Rumour Jack Reiwoldt to StKilda

Remove this Banner Ad

Lacustrus said:
He's a great great player Nick, but does has his flaws. I'd even recruit him now if he was available to move.
But also concede that it is a team game, and
StKilda had a great tactical coach and quality team during their recent era , far better tha RFC in past 30 yrs, but not now.
But to infer Jack is an far inferior player is rubbish after him coming off 2 AAs and in line for a third; as he is a considerably better playmaker than Nick, and just as valuable to his team.
I always thought, if Jack was able to kick to another Jack Riewoldt , then he'd kick 50 more goals.
Btw if Nick wanted to play for us he would've welcome too.
Click to expand...
He is inferior
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Over the course of his career Nick has Jack covered in pretty much every attribute bar goalkicking accuracy and field kicking. Endurance, leadership, bravery, contested marking, playing hurt, discipline & selflessness are all in favour of Nick.
To be fair Jack's had all the flair coached out of him, denying us footy fans the full scope of his talent but that's not Nick's problem.
 
Jack looked fed up with Richmond yesterday, wouldn't blame him if he wanted out. Jack, Bruce, and McCartin make pretty tall forward line but only McCartin struggles with pace so it could work.
 
sonnywalters said:
What do you mean by 'back' in contention?
That implies you have been in contention recently.
You havent won a final since 1995 FFS. Jack will have grandchildren before you win your next one.

Having said that I dont believe the OP.
We already have Bruce, McCartin and Membrey. No need for Jack.
We need an outside mid and a rebounding defender and we will be competitive.
Click to expand...
Using your theory that nothing ever changes, moving to Stkilda would mean he would have had great Grandchildren before any chance at a flag, it has after all been 50 years and second counts for nothing, so not much point in the move is there?
 
TallyHawk said:
Jack looked fed up with Richmond yesterday, wouldn't blame him if he wanted out. Jack, Bruce, and McCartin make pretty tall forward line but only McCartin struggles with pace so it could work.
Click to expand...
Would be happy for him to leave if that's what he truly wanted. BUT IT would have to be a once in a lifetime deal from the Saints to get the deal done. .
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Lacustrus said:
He's a great great player Nick, but does has his flaws.
StKilda had a great tactical coach and quality team during their recent era , far better tha RFC in past 30 yrs, but not now.
But to infer Jack is an far inferior player is rubbish after him coming off 2 AAs and in line for a third; as he is a considerably better playmaker than Nick, and just as valuable to his team.
I always thought, if Jack was able to kick to another Jack Riewoldt , then he'd kick 50 more goals.
Btw if Nick wanted to play for us he would've welcome too.
Click to expand...
Saints are knocking on the door to the 8 far earlier than they were expected. The form they are in now they would give any of the top four a shake excluding the Hawks. Richmond are running a side project of helping Carlton players find themselves. The Tigers are in the worst position in the league with the exception of the lions going into 2017.
 
Tiger2709 said:
Using your theory that nothing ever changes, moving to Stkilda would mean he would have had great Grandchildren before any chance at a flag, it has after all been 50 years and second counts for nothing, so not much point in the move is there?
Click to expand...
Things change but you need to be at least in contention. If you cant ever finish the year in the top 4-6 you can forget flags.
At least we are making GFs regularly. We are thereabouts. You arent even in the ballpark.
 
sonnywalters said:
Things change but you need to be at least in contention. If you cant ever finish the year in the top 4-6 you can forget flags.
At least we are making GFs regularly. We are thereabouts. You arent even in the ballpark.
Click to expand...
No you're not making Grand Finals regularly and you're not thereabouts, it is not 2010, you're not even making finals regularly, in fact you won spoon number 27 two years ago.

Are all Saints supporters this delutional, you have achieved nothing except another draw full of wooden spoons in 50 years.
 
R_Grunter said:
Saints are knocking on the door to the 8 far earlier than they were expected. The form they are in now they would give any of the top four a shake excluding the Hawks. Richmond are running a side project of helping Carlton players find themselves. The Tigers are in the worst position in the league with the exception of the lions going into 2017.
Click to expand...
Sorry but your club when it is supposedly doing well is on the same amount of wins as the club you say is in the worst position apart from the Lions, Im not sure you have really thought this out, you shouldnt let your hate cloud your thinking:$
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Rumour Jack Reiwoldt to StKilda

Similar threads

Kangaroos4eva
Scandal Jack Ziebell coward punched
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
285
Views
25K
Lavender Bushranger
L
Smiley Boy
Rumour Jack Crisp
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
297
Views
35K
Engimal v3
E
Lingsface
Rumour Jack Martin is Ray Martins son
Replies
16
Views
4K
Bogart
Bogart
holybishop
Rumour Multiple GWS players are set to be suspended to start the 2025 season after distasteful costumes and skits from their post-season function
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
82K
Cyclops
C
errant bounce
Status in Question Tony Armstrong and the ABC
2
Replies
41
Views
5K
Cyclops
C
Mitchell Madness
Scandal Sfnl refusing to enforce concussion rules
Replies
21
Views
3K
Bunk Moreland
Bunk Moreland
N
It's Time to go, Simon Goodwin
Replies
15
Views
2K
The Mares Leg
The Mares Leg

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top