extra $ its about the extra years . He is our vice captain and from the yeo interview on the radio the other day the boys are keen for him to stay .

I don't get the he is worth more than his contract .
If he was injured long term would he return money from his salary ?

Wrong thread